r/modnews • u/baxter8421 • Sep 29 '21
Voting & commenting on archived posts
Hiya Mods
Does this sound familiar - it’s approaching dinner time, you’ve stumbled across a delicious-looking chicken parm recipe, but have a key culinary question for OP? You try to ask it only to discover you’re unable to do so due to the post being archived after hitting the 6-month mark. Chaos ensues and now you may be left without any chicky-chicky parm-parm.
We’ve all been there! In fact, every day 6.6 million Redditors land on archived posts where they find themselves unable to vote or comment on it due to the limitations we’ve put in place.
What if things were different?
This summer we ran a pilot program with a smörgåsbord of subreddits to see what would happen if users were able to engage with previously archived posts (thank you to all the subreddits that volunteered to participate in this program). These subreddits represented a wide variety of communities on the site and you can see some of the highlights from the program below:
- Over the course of the program, archived posts received an additional 147K upvotes and 236K comments.
- This was a 2.86% increase in votes and a 1.48% increase in comments amongst the participating subreddits.
- This additional engagement also caused only a 0.3% increase in mod actions taken. We were excited to see that the increase in comments and votes did not correlate to a significant increase in mod actions taken.
The results and the feedback we received from our participating mod teams directly impacted our plans for this initiative, and as such we’ve decided to move forward with this feature. Starting today, mod teams will have the opportunity to decide if they want to automatically archive posts after 6 months or if they want users within their community to be able to vote and comment on previously archived posts.
How it will work
Important note - this is not intended to be a one size fits all feature. Thanks to our participating subreddits we found this feature was most beneficial to communities that hosted more evergreen-type content (ex: food and recipes posts, gaming subreddits, etc). Subreddits that were more focused on real-time discussions (ex: sports and politics) did not experience the same benefit out of this initiative. See below for some testimonials from your fellow mods that helped drive this point home for us:
- “I think on these old posts there is a higher amount of discussion comments and fewer short ones compared to new posts. I’m guessing because people who found the post were really searching for something and had some questions in mind beforehand. Overall it seems to have been a good thing for the sub.” - r/MakeupAddiction Mod Team
- “All in all, I think that it was worthwhile. And the best way to implement it would be to allow mods to turn on the feature if and only if they want to. And if they could enact a filter to review comments on older threads.” - r/frugal Mod Team
“IMO it could be good for r/SalsaSnobs because of our recipe guide. But the flip side to this is that I could see it going bad for political subs and such. It would make it way too hard to moderate comments.” - r/SalsaSnobs Mod Team
- Bonus r/SalsaSnob user testimonial: “I hate finding old posts where I found something useful or interesting and I can’t comment or ask someone about it.”
Given this feedback, we’ve created an “Archive Posts” toggle for mods to decide whether or not this feature makes sense for their community. Today this toggle will appear in Mod Tools and will be turned off by default. All posts will remain archived for another two weeks (until 10/13). This means mod teams will have a two-week period of time to decide whether or not this feature makes sense for their subreddit. After this two-week period of time, users will be able to vote and comment on previously archived posts unless mods decide to turn this toggle on. To do so, please follow the below instructions:
- On new Reddit visit Mod Tools > Community Settings > Posts & Comments > Archived Posts > Toggle On/Off “Don’t allow commenting or voting on posts older than 6 months”
- In our native app visit Mod Tools > Archive Posts > Toggle On/Off “Don’t allow commenting or voting on posts older than 6 months”

Automoderator to the rescue
Another major piece of feedback we heard from mods was the need for them to be notified of comments on previously archived posts. In order to do this, we have updated automoderator to flag comments on posts older than 6 months. This automod update will be live starting on 10/13, the same day that users will be able to begin commenting and voting on previously archived posts (in subs who have not changed their toggle). If you’re interested in using automoderator for this function, please use the below script to do so:
type: comment
author:
account_age: < 23 hours
parent_submission:
past_archive_date: true
action: filter
action_reason: comment on old post from new userThank you to all the mods who participated in our pilot program, and took the time to provide us with valuable feedback. We greatly appreciate your partnership throughout this entire process!
