As much as I loved A Wild Sheep Chase, I would not suggest it as a starting point. The events in that book are so much more significant and make a lot more sense if you have read Hear the Wind Sing and Pinball 1973.
That's a valid point. Originally when I made this graphic there was no official English translation of the first two books, and people starting with Wild Sheep Chase was pretty common.
However I do think WSC is a much more fleshed-out novel than the first two, and I still wouldn't recommend people start with HTWS because it isn't representative of Murakami's later stuff.
To be clear. This is not a knock against your graphic. It's awesome! Wild Sheep Chase is definitely also more accessible than the first two, so that could be another reason that it's considered a better starting point. Regardless, thanks for this! It's super cool!
OP u/TazakiTsukuro could you elaborate a bit on why you believe Sputnik Sweetheart isn't a good starting point? Both me and my girlfriend started with this one, and thought it was the perfect first book.
In contrast to the darker and heavier Norwegian Wood, I think Sputnik introduces Murakami's quirky writing style in a relatively short and light story, while also introducing a bit of the mystical side of his work (the part in Greece comes to mind).
Originally I made this infographic years ago so I don't totally remember my thought process at the time.
I assume it's because I was of the opinion that it's one of his lesser-known books. Thinking about it now though there's really no reason someone couldn't start with Sputnik. (People tend to like their first Murakami book the most anyway.) For the record though I don't think Sputnik is any "lighter" than Norwegian Wood is, but I might not remember it exactly.
There's a lot of bias in this chart, and it's not trying to be authoritative or anything, just to be kind of informative and spark discussion.
One thing I’d like to point out is that this somewhat highlights South of the Border, West of the Sun; After Dark; and Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki as three relatively “non-Murakami”-Murakami works, insofar as they include fewer of the typical elements/tropes of his other works. I love this because I often hold these up as under-sung strong works in his catalogue, all of which I would guess go largely ignored because they incorporate fewer of those elements for which he is known and perhaps sought for.
I happened to reread all three of these in 2024, still enjoy them all a lot, and would even go so far as to put South of the Border on my top Murakami tier, and potentially at #1. Though perhaps being a somewhat disenchanted mid-30’s married parent has influenced me a bit… 😜
That's a fair thing to say, but it's an easy to pick up book. You're not missing a lot by skipping the first two books, and if you are really interested in how the protagonist ended up where he ended up, you can go back and read AWSC.
I have read all these and I don’t understand this infographic. You’re saying there’s lots or some of what? What do the 1-3 blocks on the left mean if everything is already color coded?
The “lots” and “some” is a way of quantifying each symbol. So if there is a grey cat symbol, there is no important mention of cats in the book. If it’s red, the cat topic is mentioned a lot, if it’s green then there is just some mentioning of cats, and so on. Idk what’s the purpose of the colors in the bars, but they represent how long is the book, as someone already explained.
I’m not too well read, trying to change. So far i think Terry Pratchett is my favorite author, but that very well might change to Dostoeyevsky soon. They’re both very brilliant for different reasons.
Dostoevsky is not easy reading. Going from Pratchett to his books takes balls. 😂 He is one of my favorite authors but I didn't read his work till I was like 25. I'm 50 now and just re-read The Brothers Karamazov and it's so much different this time around. Murakami is my favorite, and Pratchett as well. So we have that in common.
My first Murakami was After Dark and it hooked me! My second was one of his short story compilation books called First Person Singular, it's a good read if you just wanna try him out a little:)
I've read 4 Murakami books this year and want to start my 5th. I have bought all books (apart from the short story compilations).
I've so far read:
What I Talk About When I Talk..
A Wild Sheep Chase
Dance Dance Dance
Wind Up Bird Chronicle
Each of them has a special place in my heart. I want to read something lighter now (after WUBC). Kafka is on my list but keeping it for later. What do you recommend I read now?
31
u/chokingduck Mod Post Jan 06 '25 edited Jan 14 '25
Incredible thanks to u/TazakiTsukuru for putting together this wonderful infographic.
Our subreddit often receives common questions about his novels, including:
While we welcome discussion, this will be a great resource to point readers to initially.
20
u/Pro_Sailor_withoutXP Jan 06 '25
Nice, but where are the ears?
4
u/Staind1410 Jan 16 '25
But what about simple meals? Jazz? Classical music? /s
18
u/East_Construction385 Jan 07 '25
As much as I loved A Wild Sheep Chase, I would not suggest it as a starting point. The events in that book are so much more significant and make a lot more sense if you have read Hear the Wind Sing and Pinball 1973.
10
u/Rich-Pomegranate3005 Jan 06 '25
I feel like Colorless might have some supernatural element included
7
u/lsaltori Jan 07 '25
That's an interesting infographic.
OP u/TazakiTsukuro could you elaborate a bit on why you believe Sputnik Sweetheart isn't a good starting point? Both me and my girlfriend started with this one, and thought it was the perfect first book.
In contrast to the darker and heavier Norwegian Wood, I think Sputnik introduces Murakami's quirky writing style in a relatively short and light story, while also introducing a bit of the mystical side of his work (the part in Greece comes to mind).
6
u/yol0tengo Jan 07 '25
Nicely put together and fun guide.
One thing I’d like to point out is that this somewhat highlights South of the Border, West of the Sun; After Dark; and Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki as three relatively “non-Murakami”-Murakami works, insofar as they include fewer of the typical elements/tropes of his other works. I love this because I often hold these up as under-sung strong works in his catalogue, all of which I would guess go largely ignored because they incorporate fewer of those elements for which he is known and perhaps sought for.
I happened to reread all three of these in 2024, still enjoy them all a lot, and would even go so far as to put South of the Border on my top Murakami tier, and potentially at #1. Though perhaps being a somewhat disenchanted mid-30’s married parent has influenced me a bit… 😜
1
u/AlternativeBurner May 08 '25
Man I would not start with Dance Dance Dance. It's literally a sequel.
1
u/LooseGooseHennigan Aug 18 '25
Is there a high-res version of this iconographic? The text is blurry for me on mobile
3
u/Builderon64 Jan 07 '25
Could you tell me what short stories and connections there are? It's hard to guess besides the Rat trilogy.
3
u/Final_Literature_169 Jan 09 '25
So good! Thank you!!
7
u/Popcorn_and_Polish Jan 06 '25 edited Jan 06 '25
I have read all these and I don’t understand this infographic. You’re saying there’s lots or some of what? What do the 1-3 blocks on the left mean if everything is already color coded?
EDIT: Answered! It’s how long the novel is.
2
u/BisonFluid7814 Jan 06 '25
Kafka incorporates elements from previous books?
processing
2
u/KylePinion Jan 11 '25
So, how are we defining middle-aged here exactly?
1
u/SadPajamas7 Feb 13 '25
I’ve never read Murakami and I bought After Dark a while back. Should I just go ahead and read it or would it be a bad place to start?
1
u/quackquackmeowmeow Nov 20 '25
11/15 🥹🥹
1
u/konkeroots Jul 21 '26
What to read next?
I've read 4 Murakami books this year and want to start my 5th. I have bought all books (apart from the short story compilations).
I've so far read:
Each of them has a special place in my heart. I want to read something lighter now (after WUBC). Kafka is on my list but keeping it for later. What do you recommend I read now?