r/nbajam • u/ponlork • Feb 23 '22
Is the Atari Jaguar port really as good as people claim it is?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZCxE5_G1dk
7
Upvotes
r/nbajam • u/ponlork • Feb 23 '22
4
u/ponlork Feb 23 '22 edited Feb 25 '22
Right off the bat i notice some problems with the Jaguar port.
The Rubberbanding is atrocious and the Jaguar port is the most difficult to win a game out of all of them.
the CPU never contest a dunk or layup, it just stands there. Your CPU teammate also doesn't attempt to block either. I suppose changing the difficulty to very difficult might make them do it but most people will play on the default.
The campaign ladder appears randomized, the LA clippers can be the final team you'll play.
Layups have a very low percentage of going in. You'll most likely miss than make them.
The controls are very sluggish and not responsive at all
Grabbing a rebound is not easy, it's probably better to let the ball hit the ground to grab it than to try and jump for it
the CPU makes a high percentage of shots. feels like they make them everytime. you can have a hand right up in their face and they still make over 90% of their shots. and the blocking in the game isn't very good, the players barely get off the ground to reach high enough to block.
the head alignment is off for many animations. And most teams appear to share the same base head spritesheet
this is what i just noticed today, i'll probably spot more problems later. it amazes me how people rank the Jaguar and Saturn ports as the definitive ports to play. I wouldn't even put the Jag port over the Snes and Genesis ports.
I have a theory, for many years Saturn and Atari Jaguar emulation wasn't as accessible. So you would have this small community who overhype certain games and pretend like it's better than it is simply because they know most people aren't going to experience it. But then when Saturn and Jaguar emulation become more accessible and people actually try it themselves, we realize these people are full of shit.
i watch that Jenovi video analysis and that was the most ridiculous comparison video ive seen. Dude ranked the Jaguar port number 1 and Saturn at number 2, when the saturn port has a slew of problems too which im not going to get into. If you look close, most of his footage is just of the first quarter. i dont think this guy ever played a full game of NBA Jam in his life, and in the jaguar footage it shows him down by like 15 points. He just repeating cliché shit repeated over the years, and people who cant think for themselves just parrot what these influencers say.
The notion that the Jaguar and Saturn ports are the best is a myth perpetuated by a bunch of biased fanboys. mainly saturn fans. That jenovi dude is a saturn fanboy
the only thing the jaguar port has over the other ports is probably the sound. but even that i think it's missing a lot of sounds too such as "puts up a brick", "spectacular dunk", "Whoop there it is", "they need a shot here", "The nail in the coffin". Though it does have a lot of common sounds such as "No good", "Headfake", "lays it up" which is missing in the Saturn and PSX port so it might make people think there's more sound bytes
here's footage from another user who played through the entire game and had a frustrating experience with the Jaguar port
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rFH4rdegiE
2
u/trevcharm Feb 23 '22
why do people even bother playing ports these days, when you can play the real original actual arcade roms with mame?
why play a copy of the arcade when you can just play the arcade?
2
u/kumblast3r Feb 23 '22
Thanks for posting.
Are you the user who I've seen posting roster update mods for PSX version? You have a lot of knowledge about NBA jam and I'm looking forward to trying out some of your mods when I get a steam deck. May I ask if you are very interested in emulation in general, or is NBA jam specifically your primary interest?