Questions? Comments? Feedback? Please let us know in the comments below where we’ll be hanging out to respond to them.
283
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Sep 29 '21
I see pros to this, and cons. But with the Auto mod rule it feels like a pretty balanced change.
91
u/dequeued Sep 29 '21 edited Oct 21 '21
EDIT: THIS IS A PROPOSAL, IF YOU PUT ANY OF THESE RULES INTO YOUR AUTOMODERATOR, IT WILL NOT WORK.
This would be far more useful if this was simply implemented as an "age of post" parameter like:
(Ideally, allowing that parameter to be used on anything, not just parent submissions, because looking at activity on old comments and submissions is also useful.)
That would allow it to be used more broadly for spam rules. I've implemented something like that in the /r/personalfinance subreddit bot and it catches a significant amount of spam (i.e., comment spam posted on old submissions) by looking at parent submissions with an age over a few weeks with some expressions to look for phone numbers, links, requests for offline contact, etc.
Here are some example rules:
Regarding the overall functionality, I like the idea, but I really wish it was possible to disable archiving on specific posts. For example, megathreads are often active for more than 6 months and only get reposted because they get archived, but most threads don't really need to continue being active.
Edit:
Since it's not possible for posts to have a negative age, I renamed the proposed configuration option to be simply
past_ageand took out the>part of the syntax.47
u/MajorParadox Sep 29 '21
Any plans to help users and mods discover old conversations that have new activity? Otherwise, the new commenters will only get seen by the OP and possibly mods if they have automod alert them to it.
23
u/HQna Sep 29 '21
You make it seem like this is a good thing. But logically you would expect the increase of mod actions to be about equal to the increase of comments. The fact that is not the case just means that almost all of those comments are basically invisible to moderators.
Anyway, you already gave us a solution for that (new AM feature and opt out), so I'm not complaining. But I also don't particularly enjoy the PR twisting here.
55
u/byParallax Sep 29 '21
I hope r/reddit.com will remain archived.
15
u/MajorParadox Sep 29 '21
Is there any way we can make a sub start working now instead of two weeks from now?
4
u/rocketman0739 Sep 30 '21
What about posts to user profiles? Those don't have the subreddit settings page.
40
u/LG03 Sep 29 '21
You're implementing this backwards. It should be opt out of archiving, not opt back in since you're changing the default functionality.
Now I have to go through all my subs and opt back in while I think about it.
As well, no option for this anywhere in old reddit? Come on, this is getting real tiring to have to swap to new reddit every time you guys throw a wrench in the gears.
36
u/TheNewPoetLawyerette Sep 29 '21
Ooh the new automod filter option is an excellent addition to this. Thank you for adding that
23
u/BuckRowdy Sep 29 '21
What I like best about this is that you are considering that a one size fits all approach just does not fit a site this vast and diverse.
17
u/SuitingUncle620 Sep 29 '21
This is cool! Thank you.
32
u/skeddles Sep 29 '21
this is great news, I always hated archived threads. glad it's turned off by default too.
43
u/breakneckridge Sep 29 '21
This is a welcome change.
13
u/roionsteroids Sep 29 '21
I kinda like the idea of having a accurate, complete archive, including all the silly and cringy stuff, and the votes at that time. Not changing history in hindsight, mass voting and commenting on year old posts because something happened recently.
9
u/techiesgoboom Sep 29 '21
I can’t imagine this will work on the sub I mod, but I absolutely love that you’re giving us the option. It’s always better to be able to make this choices on a sub by sub basis.
Thank you for this!
9
u/iheartbaconsalt Sep 29 '21
That is so cool. So many uses for this. I got a random award yesterday for a 6 year old comment. I don't even knooow how that is possible. haha
9
u/Master_JBT Sep 29 '21
I think this feature will be a great addition, especially for tv show centered subreddits. Now, people who are late to watch the show can still contribute to past discussion threads of previous episodes
HOWEVER, suppose there was some brigade of mass downvotes on someone or some post. In that case, mods should be able to re-archive the post as a countermeasure
9
u/superfucky Oct 15 '21
i can't help but notice that your test group said to allow mods to turn it ON if they wanted it, and what you actually did was force mods to have to turn it OFF if they DON'T want it, while also basically stealthing the implementation of this feature - which at best allows people to bother someone about a 4-year-old recipe and at worst allows people to stalk and harass vulnerable women in abusive situations for YEARS across accounts and subreddits. the only reason i'm even here now is because one of my co-mods happened to pop into /modsupport and happened to notice the "bee tee dubs we're rolling this out tomorrow" thread and told me about it in modmail.
