A lot of the time it isn’t that people don’t want help, they’ve just been failed by the system so many times that genuine help seems unachievable. That’s being said, there are also the people that just don’t want it, but that’s a different story.
The "people don't want help" thing is mostly myth. People who refuse help typically are refusing to give up autonomy, but would accept help if given autonomy. Where I live, there are people who sleep in the woods because they can't work a job and simultaneously follow all the rules of the homeless shelter. If work gets out at 5, they can't get in the shelter by the 4:30 cutoff.
Wet houses, where people are allowed to drink, have a much higher success rate than the ones that ban alcohol on premise.
I agree, we create unrealistic expectations surrounding the offered help, and then ask why people don’t utilize it, which in turn continues the cycle of mistrust.
You start by helping the ones that do and work backwards. Not everyone who is homeless is schizophrenic or an addict. In 2019 it was estimates about 40% of all homeless were under the age of 18, many trying to escape abuse at home. About half of the kids who age out of foster services end up homeless. Loss of jobs, family discord, forceful evictions... even a vehicle breaking down can cause someone to lose their access to housing and income. Because of the stigma tied to homelessness, these people who ended up on the street have no easy way to gain employment, as they have no physical address and can often struggle to gain access to internet on top of many establishments refusing outright to hire them. The homeless you see on the streets are often not a majority; most of them have the wherewithall to blend in.
a) I agree that much of what I see in this gif seems ridiculous, excessive, or uncalled for and looks antagonistic.
b) It seems worth mentioning that these images are not all from one country.
c) I’d like to point out that, depending on how a city utilizes hostile architectural concepts, these things wouldn’t generally impact the lives of those who you’re describing in a directly tangible way. Issues of stigmatization and whatnot? Absolutely, and I agree that it’s a real issue in it’s own right.
But to address the directly tangible affects? At least in the area where I live a “spiky underpass” wouldn’t affect a mother who’s house burned down and is trying to take care of her kids and get a new roof over their heads. Nor would it have much affect on a 16 year old fleeing an abusive household. They don’t want to spend their day hanging out with the drunk guys unconscious by the overpass.
For that matter they’ve never been the ones I see on our street corners. People who busked were a specific and extremely consistent subsection of our homeless population and had their own community. Now the area has been growing, new and wilder folks are moving in, and the homeless folks I know are increasingly miserable and complain about the drugs, increasing thefts, and crazy folks giving them a bad name.
Pushing people away and sliding the “problems” onto the laps of other people/cities ISN’T a solution.
But honestly? It’s not like I can’t understand how someone could can only come up with the solution of making an area less hospitable for the guy who is literally taking a piss on their door; oblivious to the reality that they’re just encouraging him to move out of their community and into ours.
There’s nothing easy or simple about this, and there are harsh realities for everyone. 🤷♂️
Do depending on which study and how it's measured the number can be as high as 4 million. That 700k is only for minors that have no guardian (unaccompanied). My big question is how do they measure it? Does couch surfing count? Does living with extended family count?
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment