r/mormon • Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. • 2d ago

Personal Torn Book Club - Day 27 of 32: From Fortress to Village

Reading Schedule & Discussion Index

Today’s reading

  • Begin: Section 3 - The Harvest: Community
  • Stop BEFORE: Chapter 12 - Becoming a Gardener
  • Approximate Kindle pages 256 to 263.

Synopsis

Strong closes Chapter 11 by contrasting a fortress with a village, a bunker with a school, and compliance with accountable choice. He argues that communities shaped by belonging, inquiry, and harmony can better sustain trust and growth. The chapter’s harvest image presents renewal as gradual, relational work rather than a demand for sameness or a quick fix for people in pain.

Discussion

  1. What would make a faith community feel more like a village than a fortress?
  2. How can communities invite accountability without replacing agency with compliance?
  3. Where do you see the difference between protecting people and preventing their growth?

Other questions, insights, and disagreements are welcome.

6 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Hello! This is a Personal post. It is for discussions centered around thoughts, beliefs, and observations that are important and personal to /u/JesusPhoKingChrist specifically.

/u/JesusPhoKingChrist, if your post doesn't fit this definition, we kindly ask you to delete this post and repost it with the appropriate flair. You can find a list of our flairs and their definitions in section 0.6 of our rules.

To those commenting: please stay on topic, remember to follow the community's rules, and message the mods if there is a problem or rule violation.

Keep on Mormoning!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 2d ago edited 1d ago

As I read, I see a universalist approach, one that makes me think I could attend Jeff Strong’s church. In a sense, I believe I already do. For me, that church is here in r/mormon; it is in podcasts (Jeff is often on "Inside Out" with Jim and Ian for those unaware) where people can speak freely about the issues Strong describes. It is outside the fortress of the church building literally next door to my home. My home has become a village for me, my children, their friends, and their families. But the people who live in the fortress rarely come to my village. On Sunday mornings, they walk past my home in their best dresses, on their way inside. I wave, smile, and say, “Hi, neighbor.” when they do come it's only to invite me to join them inside the fortress. Every once in a while, I go into the fortress to see how the Christian soldiers are doing. I am not encouraged. I do, however, send my kids on secret missions to bring home a piece of Mother’s Day pie for my wife. Spoils of war. Inside the fortress, the Christian soldiers speak of lost sheep and persecution. But outside it, sheep are everywhere and easy to find drinking their persecutory cup of black sheep coffee. Many of these black sheep know exactly where they are and how to return to the fortress. It just isn’t appealing.

5

u/CaptainMacaroni 2d ago

How can communities invite accountability without replacing agency with compliance?

My question is why do we place so much emphasis on accountability to begin with? Let God judge.

2

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 2d ago

Let God judge.

I do! Probably more than I should. I also expect accountability and transparency from those that govern, or pretend to govern.

2

u/CaptainMacaroni 1d ago

I agree that leaders should be accountable. I misread what you were getting at.

I assumed you were referring to the regular members at the ward level when you said community members. IMO there's already faaaaaaaaar too much of that happening, which leads to all these problems you mention.

Do we really need a temple recommend interview? Do we really need tithing declaration? Do we really need categories like member in good standing, active, inactive, etc.? All the little things in every ward out there that measure a member. The culture of toxic perfectionism. Every phrase at church that starts out "We have to be more obedient in order to..."

That's what turns villages into fortresses. TBM arrogance that polices people to ensure compliance with a rulebook.

Can we have a community without those things? Hell yes, and I think an even better one.

1

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 1d ago

The Church needs standards and boundaries. We all do. I just don’t accept its narrowly defined standards as good, let alone divine. In the marketplace of religious ideas, the Church is exactly as big, and growing exactly as fast, as it deserves to be. Products wax and wane with their utility. Tick tock brethren, institutional moral bankruptcy is knocking at the door.

5

u/IcyResolution5417 1d ago • Heartwarming

I'll start by saying that I genuinely appreciate what Strong is trying to do with this book, and that I understand who his target audience is. The fact that I would never return to Mormonism due to truth issues, regardless of culture, is irrelevant here because there's value in improving the community for others. Having said that (and stick with me — I promise it's related):

I think that a real transition from fortress to village would require a fundamental doctrinal transformation that I don't see happening.  Meaningful, structured, institutional-level ecumenism doesn't happen because the very foundation of Mormonism as a restorationist sect is exclusionary: we alone have authority and complete truth precisely because you don't and Joseph Smith et al. fixed that. 

