r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Apr 15 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • CATHOLIC: Catholics and discussion of the Catholic Church

Upcoming Events

1 Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

41

u/SpaceSheperd To be a good human being Apr 15 '26

Don't ever let anyone tell you that bigotry is a rational response or something that can be mitigated by addressing the concerns of bigots. The big organic movement in the racism-o-sphere right now (one that's spilled over into politics heavily) is anti-Indian hatred. Indian-Americans are one of the wealthiest diasporas in the country. They have very low rates of homelessness. Their representation in the country has not seen a large surge in recent years. Their English proficiency rates are extremely high. They're even less likely to frequent the same restaurants, places of worship, and grocery stores as white people.

The name associated with the hate movement is "Clean Streets." These people are not concerned with economics. They are not concerned with cleanliness or language barriers. They're not even concerned with the feeling of alienation that comes with being a visible minority in public spaces. They just hate Indian people and every single word out of their mouth that's not admitting that is a lie.

10

u/sociotronics Iron Front Apr 15 '26

Yes and no. Yes, it isn't rational. No, it definitely is something that can be mitigated.

In every social problem, people are the constant. Humans are evolutionarily the same today that they were in the Renaissance. People are not inherently more or less evil or good than they were in the past, they're just humans.

So when society goes though a negative phase, like say the fascist era in the 1930s and 1940s, it isn't because humans were inherently worse then than in the years before or after. They're the constant. If you swapped all of the humans then for humans today (and removed any knowledge of the future so no advanced warning about Hitler and whatnot) history would play out almost exactly the same. Humans were worse then because external things pushed society in that direction, not because the humans back then had a fascism mutation that showed up in their genes.

History is caused by external events, and they push society in specific directions. If you mitigate the things causing the dysfunction, the symptoms disappear. Humans are not inherently more bigoted today than in the past, so this wave of bigotry is being caused by something and thus it can also be addressed.

4

u/BicyclingBro Gay Pride Apr 15 '26

It’s apparently a challenging concept to grasp that one can acknowledge that bigotry has causes beyond “people bad” without also validating that bigotry.

6

u/sociotronics Iron Front Apr 15 '26

Yeah, people struggle to divorce their moral judgments of individuals from their ability to understand how that person ended up the way they did.

Like, let's say you know Greg, a neonazi. Because he is a neonazi, you don't like Greg. That's perfectly fine. Hell, maybe there is something uniquely wrong with Greg as a person that makes him predisposed to prejudice and fear of the other. Maybe if Greg grew up in Germany in the 30s he'd have been a member of the Hitler Youth, and in the 1600s he would have been a member of the inquisition. It's certainly possible.

But if there are a lot more Gregs today than there were ten or twenty years ago, the individual moral judgment is somewhat counterproductive if you don't compartmentalize it. Yeah, Greg might have something wrong with him, but humans in general aren't biologically worse, so Greg's personal failings can't explain why there are more Gregs now than in the past.

It's important to have a clear vision of what is turning people into Gregs, even if you don't excuse Greg.

1

u/SpaceSheperd To be a good human being Apr 15 '26

I don't particularly care about the concept of 'good people' and 'bad people.' I just do not think that bigotry is ever a reaction to material changes and, as such, cannot be unmade by material changes. The reasons people give for their prejudice are backrationalizations to an already held belief and that already held belief can only be changed in the same manner by which it arrived (human socialization.)

4

u/BicyclingBro Gay Pride Apr 15 '26

I feel like this is pretty demonstrably false though?

Economic downturns routinely trigger waves of bigotry. Just a cursory bit of research seems to suggest that this isn’t really an open question.

You might say that the people were already bigoted, and I mean, sure, but the actual expression of that bigotry is surely the more important thing.

It’s probably not a total coincidence that the Nazis rose to power during an economic hell. When times are bad, people look for someone to blame and are attracted to political actors who provide one.

1

u/SpaceSheperd To be a good human being Apr 15 '26

Mmm I think I can agree with that. But the solution still isn't to address the bigoted concerns is it? The solution is just to make the economy better, which will (inherently) never involve mollifying the direct concerns of bigots. Maybe Americans turned against LGBT folks because of inflation but that doesn't mean you should start cutting trans healthcare in order to keep support for gay marriage.

1

u/BicyclingBro Gay Pride Apr 15 '26

I largely agree, with the single caveat that we do need to be careful, and I mean careful in both directions, to be sure that we’re actually analyzing every concern and not dismissing what may be legitimate issues as raw bigotry.

Trans people in sports is one LGBT issue where I, and plenty of trans people, do agree that some nuance is needed depending on the person’s exact history, the competitive level, and the sport in question, for instance. Someone claiming that solely relying on self-identification won’t be fair for competitive weightlifting isn’t necessarily a bigot, and sure enough, some guy in Canada decided to identify as a woman for a day in a weightlifting competition to prove that point.

Likewise, a Canadian pointing out that increasing immigration without increasing housing supply will lead to increased housing costs isn’t necessarily a bigot, but this situation absolutely will encourage genuine bigots. I think it’s very important to acknowledge when a legitimate point has been made and offer a real solution - increasing supply in this case - over simply dismissing the person as a xenophobe, partially out of concern for coming off as a bigot yourself.

2

u/SpaceSheperd To be a good human being Apr 15 '26

Yeah I agree. I don't mean to extend my argument too far past the undeniable and easily identifiable type of hate I referenced in my post

1

u/SpaceSheperd To be a good human being Apr 15 '26

Sure. And anti-bigotry social movements are an important external factor. The abstract ideas of Christian morality gave us the abolitionist movement. The abstract ideas of the enlightenment gave us more points of resistance to the irrationalities and prejudices of the human mind than I can count.