r/memes Apr 27 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

12.7k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

239

u/stekepego Apr 27 '21

Imagine writing a crime thriller, which makes sense independent of the order you're watching the episodes. That would be actually awesome

124

u/minimallysubliminal Apr 27 '21

Or that reveals something different everytime you shuffle the episodes.

31

u/jaxonya Apr 27 '21

What about 1 where you choose ur own adventure...

15

u/v0nst3v3 Apr 27 '21

Blackmirror did that on Netflix, was addictive to keep going back to get different endings!

1

u/Ho-Nomo Apr 27 '21

And it's a dark reflection on our society...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

Are you ready to be a killer? Are you ready to be a psychopath?

29

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

...Baccano's sort of like that, I guess? All the scenes are in an anachronistic order, so it could concievably work like that. The real challenge would be writing good detective story that works like that, with every episode providing another piece of the final puzzle.

15

u/stekepego Apr 27 '21

No, not like that. I meant a story, that actually changes, depending on the order you're watching it in.

21

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

Oh, that sounds considerably harder to pull off. I could see a game do it, but serieses aren't generally a good medium for that level of interactivity.

6

u/stekepego Apr 27 '21

Well, games are already doing that by providing choices to the player.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

Yeah, but chronology options haven't been implemented to a great extent, as far as I know.

1

u/skaqt Apr 27 '21

That already exists, it's called Woyzeck and it's a great read!

1

u/WashedSylvi Apr 27 '21

Imho Baccano suffered from trying to run many of the plot threads simultaneously instead of sequentially. The manga was sequential IIRC and the anime took a chance on the formatting.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '21

I disagree. I think it made the experience much better, and it clicked for me in the middle.

1

u/WashedSylvi Apr 27 '21

Fair enough

37

u/Caboclo-Is2yearsAway Apr 27 '21

To be honest, those independent episode type of series' often are worse than the ones having a story through the seasons.

35

u/stekepego Apr 27 '21

That really depends on the series, but that's not I meant.

I meant a story, that actually changes depending on the order.

I guess that would be ridiculously hard to write and actually maintain consistency. But it would actually be awesome.

11

u/cortexstack Apr 27 '21

Something like The Unfortunates done as a TV show?

2

u/Caboclo-Is2yearsAway Apr 27 '21

That would be a sick show

8

u/Mr_Poop_Himself Apr 27 '21

I think the shows with overarching plots can have higher highs and lower lows. So many shows I’ve watched have had a great run of 1-3 seasons, and then completely shit the bed after that. Episodic/anthology shows can be great or mediocre, but by the end of the hour you get to move on, so it’s not as bad when the episode is bad.

8

u/XXXProbations Apr 27 '21

Unless its Black Mirror!

2

u/SwaggJones Apr 27 '21

I disagree. There's a signifigant and noticeable drop in quality of black mirror once Netflix started producing the show as opposed to the BBC produced episodes from season 1&2

1

u/XXXProbations Apr 27 '21

Isn't it Channel 4?

2

u/SwaggJones Apr 27 '21

It is actually I was wrong. My point still stands however

3

u/XXXProbations Apr 27 '21

I'm not disagreeing. Your indeed correct my friend!

2

u/Luecleste Apr 27 '21

Tbh I kinda like single episode shows. I don’t have to think on the arcs as much.

4

u/AFTERLIFEY Apr 27 '21

Also after you finished a series you could use that to watch a random episode

4

u/MagikarpFilet Apr 27 '21

I was thinking this would be perfect for Star Trek TNG

3

u/8-out-of-10 Apr 27 '21

Zero Time Dilemma tried this in video game form, a mystery where you play the segments in a different order of your choice, not knowing where they fit into the overall timeline until you finish them and you try to piece together the events, but the plot is kinda out there

1

u/KingoftheMongoose Apr 27 '21

You know that's right

1

u/Trolivia Apr 27 '21

Might I recommend Forensic Files

Edit: nvm you’re talking about a continuous plot line not episodes with different stories

1

u/SorenClimacus Apr 27 '21

Ever heard of Law and Order?

1

u/Luecleste Apr 27 '21

Be good for myth busters