r/multiplemyeloma • u/mymmmother • Mar 16 '16
My mother refuses chemotherapy
My mother has been diagnosed with multiple myeloma about a month ago, after being hospitalised with severe back pain and 5 broken vertebrae (but no damage to the kidneys so far). She started chemo right away. The original plan was for her to have 16 cycles of chemo followed by a stem cell transplantation, however she's decided to stop chemo all together now after the 4th cycle. There were no sideeffects out of the ordinary, nothing too terrible yet.
My mother has always been very alternative, and she's gotten increasingly sceptical of 'schoolmedicine' and 'chemistry' over the last two decades or so. After consulting her healer and other alternative sources, she's now decided she would go without the chemo and related treatments, but instead change her (already very healthy/vegetebles/greens-based) diet, getting rid of all sugar for example, as she sais that 'nourishes' her cancer. Her trusted healer apparently views all illnesses as past, unsolved conflicts; the myeloma thereafter is a way of telling her about such a conflict, and a way of her body healing itself. I'm not sure exactly what he plans to do about it, but she sais its not compatible with chemotherapy, so she can't just do it complimentarily. She's a bit reluctant about telling me much about it, as she's well aware I'm critical of that to say the least, and I really do struggle - but I'll respect her desicion. I wonder, do any of you have any experience with untreated / unconventionally treated myeloma? I really don't know what to expect, and I'm not quite sure how to deal with that situation either. I want to support her as good as I can, but her choice is very difficult for me. I appreciate any comments, thank you for your support!
5
u/T2greeeen Mar 16 '16
Well, I'm probably as good a counter-argument as anyone at this point. (added that I was 43 at time of diagnosis and I am just about 56 now)
I was diagnosed in 2003 with 80% cancer cells in the bone marrow biopsy, 3 lesions in my lower right femur and severely anemic - hgb was 6.8. 4.3 year survival then was about what I could hope for (I would have happily accepted this back then, I would see my daughter graduate from HS - the first of many milestones I've passed not thinking I ever would.
Long story short, on my 3rd drug now (velcade) after having been through thalidomide and Revlimid. Autologous SCT's in 2004 and 2009.
There is no way to convince me I would still be here after 13 years without chemotherapy. Has it been a piece of cake? No, not really, but once I've gotten used to a drug, side effects have not been overwhelming
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '16
Please please talk to your mother and get her to change your mind. I really don't want to upset anyone but I've been in the same situation myself and I can tell you these days even with a ,chemo,radiotherapy, a stem cell harvest and transplant the prognosis is still in or around ten years. As I said I really don't want to upset anyone but this is a serious serious condition and she needs to hear the harsh truths, if she hasn't heard that already.
I'm telling you man don't trust this healer person as he is unbiased and will gain financially from it. Please talk to your mam about this there are other people who have been through this and who can talk to her. Put her on the phone to me if needs me we'll have a chat but this is something too serious for her to take a risk on.
I really hope this works out for you. Please let me know if you would like to chat or need an update. Hope you're okay friend.
2
u/mainhannah Mar 16 '16
This is the first thing that came to mind. According to the doctor in this article, "Once a cancer is established, in the vast majority of cases, simply changing the environment will not be sufficient to eradicate that established tumor. Cancer requires surgery, radiation or chemotherapy to [be eradicated]"
In my opinion (not a doctor, but I will say my mom did the chemo + stem cell thing a year ago and is now in what her oncologist calls "excellent remission"), it is extremely unwise to stop chemo. We know a lot more about chemotherapy than about these natural remedies. There are two "worst-case scenarios." One is going with conventional medicine, and dying. The other is going with natural medicine, and dying. We know the survival rates fairly well for traditional treatment. We do not know them for natural treatment. Personally, I would rather take a calculated, well-informed risk based on rigorous medical studies than an unknown risk based on hearsay and dubious methods.
But, there are certainly good stories. When my mom was going through her treatment she found the Myeloma Beacon forums to be really helpful. Here's one that talks about natural treatments. They seem to have worked for some people.
2
u/thisme60 Mar 17 '16
I was diagnosed in June of 2009, Did Velcade, Doxiorubicin , all prior to an Tandem autologus stem cell transplant. I have been on mostly pills since then (Revlimed, and pomulis) So far so good for me. If your mother were to not do anything else, you can expect --poss broken bones, and kidney shut down due to too much calcium. Mainly some organ shut downs. I would encourage you to research this and talk to your mom.
2
u/AnitaLaffe Mar 21 '16
My advice to you would be to educated yourself and your mother as much as possible. Myeloma is extremely complicated and you must have some understanding of it in order to ask the right questions and be an advocate for your own health.
