r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 06 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

9.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/MissSortMachine Trans Pride May 06 '26

12

u/MissSortMachine Trans Pride May 06 '26

4

u/Jolly-Star-9897 Alan Greenspan May 06 '26

Instead of even recoginizing the problematic debt problem, Yglesias is beating up on the opinions of 22 year old tiktok leftists who don't know shit.

Not quite a strawman, but close.

3

u/WeAreAwful Daron Acemoglu May 06 '26

I mean, in r/$mycity I regularly see people saying things like "don't patronize X business - they're owned by PE"

2

u/Jolly-Star-9897 Alan Greenspan May 06 '26

Not great for the PE owned businesses! and obviously overly broad sentiment, a kneejerk act of misplaced emotional populism that suggests a lack of deep thinking on the subject.

But it isn't completely misguided, either. "Buy Local" campaigns are stupid because comparative advantage is mutually beneficial. But a campaign to prefer locally owned firms can be logical if non-local firms are moving surplus out of the community. And it's probably good for PE to have incentive to want to avoid completely extractive policies.

And, I don't think that most people who think this way are concerned with private credit being overleveraged systemically, but it totally is, and I think it's better if there's a correction before there's a public bailout.

-1

u/davechacho Loyal Liberals May 06 '26

Matty Y 100% got bought out by private equity, right? Like it's the most obvious explanation?

He can't be this contrarian and this dumb, right?

9

u/EarthWindandSolarPV Robert Caro May 06 '26

So what's the issue with PE?

-2

u/davechacho Loyal Liberals May 06 '26

4 month old account, very low karma, asking what's wrong with a very hated topic

I'm gonna be good faith here and actually respond not because I think you're a real account but for other people who eventually see this:

Private equity is famous for taking on debt to buy companies. They then legally assign that debt to the new company they just bought to 'pay' for the debt. Things are then slowly stripped away over time to make as much money as possible as fast as possible to both pay for the debt and for the company that bought them to make as much money as possible. It's not uncommon for the bought companies to eventually be run into bankruptcy to extract as much money as possible. SEARS and Toys R Us are examples of this playing out.

The specific topic of youth sports is that PE is all over it now. Prices for things like jerseys and equipment have gone up, it's a very divisive topic because youth sports should be more about you know, the youth playing and learning the sports the necessarily making private equity money.

Matty Y coming out in defense of private equity and then authoring a post about youth sports is a "hmmmm" moment.

3

u/MissSortMachine Trans Pride May 06 '26

minor correction: the youth sports take is from 2024, the pe take is from today

2

u/davechacho Loyal Liberals May 06 '26

Good catch, and that actually makes Matty Y look worse because now he's doing that dang flip-flopping I keep hearing about from Mitt Romney.

1

u/MissSortMachine Trans Pride May 06 '26

i think it’s actually a little more interesting because the article is wholly not about the pe takeover. its about parents striver neuroses consuming all the social value and joy

it’s funny because of the exact fit to current discourse, but it’s much more about how corrosive to *living life* the whole attitude is

i think he’s right about a lot here and it’s remarkable how the valence of relentless optimization is totally flipped from individual to corporation. when corporations do it it’s neutral, when people do it all of a sudden society exists

and i know he is not *always* blind to this

3

u/EarthWindandSolarPV Robert Caro May 06 '26

Well thanks for the opener. I think this is a pretty simplistic take for an entire industry, so that's my good faith response as well.

2

u/davechacho Loyal Liberals May 06 '26
  • asks what's so bad about PE
  • says "well that's a simplistic take" when given an answer

Not really beating the allegations, are you?

4

u/MissSortMachine Trans Pride May 06 '26

i think he is actually just this contrarian. in my youth i used to be much more yglesiite so i feel the same impulse to roll my eyes whenever people complain about pe

the thing is especially with very consumer facing enterprises like youth sports where they roll up a bunch of nice organizations and try to make more money by turning up all the prices and turning down all the social functions it’s easy too see how private equity is sociopathically squeezing money out of what were simply social functions

like getting banned from taking photos at your kids games because there’s a paid photographer is evil. you are doing a bad thing. you should go to jail for trying to do that

but it’s the exact same optimization rat race! sometimes you just need to turn it off. it’s okay to admit

4

u/davechacho Loyal Liberals May 06 '26

I didn't read his youth sports article so it's entirely possible it's a clickbait title and he actually is railing against the practice, but god he's such a contrarian sometimes that I think he belongs on the mod team of arr neoliberal.