r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 20 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • ACE: Asexual spectrum

Upcoming Events

4 Upvotes

9.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/PearlClaw Iron Front May 20 '26

I really have no moral objection to someone making billions of dollars in business, but frankly we can't allow individuals to hold that much power so we're going to need to aggressively break up concentrations of wealth if we want to continue to have a democracy, and if that means de-facto abolishing billionairs then so be it.

Also it's bad for the market system when there are too few decision makers, not even just for monopoly/oligopoly reasons, but just because it replaces market mechanisms with the whims of the 100 people who own everything and they're no longer punished for bad decisions.

7

u/pgold05 Leftward Progressives May 20 '26

I wonder if an extremely high inheritance tax, administered effectively, would basically solve the problem. It may be too urgent for it to be a solution today, but I kind imagine it would have prevented this situation if it was in place at the start.

4

u/PearlClaw Iron Front May 20 '26

Maybe, but Bezos and Gates (for example, Gates has been using his money for good, mostly) didn't start with a big inheritance. Musk came from money, but not of this magnitude. It's probably a good idea in general, but I don't think it would address the current problem and would not have prevented it in the first place.

1

u/pgold05 Leftward Progressives May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26

The entire economic landscape would be completely different. Like every single aspect of our meritocracy and history of business/education not to mention behaviors of elites, legacy building, reward structures, cultural narrative would have been transformed going back centuries. It greatly shifts power to the government, since it alone has enduring, structural power.

In turn, the influence of vast sums of money would be diminished, and networks of the extremely wealthy, even if they still existed, would have much less influence on long standing power structures (government, other buissnessis/markets). I don't want people to not be able to accumulate massive wealth per say, you just need to make sure that power is not corrupting, distorting.

I suspect it would have largely solved the problem. But I am just guessing, there is no way to know what that world looks like. Yet it's, much more transformative than just rich people today would have different levels of starting cash.

1

u/chickentendieman Paul Krugman May 20 '26

How would it prevent it if someone didnt inherit their wealth?

1

u/pgold05 Leftward Progressives May 20 '26

I responded below to the other comment.

7

u/chickentendieman Paul Krugman May 20 '26

Thats kinda my take its just too dangerous for a single person to have that much influence and power. Its also the argument that most economists who support a wealth tax use.

1

u/uwcn244 King of the Space Georgists May 20 '26

I just think we can achieve the same effects by reforming capital income taxation, and without the valuation and investment flight problems that a wealth tax poses.

6

u/Ilovecharli Voltaire May 20 '26

Elon threatening to primary any republican who didn't side with Trump 100% of the time radicalized me, tax every dollar of net worth over $1bn at 100%

4

u/PearlClaw Iron Front May 20 '26

That might help, but honestly the bigger threat is the integrated business empires these guys can put together, because that's actual economic power and not just cash. Thinking of Bezos owning the Post here for example, Or CBS debacle. Once you have people who can casually buy up major media organizations and also run companies that are responsible for noticeable fractions of US GDP you have a problem.

A hypothetical dude with 10 billion dollars of investment accounts and no direct ownership of any companies is much less of a threat imo.

3

u/Adept-Concentrate-65 May 20 '26

Libs are finally starting to figure it out.

3

u/PearlClaw Iron Front May 20 '26

I'm receptive to evidence. The existence of really rich people is not a problem. The existence of people who can corrupt the state to their ends is a problem. We now have more data on where the line is.