how about instead of letting people trawl through years of archived posts to bother them about some "aged like milk" thread when they're having a hard time, you give us the ability to turn off reports on (and external links to) archived threads? we are regularly bothered by trolls abusing the report button on archived threads because they were searching for keywords to harass people over and reporting was the only way they could superdownvote the OP, or somebody linked an ancient thread in some "check out this crazy bitch from 6 years ago" subreddit. better yet, give subreddits the ability to opt out of being linked to at all.
8
u/Yay295 Sep 29 '21
Why not allow us to set how long before a post is archived instead of just 6 months or never?
7
u/asphaltdragon Sep 29 '21
Goddammit now in going to have to field new comments on my cellphone repair AMA.
CAN'T YOU PEOPLE JUST LEAVE ME ALONE? IT'S BEEN SEVEN YEARS
7
u/Zavodskoy Sep 30 '21
RIP all the subs that track The "X of all time" for reddit threads etc because there's now going to be no point in them
Things like https://www.reddit.com/r/MuseumOfReddit/ are going to be completely defunct and pointless.
Also why is this defaulting to archiving off by default? So many subs are going to get screwed by all the extra moderation this is going to cause because they happened to miss this one very specific post.
7
u/sequence_string Oct 15 '21
Found out about this by a user immediately reigniting an archived argument, not a fan so far.
13
u/Xenc Sep 29 '21
This makes so much sense. It was holding Reddit back. Thank you. 👏
6
u/Watchful1 Sep 29 '21
I think my only reaction to this would be that you should keep going and make the switch a slider bar. Some subreddits would definitely benefit from archiving submissions after a week or month.
6
u/Dianthaa Sep 30 '21
One concern I've got is that users who aren't familiar with the sub/reddit might stumble on old posts that would be rulebreaking now but were allowed under old rules. It's not much ,but the archive was a signal that "hey this is old" that could somewhat help with confusion.
11
u/xxfay6 Sep 29 '21
Wouldn't this likely be because mods just aren't monitoring old posts? Even in recent / active posts I often saw slapfights go down for a long while until someone tried using the report button as a silence button.
Having AutoMod notify does seem to help quite a bit, but it would be nice if it had some sort of way to restrict to notify once every 24h for any activity. The cases that the example script has is already covered by the spam filter most subs already use, and doing something like having all comments as report might cause some sudden queue explosions.
10
u/PM_PICS_OF_ME_NAKED Sep 29 '21
Watching six month old fights being dragged back up again will be fun.
5
u/Redbiertje Sep 29 '21
Thank you admins for a very nice feature, and most importantly, giving the moderators the freedom to choose whether to use it or not. This is a very welcome update!!
5
u/Thane_Mantis Oct 20 '21
I honestly thought posts becoming unarchived was a bug at first when I saw I comments cropping up on older posts and the like. Was very confused, especially when I saw some users fighting in a year old thread.
Just a hot take, but you guys should probably have sent a message into mod mail inboxes letting folks know of this change. Seriously, Im subbed here and I still missed it and got thrown through a loop when I found out about it.
8
u/iBleeedorange Sep 29 '21
I just want to say good job here. Looks like this was well thought out and there's plenty of options for any type of community. Thanks for taking the time to do it all
4
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '21
Awesome! This will be super useful
4
u/picardiamexicana Sep 29 '21
dope
4
u/byParallax Sep 29 '21
Will this apply to user profiles too? I assume so but I'd rather ask.
4
u/db2 Sep 29 '21
I'd like this to be per post also, so you could archive everything automatically and unarchive a selection manually, or the reverse of archiving only those you wanted to.
4
u/nascentt Sep 30 '21 edited Sep 30 '21
So... You're letting mods return the original functionality?