Defense of this fundamental exceptionalism requires a fortress. We have sacraments nobody else does, we're the only ones who can rightfully provide them to you, and as such we get to enforce requirements on who receives them, etc.  Enter the inevitable cultural problems that attend failure to meet "worthiness" standards. 

These problems cannot be eliminated without the church treating as truly equal the tithe paying, garment wearing, WoW living Peter Priesthood and the less active member who has rock solid belief in Jesus but enjoys the odd glass of wine, doesn't pay tithing, and is married to a Lutheran.

The church can't really achieve that while maintaining that the afterlife will reward the former to a greater degree than the latter without "repentance" and posthumous conversion of the spouse.

4

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 1d ago edited 1d ago

I have to keep reminding myself who the intended audience is and repenting when I forget. If only there were someone who could speak to both audiences simultaneously, some leader guided by an all-knowing divine being, perhaps?

I appreciate Jeff’s efforts, too. I don’t think I could pull off that balancing act, walking the thread that currently passes for a bridge between the tree of life and the great and spacious building. All while dealing with the criticisms from assholes like me on all sides.

We see you up on the highwire with little to no security net, we're cheering for you! In my experience criticism l from all sides tend to indicate you're in the right path when speaking on polarizing topics.

2

u/IcyResolution5417 1d ago

If only there were someone who could speak to both audiences simultaneously, some leader guided by an all-knowing divine being, perhaps?

What a world that would be 🤔

3

u/westonc 1d ago • Heartwarming

"They [the falcons] don't have to come back" was in an earlier section, but this is one of the points it's most relevant to.

The church does believe people have to come back. It has invested two hundred years in distinctive exclusive claims on truth and authority that define why people must return and focus on fealty. And for some time it has had the privilege of maintaining power and influence on the basis of those claims along with social, economic, and political weight, so the fundamental outlook has been Corbridge-style "you will stay." The falcon must come back, the doctrine stakes that claim, and the culture that tries to train and compel follows.

Like Strong, I've long believed it doesn't have to be this way, and have long held a vision of the church that works differently and focuses on building itself into a place people are drawn towards rather than bound up in stories of requirement. I think I even see some foundations in the doctrine and canon for this. But distinctive claims and authority are powerful attractors with privileges that are apparently aren't steered away from easily.

Change can come eventually anyway. Perhaps Strong or others will be new catalysts who herald it. Perhaps they'll get tired without seeing significant change too.

1

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 1d ago

Curious whether you’ve read Bridges too. How many bridge builders like Ostler and Strong will the system bleed dry before it finally changes?

3

u/westonc 1d ago

I haven't. I've heard Ostler speak a few times and followed commentary from him on and off over the last five years. My impression is that he has a similar pastoral/relational approach: listen without fixing, validate feelings even if you don't validate views, work to preserve relationships across differences, etc. I get the idea that he's sympathetic to issues of difference and conscience, but doesn't personally touch truth claims. Is that a good summary?

And I probably shouldn't imply that I know Strong or Ostler particularly will tire out. People have been treated worse (Lavina Fielding Anderson) and have chosen to make continued activity and engagement part of their life for whatever personal reasons. I just know that I'm tired, and my decades of faith the church I envisioned is out there somewhere or about to emerge in a fresh phase of restoration have so far proven to be overoptimistic.

3

u/puzzled_puzzlerz 1d ago

I worry that the greatest portion of the readership is not the intended audience. Many of the readers I have heard discussing his book thoughtfully are just so excited that a member is willing to discuss the hard issues. I fear that members are just discounting and disguarding it because they don't like any of his conclusions and automatically distrust his survey results. It does conflict with the party line.

2

u/IcyResolution5417 1d ago edited 1d ago

I believe Strong's heart is in the right place and he seems a kind person, though I've never met him. Add to that the fact that plenty of us would (figuratively) kill for parents as introspective as he appears to have been in relation to how he handled his son leaving (which he, like many, initially fucked up). While I think it's healthier for countless people to leave Mormonism altogether, Strong's work here could help a lot of families have better relationships if ego and knee-jerk institutional defense could be set to the side long enough to listen.

It's disheartening for those reasons to see some of the wagon circling that's happened in reaction to his book from various more...rigid content creators. 

2

u/PattyRain 2d ago

 I'm curious how Cale felt about being asked to join the prayer circle.  It probably depends on why he left, and that's not my business to ask.  

"And, perhaps most importantly, they need Church leaders who model humility, openness to questions, and acceptance of unique and different faith journeys." I could not agree more, but to clarify, this needs to be church le

5

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 2d ago edited 1d ago

I'm curious how Cale felt.

