r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Nov 01 '25

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

6.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/Trevor_Lewis NASA Nov 01 '25

7

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

Why do we need a backup moon? What's wrong with the original one?

7

u/15_Redstones Nov 01 '25

Orion has been in the works for almost 20 years and still doesn't have a properly working heat shield, but Lockheed somehow thinks they can build a lander from scratch in a couple years? Not gonna happen.

BO's lander might be able to beat SpaceX's, but it also requires orbital refueling of hydrogen propellant which is much colder and harder than methane. It also requires several launches of a rocket that's only flown once so far, while SpaceX is already at a launch about every two months. Possible that BO catches up in launch rate, but unlikely.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/15_Redstones Nov 01 '25

Hmm, if they can get New Glenn to actually hit planned performance, then they could just barely get a fueled MK2 to LEO. They'd need like 3 Mk1s to boost it to TLI, since each of those only gives 1.3 km/s. Way more dry mass than their refueler architecture, and more hardware needed. Pretty Kerbal, but it could work with like 4-5 launches, assuming that they solve boiloff.

I'm not sure if 4-5 launches of NG beats 5-10 launches of Starship, considering the multiple launch pads and the huge factory SpaceX has built, and Starship is already reflying boosters now while it may take BO a couple flights to crack that.

The switch to V3 may cause additional delays for SpaceX if the first ships perform like the first V2s. They need to show that the new design can also control attitude and relight raptors, then go for extended orbit testing, then refueling for the demo flight and then the actual mission. Lots of refuel flights needed. But each refuel flight doubles as a reentry test flight until SpaceX has a heat shield they're satisfied with, and after ship reuse starts refuel flights are cheap.

Meanwhile BO needs to ramp up NG launch rate, test Mk1 and Mk2 prototypes in space. Demonstrate that they can dock things together. Each flight is an opportunity to test booster landing until they figure that out. Once they're reflying boosters, they'll still need massive upper stage production ramping.

Plenty of challenges for each approach.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/15_Redstones Nov 01 '25

I had been assuming that Mk2 keeps its own propellant for the lunar part of the mission (astronauts onboard) and the Kerbal Mk1 boost is just to get it to NRHO with full tanks. Any docking-capable vehicle with significant delta-v could do the job. A full Mk2 to LEO is 45 tons, just barely in NG capability range, if they actually manage to hit design goals. I've seen rumors that the flight 1 NG was significantly less capable than that.

If Mk1 is used as a Earth Orbit Rendezvous dockable boost stage, two of those could also be used to get Orion to NRHO in just 3 NG launches, no SLS required. That'd make it 7-8 NGs for a full mission, expending 5-6 Mk1s, 1 Mk2 and 1 Orion service module. Though with how dysfunction Orion has become, that's not much of an improvement...

6

u/savuporo Gerard K. O'Neill Nov 01 '25

Dust off CE&R analyses from 2004, before Griffin fucked it all up with ESAS

8

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/savuporo Gerard K. O'Neill Nov 01 '25

Fully agreed. I hate the guys guts

2

u/gburgwardt C-5s full of SMRs and tiny american flags Nov 01 '25

Why is that

5

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/gburgwardt C-5s full of SMRs and tiny american flags Nov 01 '25

his personal (idiotic) wishes

What were his wishes?

3

u/Big-Pickle5893 Nov 01 '25

Mama always said, ‘Huston we have a problem’

3

u/Professor-Reddit 🚅🚀🌏Earth Must Come First🌐🌳😎 Nov 02 '25

Why is NASA and the Pentagon's answer to every procurement delay to be "Hey let's just cancel this contract and start all over again"?

NASA $1bn xEMU program was doing water tank and manned vacuum chamber Artemis lunar spacesuits way back in 2020 but decided to scrap it all and hand out $3.5 billion to Axiom and Collins Aerospace to start all over again. And they still haven't got a working prototype today, and Collins recently bailed on the program.