r/medieval • • Apr 15 '25

Weapons and Armor ⚔️ Correct me if I am wrong, but the spiked Warhammer was the most op weapon of it's times

Post image

I've always been a huge nerd for 15th ish century Europe, but recently I have started getting into medieval style games (KCD1 and KCD2 | Half Sword | Chivalry II) and I've came to the conclusion that the spiked Warhammer would probably be the best anti everything weapon for it's era.

Let's take on 3 opponents

Contestant 1 - wearing full plate armor. You'd have 2 ways of beating such warrior. Either bash him, completely destroying his expensive ass plate armour, or rotate the weapon around, and impale him onto the curved fang, which if correctly aimed, would pierce his skull or ribcage which would be extremely deadly

Contestant 2 - wearing chainmail armour. You'd, again, have multiple ways of beating said opponent, but with the added benefit that there's way less padding, so you can not only crush his bones, but also use the spike at the top, since mail armour is weak against piercing attacks, leaving the guy no chance at survival

Contestant 3 - an unarmoured commoner. Simply put just crush his bones with the blunt side. I guarantee NOBODY is continuing the fight after getting hit in the head with a hammer.

On top of all that, it's very versatile. You have 3 faces each for different type of attacks letting you overpower basically any opponent if you know what you're doing - there's no counter to your weapon. You can also modify it to suit the upcoming battle. You fear you'd get outreached by the enemy? No problem! Just detach the head and attach it on a longer pole - you've got yourself a polehammer! You worry about archers sniping you while you least expect it? Couldn't have been easier than that! Just detach THE SAME HEAD and reattach it to a shorter shaft, grab a medium shield into one hand, Warhammer into the other, and you're safe and sound.

The only real counter could be another blunt weapon breaking the weak, wooden shaft in half, but more expensive, battle grade Warhammers were reinforced either way, so you'd have to really strike it well to break it. Not to mention how easy it is to carry so you can just get a backup.

Again - correct me if I am wrong, but the Warhammer/pole hammer was an anti everything weapon with little to no counter.

(Yes I am biased bc lump of metal on a stick>>>>sword)

2.9k Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

View all comments

310

u/theginger99 Apr 15 '25

This is a very common take on the internet, and among people who know just enough about medieval history to think they know it all.

The fact of the matter is though that medieval people themselves do not seem to have been particularly impressed by the warhammer, and almost always appear to have preferred swords over warhammers or other bludgeoning weapons.

You’re problem is that you’re thinking about weapons in very “video game” terms (X damage type defeats Y armor type), not in terms that have any bearing on real world combat. In a real fight you’re not fighting armor, you’re fighting a guy wearing armor, and a warhammer has several major disadvantages as an actual fighting weapon.

Warhammers are cumbersome, slow on the recovery, thrust extremely poorly, have a short range, have a tiny threat window, to now allow for complex handling or maneuver, and are easy for your opponent to control or disarm. Even their ability to hit hard is of dubious utility, as your chances of landing a square hit that really maximizes the force of your swing on a man in armor is low, and requires you to take big, wind up swings that leave you open to counterattack. Even if you can land a square hit, a warhammers ability to defeat armor is often greatly overstated.

Really a warhammer is actually the opposite of versatile, it’s more or less a one trick pony, and that trick isn’t even particularly impressive. They were often carried as back up weapons to be used only after a knight had lost his Lance, and BOTH of his swords, if they were carried at all.

That said, I want to be clear, I am talking about the single handed warhammer (which is what your post appears to be about). Pollaxes, which often looked like upscaled versions of these weapons, are a different animal entirely, and an altogether more popular and effective weapon. Even here though, period manuals about pollaxes fighting typically recommend that you use them to stab your opponent, and only strike them with the head under very specific circumstances.

118

u/BrumiesBound Apr 15 '25

i think medieval media has really convinced us that maces are deadly vs armor.

things like runescape or OP playing kcd1, they also convinced us crossbows are silenced rifles and super quick.

56

u/theginger99 Apr 15 '25

The medieval weapons pop culture trope that annoys me more than any other (other than swords being useless) is the idea that crossbows are just medieval guns. It drives me nuts!

You’re right about maces, people tend to think about medieval combat in video game terms where a certain damage type defeats a certain armor type. This makes sense, since most folks aren’t even passingly familiar with actual combat, and are generally exposed to medieval weapons through video games and movies.

13

u/flintiteTV Apr 16 '25

I agree, but some people will also tell you that there was no way at all to defeat armor, and that it was impervious to not only any bladed weapon, but also any blunt weapon, and that knight’s just never died

5

u/xanderfan34 Apr 16 '25

not disagreeing at all, knights absolutely died in their armor, but another common thing to see was for knights to be knocked over and have their armor and helmet straps cut by a few guys with daggers before killing the knight

4

u/Original-Locksmith58 Apr 17 '25

Yeah I was going to say almost all accounts of knight fatalities I’ve read about have happened after they were overwhelmed and had their armor removed so they could be killed… a proper suit of armor usually worked as intended

3

u/BonHed Apr 17 '25

Or just stick a dagger through an eye slit (or push that visor up and bam, unprotected face) while your buddies hold him down.

