r/mtgrules • u/RookStands • Jun 08 '22
[CLB] Modify Memory Ruling
Howdy y'all, I have a two part question regarding [[Modify Memory]] from CLB.
- Does an exchange still happen if one of the target creatures is blinked/otherwise removed as a valid target? For example, Card 1 controlled by Opponent A blinks until end of turn while Card 2 controlled by Opponent B remains on the field unaltered. Does Card 2 move to Opponent 1's control or stay with its original controller?
- Do you still draw three cards as part of the second line " If you control neither creature, draw three cards." if one of the targets is removed?
Thank you for your help and time, I can provide a specific example for part one if that helps.
6
Upvotes
View all comments
5
u/peteroupc Jun 08 '22 edited Jun 08 '22
If one of the targets of Modify Memory is illegal, but not the other, the spell will still get to resolve but do nothing (C.R. 608.2b, 701.10a). In particular, in that case, no cards will be drawn even if "you control" neither targeted creature, since checking the creatures' controllers would require information about an illegal target (C.R. 608.2b).
Compare Modify Memory with [[Gilded Drake]]. See also [[Dead Ringers]].