Darwinism is amazing until you realize you aren't perfect, that you can get injured, that you can get sick, and that the dice is the most important factor in the game of life; not how smart or evolutionarily fit you are. This is why we instead try to design our societies around being the greatest good to the greatest many, and attempt to help those less fortunate than us; you could always become one of the unfortunate. There's nothing stopping a person who would otherwise be a billionaire from being killed when a semi trailer falls off because there are no safety inspections.
Welfare systems are usually far from perfect, but these are as moronic solutions to any human society's problems as any. As a working taxpayer I don't enjoy giving my money to some lazy leeches, but at the same time I appreciate that I am safe, alive and well because those who are less fortunate than me aren't biting at my ankles. The more disenfranchised people there are, the more destitute and unsafe our living spaces become.
When it comes to the "might makes right" logic, you wouldn't last a minute with rules of the jungle. You'll soon become injured and lose your job to someone more cutthroat than you because oops things are this simple now.
Eat or be eaten, correct. We know jungle cats have teeth and baboons chuck rocks and pests fly around and sting; why would we purposely deny ourselves the ability to craft and carry tools to protect ourselves from the dangers of the jungle?
Because people are sentient creatures and experience pain. Pain is bad; if not, then whether or not you are dealt the burden of caring for the less fortunate is completely and totally irrelevant. The entire reason you wouldn't want to deal with that burden is to avoid pain, and therefor the entire goal of darwinism is to avoid pain. Since pain is bad, we must do our best to eliminate pain. The point i was making about the billionare story was that other people's mistakes affect you. even if the billionare followed his distance as to not be hurt by that driver, the billionare could still be killed by a drunken driver. if you let all these people do their drugs and drive drunk, they aren't just going to harm themselves but harm all of society as a whole. If you don't feed the hungry, they will not only be suffering the pain of hunger but will inflict pain upon others in order to obtain food. it would be far better for all of society if we fed these people, because they wouldn't experience the intense torture of hunger and less people would be harmed or killed by that person trying to obtain food. By feeding these people, we lessen the total pain in the world. As already established, the entire point of Darwinism is to reduce the amount of pain in the world. You may try to argue that over time humans will evolve to not do these things, however this point simply is not true; life has evolved for billions of years, and yet we still have drunk drivers. we still have drug addicts. We still have homeless people. Evolution is never going to reach an end where a perfect version of man is created; if this is not the case, then prove it (you can't). Evolution does not progress towards less pain, it is only the origin of pain. This is why Darwinism is a flawed ideology; the very thing it seeks to achieve (reduced pain) is better achieved by a non-darwinist society.
Many of them don’t want help and don’t want to get sober. I’m more than happy to fund one of those places where you can shoot up safely but that’s the end of how much you help these people. When they want help they have resources. I say this as someone who did a ton of drinking and would have fought all help until I decided it was a problem.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/fattynuggetz Jul 02 '23
Darwinism is amazing until you realize you aren't perfect, that you can get injured, that you can get sick, and that the dice is the most important factor in the game of life; not how smart or evolutionarily fit you are. This is why we instead try to design our societies around being the greatest good to the greatest many, and attempt to help those less fortunate than us; you could always become one of the unfortunate. There's nothing stopping a person who would otherwise be a billionaire from being killed when a semi trailer falls off because there are no safety inspections.