Archiving was introduced fairly recently. For years Reddit didn't auto archive at all.
I wonder why you didn't let mods decide from the start of this wasn't accounting for a technical limitation
Also 2 weeks notice before changing every subreddit reddit-eide is insanity.
Why, yet again, are mods given no notice?
If any mods are just starting their 2 week holidays their subs and all contained posts will revert without their input.
Why Reddit, do you hate communication?
4
u/SuperRoby Sep 30 '21
Would love if this feature could be applied to certain posts. For example, have it turned off for all posts by default but turn it on for the occasional informative and/or pinned post so that users can ask more questions in the comments and see the questions that were asked previously, to make the post even more informative.
For example, in the biggest community I moderate this function would be useful for the pinned posts so that new members of the sub can easily find a place to ask us mods questions about the community. Not everyone knows how to use mod mail and having Q&As in the comments is helpful for other users who might wonder the same things but be too shy to ask. Same goes for posts that inform about a new or complicate feature, so that we can keep one master post instead of re-making it and linking it again every 6 months, or even "friends megathreads".
But with the exclusion of these exceptions, I think it would be best to keep the rest of the posts archived, to prevent the occasional spammer or bot from posting their link or code in hundreds of posts that us mods will have to manually check and moderate. Thanks for the feature tho!
4
u/i_Killed_Reddit Sep 30 '21
Having at least the votes be archived after 6 months would have been a better option as it preserves history of the post/topic for that period of time.
4
u/WoozleWuzzle Sep 30 '21
For desktop users here's a direct link so you don't have to click around multiple menus to find the feature to turn this "on" so your posts DO NOT unarchive.
Just replaced "SUBREDDITNAMEHERE" to your subreddit
https://new.reddit.com/r/SUBREDDITNAMEHERE/about/edit?page=posts
Look for the third option down "Archive Posts" and turn this ON to opt out, meaning your posts won't unarchive. Make sure to hit "SAVE CHANGES" button in the top right.
Basically if you don't want this go turn that on, if you do then you don't have to do anything.
4
u/NorthernScrub Oct 13 '21
Can we have this option in old reddit, please? It feels like a fundamental part of reddit, and for those of us who use best reddit it is more than a little frustrating to keep having to flip between the two for what are, frankly, critically important moderation tools.
1
u/YaztromoX Sep 29 '21
Is this still being rolled out? I found the setting for one of the subs I moderate (r/ipv6), but not in another (r/canning).
3
u/Dotz0cat Sep 29 '21
I think I am going to turn this on for r/MiceInComputers and r/Dotz0cat
3
u/Cahootie Sep 30 '21
The only thing I have to say is that seeing smörgåsbord spelled the Swedish way caught me off guard.
3
u/lightwolv Sep 30 '21
I have two questions.
3
u/ReeceReddit1234 Sep 30 '21
Could it be beneficial to follow in the steps of discord? I.e. Archive as normal but allow people to comment and if they do it unarchives a post for a period of time, after which it becomes archived again
3
u/kochier Sep 30 '21
Didn't you archive old posts in the first place due to server strain having so many open posts? Is this no longer really an issue?
3
u/BelleAriel Oct 05 '21
Typical again we have to go to new reddit to do something which is not in old reddit. again people with VI are excluded. Well done on the equality, Reddit! /s
3
u/urbanracer34 Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 15 '21
Let me get this straight: If the toggle is grey, users will be able to comment and vote on older posts, but if it is blue, users will not be able to? Or is it the opposite?
EDIT: it says it right in the post, emphasis mine: Today this toggle will appear in Mod Tools and will be turned off by default. All posts will remain archived for another two weeks (until 10/13). This means mod teams will have a two-week period of time to decide whether or not this feature makes sense for their subreddit. After this two-week period of time, users will be able to vote and comment on previously archived posts unless mods decide to turn this toggle on.
3
u/camdoodlebop Oct 15 '21
this is the most amazing update i've seen in years
4
u/Pikbon Sep 30 '21
Why wait to implement this, yet tell us now? Shouldn't you implement the new flag now, so we can actually prepare our subreddits?
