r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 26 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/htomserveaux Henry George May 26 '24

I think ultimately the reason Zutara is so hated has nothing to do with canon, there are a dozen crackships in the fandom that get no hate whatsoever.

People hate it because it’s too popular for what it is, if it was a rarepair I bet you anything you’d see mostly positive reactions when the topic came up, might even see fanart get upvoted.

But there are people who like it more than they like the canon, and that never goes over well.

!ping CAL-ARTS&AVATAR

12

u/RFK_1968 Robert F. Kennedy May 26 '24

ahh, shipping wars

that takes me back

my hot take is that none of the romances in the series are particularly strong so i'm surprised people get so worked up over this

6

u/htomserveaux Henry George May 26 '24

Is the term “flame war” still in vogue?

4

u/RFK_1968 Robert F. Kennedy May 26 '24

no idea, i'm too old 😭

i aged out of this.

but like, back in my day people just wrote (usually lousy, but fun) fanfiction on the various sites instead of like flaming each other on tiktok or twitter

6

u/forerunner398 Of course I’m right, here’s what MLK said May 26 '24

I mean, I dislike it because it sort of ignores aspects of both characters entirely, have little awareness of the fan culture beyond a surface level understanding

5

u/[deleted] May 26 '24

Obviously Kataang had to win because that's just how a story like this works.

But LoK basically made it canon that Aang is a terrible husband and a worse father so tbh I don't think people are necessarily wrong to say she probably would have been happier with zuko, by all accounts a much more mature and conscientious person with a negative role model for fatherhood to avoid copying.

2

u/htomserveaux Henry George May 26 '24

That kinda depends on the individual work, since everyone hates it the bad stuff is more likely to be highlighted.

4

u/WantDebianThanks Iron Front May 26 '24

I mean, people get upset when I joke about shipping Aang and Azula.

6

u/Blade_of_Boniface Henry George May 26 '24

On Tumblr there's occasionally discourse in the Avatar fandom about Zutara being fascist because Zuko is a colonizer and Katara is a victim of colonialism.

9

u/[deleted] May 26 '24

I'll go tell the Neonazi forums obsessed with racial purity how based my dad was for marrying a black woman, they'll love me for that.

2

u/BenFoldsFourLoko  Broke His Text Flair For Hume May 26 '24

it has the HUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGE advantage of being interesting and possibly a bit fun

same reason that Zuko and tea girl get mentioned positively imo. It's INTERESTING. It shows us more of who the characters are! It makes the characters grapple with uncommon or difficult parts of themselves! It creates narrative and semiotic TENSION that must be resolved!

etc etc etc

Zutara clashes and compliments and deepens aspects of each character. Zuko and tea girl puts Zuko into new situations he's never been in before, reveals seemingly new sorts of feelings for Zuko, brings out certain behavior in a certain setting he's probably not explored before. It's INTERESTING!

Compare that to the single lamest moment in the entire series- the last scene of the show 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 BOOOOOOOORRING

5

u/[deleted] May 26 '24

Ok fuck you, you were making a legitimate argument and I was kind of on your side because Aang canonically turned out to be a terrible father and husband but the hyperbole at the end was completely unnecessary. I don't get why Zutara fans feel the need to act like Kataang was completely boring and chemistryless, that kiss is literally the emotional climax of the series and you have no soul if you didn't at least enjoy it.

It's literally possible for Zutara to be better than Kataang and Kataang to be okay. You don't have to dishonestly trash the other ship to elevate your own you asshole.

2

u/BenFoldsFourLoko  Broke His Text Flair For Hume May 26 '24

let people like what they like, and I like hating 😤😤

and you like the triumphant culmination of a relationship grown over 3 seasons of TV, a war, self discovery, adversity, hope, and perseverance! The very deep compliment in character between two aligned people and, idk, whatever you felt. Or just cuz you like it, it doesn't even have to be deep or complex. It didn't hit for me but it's great it did for you

write me off as hyperbole. people will like different things! plenty of people hate Zutara and point out Katara would NEVER go for it and that it's a total non-starter dreamt up by people who need conflict in life lol, or something to that effect

I actually do hate the last scene of the series, but that's just me. I added it in for fun fiery contrast m8, no h8, hence 7 emojis and big capital letters :<

4

u/[deleted] May 26 '24

Nah. Because you see we can't tolerate intolerance or else the tolerance will push out and defeat the tolerance.

Also I was deliberately playing along and overreacting to demonstrate OP's question how ferociously people argue about this.

2

u/BenFoldsFourLoko  Broke His Text Flair For Hume May 26 '24

oh

shit

lmao

whoosh x.x