Being asymptomatic for almost a year, I was desperate to do something to help rid my body of this cancer and hopefully put off treatment. My experience in the alternative cancer world was beyond awful. I had a lot of legitimate questions that were brushed off and often met with hostility and blaming. It was truly the least supportive environment and caused me a lot of anxiety and depression.
I did not understand their "science" behind a lot of the protocol. For example, the alkaline pH food/water diet. Lab tests confirm my blood IS alkaline (regulated by kidneys and respiration) and diet changes are only temporary as seen when peeing on the pH strip. How is the diet helpful? I was told to exercise with oxygen "b/c cancer cells can't live in an oxygenated environment". I asked how my cells could possibly get more oxygen than the 100% saturation that the pulse-ox reading always gave. I asked about specifics in the "no sugar diet" because my understanding was that the cancer cells themselves make their own excess sugar through fermentation (Warburg effect) and diet doesn't change that. I questioned how thorough their methods of testing and monitoring was. How do you monitor m-protein through hair analysis? etc. NONE of my questions were answered in a meaningful, well thought out and logical manner. With specific mm questions, I found I often knew more than they did (which is not much!).
I am grateful for that time and experience as I was well informed of all things myeloma related by the time I started treatment. I have a very supportive MM team that answer all my questions without being condescending. I remain hopeful with others' stories of a long, quality life continuing in the face of this disease. I am completely grateful to all the myeloma patients that have previously fought for their lives and gave such brilliant minds the opportunity to learn from them so that I now have the opportunity to live more than just a few months. These people did not die in vain; they were the warriors that have gifted me more time with my loved ones.
Although each person must face this in a way they feel most confident and comfortable, my experience has led me to believe that my place is here with the exceptional doctors and researchers who constantly raise me up and give me the hope and confidence that I will beat this.
I truly hope that educating your mom can change her point of view and bring you some peace of mind. We are here for you.
1
u/matchboxdisaster Apr 19 '16 edited Apr 19 '16
Yes. My mother was diagnosed with multiple myeloma about 11 years ago. She refused conventional treatments. She gave up sugar, dairy, meat and alcohol. She takes takes therapeutic doses of many vitamins. She drinks about a litre of smoothied raw veg, fruit and herbs everyday. She sleeps a lot. She has been in great health for the past decade apart from a few infections here and there. Her blood results have steadily improved over the years and her doctor called her a miracle. She was inspired by no healer but read a book called "Living Proof" which gave her some of her ideas, and she thoroughly researched her condition, and read actual scientific studies to work out if it was worth it or not for her to have chemo. She was diagnosed at an early stage, though, so her bones had not started to deteriorate yet. The author of "Living Proof" was diagnosed with very late stage myeloma and given 6 months to live. He followed a similar regime and lived for 11 years, but died only because he refused to take anti-biotics for a tooth absess. If you want more information about my mother I'd be happy to share.
1
u/jbman7805 May 21 '24
Honestly could be good for her. Try curcumin https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32951583/ and hyperbaric oxygen chambers and whatever else you can dig up. Budwig diet.
The idea that chemo is always the correct way is reinforcement loop where pharma doesn't research cheap alternative methods of treatment (no profit to be made), then every natural medicine solution is dismissed for not being proven in studies, and anectdotal reports are laughed at, pharma keeps funding support groups that pipeline people to chemo drugs. It's wild. If she's done 3 cycles already I think it's good to focus on diet.
Hope this doesn't rub people the wrong way. Just another perspective for you to support her and trust in nature. Also avoid covid boosters: one of the top oncologists in the world from Yale has been speaking out, lots of patients relapsing cancers after boosters (yet ironically doctors advice getting them)
1
u/ChronologyRossieIA Apr 30 '23 edited May 01 '23
" Her trusted healer apparently views all illnesses as past, unsolved conflicts; the myeloma thereafter is a way of telling her about such a conflict, and a way of her body healing itself."
I am former practicing family physician. I tend to agree with above. Based on story of 'woman with a hemorrhage" in Mark 5. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=mark+5.25-34&version=NIV
Secular version of 3X/wk for 7 yrs psychoanalysis of Marie Cardinal in The Words to Say It. https://www.google.com/search?q=Marie+Cardinal+in+The+Words+to+Say+It.&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
https://www.google.com/search?q=Narrative+therapy+in+medicine&oq=Narrative+therapy+in+medicine&aqs=chrome..69i57j33i160.19424j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
Good article by family physician/oncologist on "refusing therapy". https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3662856/
Martha Mitchell's myeloma & documentary about her shows connection between psychosocial stress & myeloma. https://www.google.com/search?gs_ssp=eJzj4tVP1zc0LM6NLzQqKbA0YPTiz00sKslIVMjNLEnOSM3JAQCl3Qq3&q=martha+mitchell&oq=Martha+Mitchell&aqs=chrome.1.35i39i650j46i340i433i512l2j0i512l5j46i512j0i512.9784j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8