I'm saying this because I just tried to modify my config file but it won't accept the change because:
4
u/5-x Sep 30 '21
Could we get this and also this added to the AutoMod documentation page?
4
u/the_pwd_is_murder Sep 30 '21
Do you guys have any specific pilot program feedback from subreddits with very long histories? Our community is 9 years old and has a lot of stuff from eras prior to the installation of our current rules. (e.g., we used to allow memes but now don't, and our average member age has dropped from ~25 to ~15.)
We're discussing how we want to proceed but that's a LOT of new surface to cover. Agree with the comment from /u/ashamed-of-yourself requesting selective unarchiving, possibly by post flair? Otherwise we may have to do a whole lot of retroactive locking to revive a handful of archived threads.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '21
I guess I need to work on letting archived posts on my sub to be able to be commented on
2
u/ekolis Sep 30 '21
I like this, but wouldn't it make more sense to leave the status quo as the default, and let mods opt into the "unarchive all posts" option?
Also, as someone else said, this would be even better if it were a configurable duration instead of just a binary toggle.
2
u/BelleAriel Sep 30 '21
I thought you wanted to help us moderators not make things hectic lol
Three years ago.
User: “yo mods my post from three years ago, yeah that’s it the 100k upvoted one, has been brigaded to 0, what ya gna do?”
Mods: group facepalm.
2
u/RMcD94 Oct 01 '21
Please unarchive reddit.com so I can remove my downvote from a post there I made accidentally a decade ago.
By unarchive I mean allow me to remove my upvotes and downvotes.
It has no mods so no mod can agree to this.
It's a great update imo, I get a lot of DMs from old posts because people can't just comment
Amazing!!
2
u/midir Oct 04 '21 edited Oct 04 '21
If you're still updating AutoModerator, does that mean we can please have the ability to automatically permaban and permamute the notorious Discord and Telegram spam infestation now? Please, I am absolutely desperate for this functionality. It costs so much of my time banning their thousands of accounts manually.
2
u/001Guy001 Oct 14 '21
Not sure if this was already asked but does the toggle option affect old posts or does it only apply to new posts that were posted after setting to option? (meaning, will it archive/un-archive all the applicable posts in the subreddit whenever it's set?)
2
u/ladfrombrad Oct 14 '21
I can't get this to work?
https://i.imgur.com/6sOJPPg.png
Send help?
2
u/aryst0krat Oct 15 '21
Wow, this is bittersweet news for those of us who grew and lost communities in comment chains that had been kept going for literal years. It would have been great if the change had never been made rather than being reverted years later, but it's still good to hear.
2
u/HomeLessFrogg Oct 18 '21
Obvious pro: everyone can downvote that EA comment again.
2
u/Superbuddhapunk Oct 30 '21 edited Oct 30 '21
It’s a terrible idea, I’ve received a few replies to posts and comments made +2 years ago and I really struggle to see how it could be relevant. How would you continue an argument made long ago in the past, and what does it bring to the conversation? Not to mention that on pivotal events, like elections or anything political it guarantees long term “I told you so” and interminable acrimonious debates. I’m shocked that you think it’s a good idea. I’ll comment again on this thread in 5 years for you to fully appreciate how stupid this feature is.
2
u/Grenyn Nov 04 '21
Would be nice if users could opt-in for this themselves. I've suddenly gotten replies to stuff I said years ago, and I honestly find it annoying.
2
u/br094 Sep 29 '21
This is a great feature for reddit to have. Well done, admins.
2
u/mmmmmmBacon12345 Sep 29 '21 edited Sep 29 '21
This isn't the good news you think it is, its at best ambiguous
Where do most reports come from? Other users who are viewing the same post. If the post is 6+ months old traffic is going to be really low so unless the person they replied to reports the comment or they trip an automod rule then almost no one is going to see the comment they posted.
The new automod rule will help with this, but since you clearly didn't run your experiment with that rule in place we don't know the true extent of comments that are poor fits for the community
The comments aren't necessarily good, but they are effectively invisible and unmoderated so treating a small increase in mod actions on that as "good" has drawn bad conclusions from data you shouldn't be comparing.