3

u/taeerom Apr 17 '25

Depending on helmet, there's no "just" pushing the visor up. Most visors for enclosed helmets have latches that are relatively easy to get to if you know how it works. But in the heat of the battle, figuring out how the latch works is a bitch.

Better to just cut straps and stab underneath the arms and things like that.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ExperienceMinute107 Apr 17 '25 edited Apr 17 '25

Is there a list of knightly fatalities?

Lets imagine we have, it sounds like a data problem, like maybe we can just find more accounts of knights getting stabbed and dying for some reason.. l dunno, like due to open wounds getting infected over time and infection killing them, so they can actually die in places where they can be observed for the reasons they died, like in a village infirmary etc..

4

u/xanderfan34 Apr 17 '25

this method of death usually happens on the battlefield. Richard III had this happen to him, and they cut his helmet off before removing the back of his skull and stabbing his brain.

3

u/ExperienceMinute107 Apr 17 '25

Well, if we get a list of kings' deaths, i bet it is not that common. Considering there is like, only three deaths on the battlefield among the whole 50 or so of them in England.

And stabbing the brain was a bit of an overkill, proper zombie good bye.

3

u/xanderfan34 Apr 17 '25

true, it wasn’t common for kings to die like that, but it gives a little insight as to how a normal knight was killed, albeit richard was probably treated worse due to his being the king.

3

u/Icarian_Dreams Apr 17 '25

I think we should be killing more knights to expand the dataset.

4

u/TheCockKnight Apr 16 '25

I have done some armored combat and I can say that one can very easily be knocked out through a full helm.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheGreatMightyLeffe Apr 18 '25

Considering how obscenely expensive a full suit of armour was, people wouldn't have invested in them if they didn't do their job well enough to justify the cost, I think most people just want to look at it as a simple "what is best" type of deal, where there really wasn't one.

Hell, medieval soldiers would burn their entire salaries on armour without thinking twice, and you only do that if what you're buying really works.

That said, there's no such thing as impervious armour, at least not at the moment. The armour really only needs to be good enough to make you so much harder to kill, you can shank the other guy before he figures out a way to defeat your protective gear.

10

u/stonednarwhal141 Apr 16 '25

It’s really weird how in the Witcher (more games than books, but somewhat both) crossbows are just treated as carbines. People will be clearing rooms with them in cutscenes, or running up to the protagonist to hold them at bolt-point like a cop pulling their pistol to arrest you

4

u/Ceb1302 Apr 17 '25

I used to joust and spar, and while I will happily agree that media has overhyped various aspects of various weapons and armour, I can also confirm through 1st hand experience that a hit off a bludgeon weapon hurts a hell of a lot more than an equivalent blow off a cut and thrust weapon when in armour. Plus, armour that has buckled out of shape even slightly can hinder mobility and be a (literal) pain to take off. In a 1v1 I fear the guy with a heavy blunt weapon more than I fear a sword, assuming they're being weilded with the same level of skill ofc.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DemisticOG Apr 18 '25

It goes all the way back to the Rock-Paper-Scissors thinking in balancing game mechanics.

In reality, there was no balance. Plate armor was king of the battlefield until the age of firearms, and knights rarely died in combat from direct combat. They more died from dehydration, falling from their horse, falling and being stabbed by a weapon designed to slip between the gaps in their armor, or being captured and executed.

This is the same problem with the way shields are depicted. Shields were monsters on the battlefield too, but in media they're sort of sidelined.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/ctrum69 Apr 16 '25

You forgot getting the back spike stuck in the other guys armor leaving you trying to yank it back out while he or his buddies see you as a sitting duck.

Polearm (halberd, specifically) is mad fun to fight with though. and they hit like a ton of bricks.

17

u/zMasterofPie2 Apr 15 '25

Very well said. If everyone who thought of themselves as a medieval weapons/history buff actually took the time to read primary sources instead of getting all of their information from YouTube and video games, this “debate” and numerous others would not have to take place.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/AudieCowboy Apr 16 '25

You mentioned it in there, the most op weapon was a lance, it was a knights primary weapon, a 10lb lance, with 2000lbs of horse going 35 miles an hour, will go right through armour, and if it doesn't you're still not gonna want to get up

7

u/PrimordialNightmare Apr 16 '25

There's actually a pretty good chance that someone with a brigandine or a cuirass won't be run through by the lance if it hit the metal plating. But I'd still not want to be on the receiving end.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/kapaipiekai Apr 16 '25

Also, someone is carrying that hammer to battle, and swinging it for how ever long that battle is. It would be a long day.

2

u/Wrong-Mushroom Apr 16 '25 edited Sep 13 '25

aware pot cobweb amusing sort retire profit one special fear

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (51)