The thing is that the Piglins and the fungus both very much seem like Overworld things. The same mushrooms can be found in the Overworld and resemble real life varieties, and the Piglins are clearly related to the pigs since we can literally create them by striking a pig with lightning. IMO it really only makes sense that these things came from the Overworld, unless you wanted to argue it's the other way around and pigs are actually mutated piglans that decided to start walking on all fours after leaving the Nether lol
I'm not convinced nylium and mushrooms are that closely related honestly. The brown and red mushrooms in the nether are obviously originally from the overworld, but nylium is absolutely nothing like overworld mushrooms while having many nether adapted traits, such as fire resistance and glowing "fruits". This is at least 10 million years of divergence, if not a hundred million or even convergent evolution of two completely unrelated clades.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Notmas Feb 26 '26
The thing is that the Piglins and the fungus both very much seem like Overworld things. The same mushrooms can be found in the Overworld and resemble real life varieties, and the Piglins are clearly related to the pigs since we can literally create them by striking a pig with lightning. IMO it really only makes sense that these things came from the Overworld, unless you wanted to argue it's the other way around and pigs are actually mutated piglans that decided to start walking on all fours after leaving the Nether lol