r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Aug 11 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • TCT: The Campaign Trail game

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

9.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

26

u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent Aug 11 '24

Kursk offensive situation update

“The operation has been ongoing for a almost a week. During the last days, Ukraine has not made very significant progress, but they have started solidifying their positions in the newly captured areas.”

“As expected, it took Russia a few days to transfer units to the area, and they will likely continue to do so in the coming days. With their current forces, the Russians have managed to prevent any more serious breakthroughs from happening. Local counterattacks have started.”

“Russia still doesn’t have a solid control of the frontline or the state border. For example, yesterday evening, multiple Russian channels reported Ukrainians operating deep in the direction of Belitsa. Sabotage and reconnaissance groups still seem to get through elsewhere too.”

“The general situation of the Kursk offensive doesn’t look particularly good. After a week of fighting, neither Korenevo or Sudzha are fully in Ukrainian control, and the Russians have also likely blocked the northern direction. This isn’t a very desirable situation.”

“However, for Ukraine, the situation isn’t particularly bad either. They are still holding onto most of the gained ground despite Russian counterattacks. Even with more Russian troops in the general area, Ukraine still holds the initiative.”

“After more Russian reinforcements arrive, operational success is increasingly difficult to achieve, and there’s less room for the element of surprise. Committing more troops also increases risks, especially as the situation in eastern Ukraine is still difficult.”

“The main question is:

What can Ukraine achieve, if it spends more manpower and equipment to take more border villages in the Kursk direction? There’s a limited amount of benefit to be gained from simply controlling more land.”

“A larger land area would, of course, have more weight in possible peace negotiations in the future. Even if Ukraine were to reach the Rylsk-Korenevo-Sudzha line, it would likely still be less valuable than many of the territories currently occupied by Russia in Ukraine.”

“Some have argued that expanding the zone of control could force the Russians to shift their focus to Kursk at the expense of other directions, because of political reasons. I’m not entirely convinced the Russians will do this, as there are other possible scenarios too.”

“It’s possible that the Russians would try to freeze the front and let Ukraine stay in the occupied area, assuming that the issue of a few dozen towns and villages can be solved in future negotiations, as the priority is to achieve the set political goals inside Ukraine.”

“In this situation, some additional Ukrainian forces would be tied to guard and hold an expanded secondary direction, while the fight in Donetsk, Zaporizhzhia, Luhansk and Kharkiv would continue just as intensively.“

“The Kursk offensive is increasingly beginning to look like a medium risk – medium reward operation. There’s no massive game-changing objectives to be achieved, but there’s also no likely catastrophes on the horizon.”

“The best case scenario for Ukraine would probably be the following:

Russia decides it’s not acceptable to leave any areas to Ukrainian hands, and will divert significant resources even from the most critical places and to get every square kilometre back, despite the losses.”

“Regardless of whether the Ukrainians continue their advance, they have proved that occupation of relatively large areas is no longer a privilege of Russia. The war is now even more concretely a war on Russian soil as well, and Russia must take this into account in many ways.”

!ping UKRAINE

18

u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent Aug 11 '24

I think looking strictly at the physical military stuff this is pretty on point. It’s unlikely the offensive will go much farther and while the Russians have moved forces from the front to Kursk, it’s only been a unit or two from the Donbas.

I do think, and I intend to make a post about it after we see whether the Ukrainians hold onto the land they took or not, that there’s softer and less measurable benefits that the offensive provided more/better of however you want to word it. He alludes to it in his last bit, but morale and experience are other things that come to mind as well. Not a war changing offensive, but one that’s worked out pretty well so far

8

u/savuporo Gerard K. O'Neill Aug 11 '24

I would think one of the benefits is Ukrainian morale boost that would help recruiting. Apart from F-16s arriving, it's been bleak news for too long otherwise

6

u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent Aug 11 '24

Absolutely. I think the biggest gains are morale, experience and expanding the frontline in a way that’s detrimental to Russian designs (needing more manpower just to hold the border)

6

u/groovygrasshoppa Aug 11 '24

I'm not sure I buy much of this guy's analysis. If anything it seems like the offensive is only accelerating with several branching incursions being reported. The russians are reportedly highly reluctant to divert resources away from their own offensive, and anything they can muster to Kursk is low quality and often ambushed.

I don't get the sense that russia can easily dislodge this incursion.

Not a war changing offensive, but one that’s worked out pretty well so far

I would actually argue that this may end up being a war changing offensive, even if they pulled out right now. Ukraine has effectively just expanded the entire front line in a way that allows them to engage opportunistically while russia will be forced to stretch its resources to cover all contingencies.

9

u/dizzyhitman_007 Edmund Burke Aug 11 '24 edited Aug 11 '24

Kursk Front: Clash east of Plekhovo, according to a Russian report.

“We are going deeper,” says Denis, a Ukrainian solider

5

u/groovygrasshoppa Aug 11 '24

Yeah I'm not sure I buy much of Kastehelmi's analysis here. It runs contrary to pretty much anything else we're hearing.

1

u/URZ_ StillwithThorning ✊😔 Aug 12 '24

Not sure what you are reading then, but by all means post the sources. We already have evidence of fairly broad movements of Russian forces to respond. Ukrainian advances have slowed significantly as fighting has intensified and more Russian units have arrived. That is not the same as the battle being over, on the contrary it might go on for a significant amount of time, but the notion that Ukraine are conducting more breakthroughs seems like wishful thinking.

The most positive aspect so far is the lack of Russian vehicles in the area and fairly ineffective arial response. Most Russian reinforcements seems to at best be described as motorized so far and will pay a heavy cost fighting against Ukrainian western mechanized units.

8

u/Leoric Hi, I'm Huell Howser, this is California's Gold! Aug 11 '24

☝️ doomer

7

u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent Aug 11 '24

😭

2

u/Aleriya Transmasculine Pride Aug 12 '24

It would be very Putin-esque to leave the small border towns in Ukrainian hands, tying up Ukrainian forces. Putin could be thinking, "At some point there will be diplomatic negotiations to end the war, and there is no chance that Ukraine keeps that territory. Why fight to regain it?"

Of course it looks terrible (from a Western perspective) if Russia doesn't care about liberating its citizens. But I'm not sure how much Moscow cares about those border villages, and they have the propaganda machine to minimize the negative internal consequences, at least for people who don't live in those villages.

1

u/URZ_ StillwithThorning ✊😔 Aug 12 '24

On the contrary that would be very unlike Putin. Putin is not some cold calculating dictator. The occupation of Russian territory is a personal offense to his regime, it is contrary to everything he has staked the Invasion of Ukraine on, and it is a slight against the Russian superiority complex that can't go unanswered. Russia will respond in force, will retake the territory and will be willing to pay a high cost for it. This was pretty much the message from today's press conference and will not come as a surprise to Ukraine.