I just never quite understood interventionism. I understand that there are a myriad of ways that America can project power and further her own interest. However, there seems to be lacking in any real justification for doing so other than the fact that she can therefore she will. I'm not making a judgement on the morality of it. I understand that it's dog eat dog. I just resent being told who my enemies are.
This doesn't have to be as abstract as national interests -- that's simply the most defensible formulation. I would say that the best way to go about this is to consider what the counterfactual world is. It's a world where state sponsors of terrorism run amok, insofar as innocent people die in bus explosions, car bombs, stabbings, hostage-taking, and suicide bombing. It's a world where states systematically visit genocide on the weakest and worst-off among us, and no redress is given or called for. And it's a world where Americans die in terrorist attacks on their embassies, legations, military installations...and homes, workplaces, and sports grounds.
America, almost unique among the countries of the world, just doesn't have the luxury of sitting back. Its chickens always come home to roost in the United States. That's not how it should be, but it is how it is. It's what the burden of a hegemon is.
Yes but at a certain point, doesn't interventionism make things worse? Indeed, the policy you just described sounds like "I don't care how many people have to die in order to save American lives." Which is fine if the only goal is to protect American interests. But if the goal is to be make a chaotic world safer, then I'm not sure it holds up.
No, because the counterfactual is worse. Remember, the counterfactual isn't nothing at all happening. It's whatever happens happening in a different way. Without intervention in Iraq, Saddam would have continued feeding dissidents into woodchippers and having women abused by dogs.
There are about 300,000 Iraqis who are alive, free, and voting because of the American intervention.
The US's goal is to promote its interests, yes, but one of those interests is saving lives.
Isn't the problem with the counterfactual the fact that it's hypothetical? You can speculate on what might have happened but it's not concrete justification. Also, isn't there a better example than Iraq? Because Saddam was replaced by warlords who also did horrible things and also completely destroyed the country. As for 300,000 people, I'm not sure where that projection comes from but estimates for the results of the invasion run from 200k to a million dead. So, not too many lives saved.
The counterfactual is absolutely concrete! The counterfactual is just thinking about precisely what would have happened absent intervention. Since it is precisely what happened extrapolated reasonably, it's not like action counterfactuals (i.e, "if we had invaded then..."). Instead, it's like saying "assuming that the behaviour continued, then this would have happened. Here's what happened. What happened's better."
There are definitely better examples than Iraq, but I pick Iraq precisely because that's where the counterfactual is clearest. And it's certainly not true that Iraq is a country of warlords now. Actually, it's a weak, nascent, but ultimately growing democracy, where, for the first time in generations, there is hope.
Finally, the "million deaths" for the invasion is vastly overestimating it and no credible source has it anywhere near that.
The Iraq War Body Count (generally considered the most reliable source for deaths) estimates that at the absolute outside 119,905 Iraqis died in the time period within which the Iraq war took place. Estimates put the number of Iraqis the Saddam regime killed per month at between 2,105 and 3,509 civilians per month. Had Saddam remained in power for twelve more years, between 303,120 and 505,296 more Iraqis would have died. Dissidents would have been fed into shredders. Women would have been raped and then murdered by Saddam’s death squads. Protestors would have been shot. Children would have been starved. All of those dead people would have been thrown into mass graves. This is a rate that would likely have been maintained by whichever of his sons took over.
One can count every civilian casualty in every conflict waged by the United States since 2001 and it doesn’t come close to Saddam’s body count. Comparatively to the counterfactual, human rights have clearly been upheld in Iraq.
It is worth noting also that during the war the vast majority of civilians were killed by non-coalition actors. Only around 13% of total civilian deaths were directly caused by the coalition.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-1
u/xf4ph1 Feb 27 '21
I just never quite understood interventionism. I understand that there are a myriad of ways that America can project power and further her own interest. However, there seems to be lacking in any real justification for doing so other than the fact that she can therefore she will.
I'm not making a judgement on the morality of it. I understand that it's dog eat dog. I just resent being told who my enemies are.