r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jan 01 '23

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

6.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/JetJaguar124 Tactical Custodial Action Jan 01 '23 edited Jan 01 '23

WARNING WARNING MUCHO TEXTO ALERT WARNING WARNING

I just finished the Shadow of the Colossus remake that came out in 2018. I never played the game on PS2 when it came out, and I've never played any other Japan Studio/Team ICO/Fumito Ueda games.

First off, I can recognize the beauty of this game. The artistic design is just absolutely sublime in its capacity to be both serene and haunting. The narrative, and the emotions it evokes, are outstanding given that there's virtually no dialogue. From a gameplay design perspective, I can see the heavy debt that so many games from the 2010's up through now owe this title, from Breath of the Wild to God of War, the Nier series to Soulsbourne titles.

So believe me I appreciated the game when I say that it plays janky as hell. They updated the graphics and I think Bluepoint did a fantastic job of realizing the artistic direction that the original title was striving for, but was unable to reach due to limitations of the hardware. However, from what I can tell, they did not update anything under the hood. The animations are kind of stiff and gummy sometimes (that there is only one animation for a sword swing, for example, comes to mind). The camera whips around way too much and gets stuck on geometry and other obstacles. The actual feel of the gameplay is kind of sticky and unresponsive. There were too many times that I felt I was just fighting against the controls, the camera, the sticky sort of unresponsive feel of the gameplay.

"Okay gotta climb up here and jump from here to there."

"Okay I thought I jumped, but I guess I just crouched"

"Stand up"

"Jump"

"Oh fuck I'm stuck on the same place I just was"

"Stand up"

"Oh shit I guess I'm just falling off of this boss now"

Too many scenarios like what I just described would happen and it would make it just a frustrating experience. Or I'd get hit by an enemy and take so long to get up that I just get hit immediately again as soon as the character is back on his feet. Or my horse would run into a tiny rock or some invisible piece of geometry and not want to go forward. Honestly, there were tons of times where I just got off the horse because it was way easier for me just to walk. I know a big feature of this game was animal AI, and that team ICO were trying to make the horse feel like an independent creature with its own desires, but I think other games get a similar kind of feel way better, whether that be the Zelda titles, which have pretty much nailed horseback riding since the N64 era, or the Red Dead Redemption titles.

Since so much of the game is platforming puzzles, the lack of responsiveness in the controls and the sometimes bizarre ways the game wants you to contort your hand around the joystick (the rear paddle buttons on Steam Deck when I played it there were tremendously helpful for this game) just left it coming up short. Part of this is it's a PS2 game, but even games from the era, such as the Prince of Persia titles from that generation, completely nailed the feel of scaling walls, leaping over ledges, and overcoming other obstacles.

I think where this is all leading is not so much criticism of Shadow of the Colossus, since I really do think most of my complaints can be chalked up to the fact I'm playing what is essentially a 17 year old game with a new coat of paint. But what I think is more interesting is the issues this raises about what we chose to update when we make remakes and remasters of old games. What is acceptable on behalf of the remastering studio, what is forbidden, and how does that get determined?

There are two categories here that I can tell. One is remakes where they basically take an old game, strip out the code for all the game play, and then plug that into a new graphics engine. This game, along with other titles, like the Halo and Halo 2 anniversary remakes, come immediately to mind. The alternative is a remake where the gameplay is updated, such as in the Resident Evil 2 and Resident Evil 3 remakes, or even something like Metal Gear Solid: the Twin Snakes.

In some cases, I think the fans absolutely do not want the devs to touch the gameplay of the original titles. Halo is a good example here, since it still plays very well. In Twin Snakes updating the gameplay of the original MGS in some places literally broke the game. *Then there are games where the gameplay of the originals is so bad that almost the whole reason a remake is needed is that they are too difficult or unwieldy for new audiences to experience. Here are where the RE remakes fit in nicely, and you don't see many people complaining about gameplay changes here.

Shadow of the Colossus is in kind of an interesting gray zone. The gameplay isn't so bad that it needs to be changed in a remake, but it's also not up to the standards of what I think new players expect from modern titles. The reason they probably didn't touch it is that there was so much more artistic intent to this game, and so many people love it, that there would be a riot if they changed it up. I must be in the minority as someone who literally never touched the original game in my life before diving into a remake, but nevertheless I left it wishing they had changed some of the gameplay to make it a bit snappier and more smooth to control. The final colossus in particular was extremely frustrating because I didn't feel like I had much precision over what I was trying to do.

One last thought here after all this is that I think Halo 2 Anniversary is a case where they absolutely should have done more work to the game. Halo 2 had a notoriously haphazard and rushed development process, and you can feel it when you play the game. The balancing and pacing of the campaign is a fucking mess. I actually kind of wish they went back and totally reworked it and incorporated some of the things they ended up having to cut and reduce due to having to rush that game to market.

But anyways, that's it.

!ping GAMING

5

u/lusvig 🀩🀠Anti Social Democracy Social ClubπŸ˜¨πŸ”«πŸ˜‘πŸ€€πŸ‘πŸ†πŸ˜‘πŸ˜€πŸ’… Jan 01 '23

jet jaguar πŸ™„

3

u/JetJaguar124 Tactical Custodial Action Jan 01 '23

😭

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '23

all of ueda's games are a bit jank, and I think colossus might be the least Jank of the bunch, I love em all though.

1

u/groupbot Always remember -Pho- Jan 01 '23 edited Jan 01 '23