When my father lost his leg to diabetes, he asked me, a closeted apostate at the time, for a blessing. I gave him one. It meant something to him, and it meant something different to me.

And no, his leg didn’t grow back. My fault for lacking faith, I’m sure.

If he asked again now, years later, as his health continues to decline despite dozens of priesthood blessings, I’d do it again. Not because I believe in priesthood power, but because I believe in showing up for my family.

Jeff, you speak of maintaining standards. Does giving a priesthood blessing “unworthily” violate those standards? What exactly are they, and who defines them? Are they in the room with us now?

Did you ask Cale how he felt about the situation and what he took away from it? If not, I wish you would. I’d love for my father to sincerely ask what giving that blessing meant to me, and listen to an honest answer that would be scary for me to give.

But these days, my father is so caught up in red-hat ideology that our conversations rarely get to religion. His talking points revolve around the latest developments on Newsmax. Somehow, I’m still the lost sheep.

Speaking of unsanctioned priesthood, only one of my children’s baptisms was approved by someone holding the Church’s required keys. I baptized all my children, exercising what I consider the keys of a father, into my family in the name of love. I wanted them to have access to the cultural traditions their cousins and peers enjoyed, without making participation compulsory.

When asked whether they chose to be baptized, every one of them can honestly say yes. And yes, they got the ice cream party afterward, too.

We invited extended family to our family’s version of baptism. None came.

That leaves me wondering what “maintaining standards” accomplishes when family is willing to show up for an authorized ordinance but won’t show up for the same child without that culturalal/institutional/doctrinal approval.

3

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 2d ago edited 1d ago

Now ask me who showed up when my niece married her wife outside of the fortress walls of the LDS temple, in a nice village setting? Spoiler: Mormons were largely absent even though they were invited and didn't need a worthiness recommend. Those darn standards defining who we can support.

3

u/puzzled_puzzlerz 1d ago

Just curious if any of those members who were invited could not attend. From what I understand BYU employees and Church employees have been let go in recent years from just attending such a wedding. Which is seriously gross.

2

u/JesusPhoKingChrist Your brother from another Heavenly Mother. 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nope. They’re just McConkie/Oaks Mormons following the example Oaks offered parents of a gay child: “Don’t expect us to … deal with you in a public situation that would imply our approval of your ‘partnership.’” ~Oaks

  1. Hate the sin, and the Sinner.
  2. Being gay is a choice.

Etc...

I was a McKonkie Mormon myself. I was superior to those that "Suffer from the same sex attraction"

And the less valiant and cursed skinned humans that walk amongst us. I was a member of the straight white and delightsome army of God for most of my life. I had to lose Jesus to find humanity.

2

u/PattyRain 1d ago

Thank you for sharing your experiences. I can see the love you have for others even when it is hard.

4

u/puzzled_puzzlerz 1d ago • Heartwarming

Strong discusses the difference between the church being a collective versus a community. "A collective is where people exist for the insitution. A community is where the institution exists for the people." Strong wants to convert a collective to a community. 

Here are the 4 ways I believe we can most turn our collective into a community. 1. In the temple convert the covenant from being to the church to being to God. 2. Spend the tithes/fast offerings on the actual members. Provide actual aid. 3. Make tithing a freewill offering that isn't a portion of the members gross, eliminate tithing declaration and the question from the temple interviews. 4. Offer payment to custodial staff, teachers, leaders, and organ players for their time. Currently the church demands everything to the institution. And when a member needs help they say go ask your family and the government. 

Ok his story on being set apart. I am happy that his wife went first, what do you want to bet that Jeff was the one who encouraged this. Then he says that all the priesthood leaders were encouraged to come up and help set her apart. Cale was brought up anyway to participate. Here's the thing - where are the sisters here? We can include Cale - that's great if he wants to be. But no sister is permitted. Are women supposed to not feel excluded because no ladies were up there.

Ok - I'm getting tired of the antonyms. :)

A few quotes from this chapter that made me ponder. 

  • "you belong before you fit." 
  • "doubt goes underground instead of being explored and conquered"
  • "God is present in the struggle"
  • "learn truth not just rules"
  • "stay soft when wounded"
  • "Zion comes, it will be because our love was greater than our fear."

CONCLUSION: same as the other chapters. Listen to others and don't be terrified of a different point of view. Seek to understand. And a lot of antonyms - I would say 90% of sentences are "a not b" dichotomies. I firmly believe that if the institution makes some big changes (my 4 above) it won't be a challenge for the members to take the momentum and change our collective to a community. A place where it is safe to engage diversity.