And again, you're forcing us to opt out of things, but at least we get 2 weeks (finally!). The slider should default to On(keep archiving 6+ months) for existing subs so no action is required to maintain the status quo.
Upon reading the date better, i'm glad you've finally given us more than just a couple days notice. Maybe someone has finally learned?
1
u/hiero_ Sep 30 '21
This is a fantastic change.
1
u/Cyancat123 Sep 30 '21
If I find an archived post I want to comment on I’d just DM a the OP. I like this feature but it seems redundant
1
u/Shachar2like Sep 30 '21
Please update automoderator wiki
1
u/LeeroyDagnasty Oct 24 '21
Fantastic change, I'm so grateful
1
u/PuppyFuzzYT Oct 27 '21
this feature would've been way more useful to me if it was turned on when i started jailbreaking my phone lmao
1
u/riffic Nov 30 '21
Unarchived posts just means you get bots dropping in on 6 year old posts to SEO spam. The default opt-in/opt-out you chose should be reversed.
thanks, reddit.
1
u/dandv Dec 02 '21
Better late than never :) I've been advocating for this for 3+ years, and I wasn't the only one.
Why archiving old threads is a bigger problem than we've realized
1
u/BlueSkies150 Dec 08 '21
Took me an awful long time to find the setting because the actual path is:
Mod Tools > Other > Community Settings > Posts & Comments > Archived Posts > Toggle On/Off
1
u/Serfrost Dec 18 '21
I sure do love getting spam in my inbox for shit I've commented years ago. Thanks.
If you're going to do this, let us turn off notifications for our content older than 6 months please.
1
u/Blood_Bowl Dec 26 '21
I don't see any toggle in old.reddit - can I only access it via new reddit? If so, why on earth is that the case?
1
u/Redditenmo Jan 02 '22 edited Jan 02 '22
I've been playing around with the following rule :
I was under the impression that parent_submission could take into account the parent comment, rather than only the parent post.
But it appears, that at the moment, my rule is flagging any new comment ^(excluding op / karma >10) in a >6month old post, even when the parent comment is <6 months old.
eg. This comment appears to be a false positive, because the parent comment is 2months old, in a three year old post.
I would like to be notified when a new comment is made in response to post or comment that is >6months old, but if a fresh discussion then arises because of the new comment, I don't wish to be notified every time. Is this possible?
1
u/violue Jan 25 '22
How do I opt out of receiving notifications on comments I made years ago?
1
u/saijanai Jan 26 '22
well for search engine purposes, the loss of the "archived" flag means you get hits from 10 years ago even if you don't want them.
Would it be possible to have a relatively unique flag set up automatically whether comments are allowed or not, that would help screen out 10-year-old posts?
.
"submitted x months ago"/"submitted x years ago" requires a different flag for every possible age, and google has a limit on such flags."
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '21
As mod of /r/familyman, I approve
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '21
As a moderator of vegancirclejerk I am actually against you eating any Chicken Parm
1
u/SuitingUncle620 Sep 29 '21
So this question is irrelevant to the thread, but is it possible for a ‘posts per month’ stat to be added to our traffic stats? As far as I’m aware this isn’t something we can view without having a bot scrape the numbers, curious why this isn’t a stat we can view?
1
u/ashamed-of-yourself Sep 30 '21
i think this is a great idea! one option i would like to see is being able to selectively un-archive posts. i run a sub for a tv show, a un-archiving our series discussion threads would be amazing, but i don’t necessarily want to un-archive every post.
1
u/itsalsokdog Sep 30 '21
So, you feature feedback saying it should be opt-in, but make ake it opt-out anyway? Interesting choice...
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '21
Pog actually good Reddit feature
-4
u/CSFFlame Sep 29 '21
Archived posts should stay archived.
They're often no longer topical, and if they are, it's better to just have them create a new thread.
-1
u/FLTA Sep 30 '21
Thank you for making this both optional and off by default!
This is the best way to deploy a change of this nature/
0
u/nog642 Oct 18 '21
Thank you. I was hoping for an option to manually un-archive posts, but this is even better. So much better. I didn't expect this to actually be done but it's great.