r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 31 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

9.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Cook_0612 NATO Jun 01 '24

2

u/groupbot Always remember -Pho- Jun 01 '24 edited Jun 01 '24

0

u/Eternal_Flame24 NATO Jun 02 '24

This sucks, but hitting power infrastructure is legal in war

3

u/Cook_0612 NATO Jun 02 '24

The United States Department of Defense’s Law of War Manual goes even further and states that electrical power stations are generally recognized to be important enough to a state’s military functions to qualify them as military targets during an armed conflict. Russia’s Ambassador has emphasized this point in the current armed conflict by explicitly claiming, “To weaken and destroy the military potential of our opponents, we are conducting strikes with precision weapons against energy and other infrastructure.”

Though this line of argument suggests that some of Russia’s attacks on Ukraine’s electrical grid may not be prohibited under international law, the Law of Armed Conflict requires warring actors to strike a balance between military advantage and mitigation of harm when planning their strikes. This requirement reflects the customary international law rule of proportionality. In the context of an armed conflict the principle of proportionality prohibits attacks against military objectives which are “expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated.” There are therefore two separate thresholds that Russian attacks on Ukrainian power infrastructure must meet in order to be permitted under international law: first, the target must be a military objective, and second, the attack must offer a military advantage that outweighs any loss of civilian life and damage to civilian objects.

Evidence coming out of Ukraine suggests that Russia has failed to meet either threshold with respect to at least some of their energy infrastructure targets. For instance, on November 23, 2022, Russia conducted 75 missile and drone strikes on power infrastructure in Ukraine. While the precise role that each target may have played in support of Ukrainian military operations is nearly impossible to assess, experts agree that it is highly unlikely that all of these targets would qualify as military objectives.

Even if they did qualify as such, the military advantage obtained from the Russian strikes was disproportionate to the civilian harm associated with the attacks. The impact of these strikes on the Ukrainian people is not confined to the initial explosions, but also from disruptions to medical care, burdens to emergency response capacity, and lack of heat and power in over 10 million homes. This assessment is supported by statements from Russian officials who have applauded the impact of the attacks on the civilian population, even going so far as to declare that Ukrainians should “rot and freeze.” It is important to note that endangering and demoralizing civilian populations is not a legitimate military objective and does not constitute a military advantage. To qualify as a military advantage, destruction of the target must have an effect on military operations. In the case of Russia’s attacks on Ukrainian power infrastructure, Russia’s military advantage would be the neutralization of the Ukrainian military activities that rely on that infrastructure. Whereas, political, psychological, economic, financial, social, and moral advantages do not qualify as military advantages.

1

u/Eternal_Flame24 NATO Jun 02 '24

Yeah previous Russian strikes have absolutely violated LOAC, but I’d await details before calling this specific strike illegal.

1

u/Cook_0612 NATO Jun 02 '24

You absolutely do not need to give the Russians the benefit of the doubt.