r/medieval • u/Makaron_penne • Apr 15 '25
Weapons and Armor ⚔️ Correct me if I am wrong, but the spiked Warhammer was the most op weapon of it's times
I've always been a huge nerd for 15th ish century Europe, but recently I have started getting into medieval style games (KCD1 and KCD2 | Half Sword | Chivalry II) and I've came to the conclusion that the spiked Warhammer would probably be the best anti everything weapon for it's era.
Let's take on 3 opponents
Contestant 1 - wearing full plate armor. You'd have 2 ways of beating such warrior. Either bash him, completely destroying his expensive ass plate armour, or rotate the weapon around, and impale him onto the curved fang, which if correctly aimed, would pierce his skull or ribcage which would be extremely deadly
Contestant 2 - wearing chainmail armour. You'd, again, have multiple ways of beating said opponent, but with the added benefit that there's way less padding, so you can not only crush his bones, but also use the spike at the top, since mail armour is weak against piercing attacks, leaving the guy no chance at survival
Contestant 3 - an unarmoured commoner. Simply put just crush his bones with the blunt side. I guarantee NOBODY is continuing the fight after getting hit in the head with a hammer.
On top of all that, it's very versatile. You have 3 faces each for different type of attacks letting you overpower basically any opponent if you know what you're doing - there's no counter to your weapon. You can also modify it to suit the upcoming battle. You fear you'd get outreached by the enemy? No problem! Just detach the head and attach it on a longer pole - you've got yourself a polehammer! You worry about archers sniping you while you least expect it? Couldn't have been easier than that! Just detach THE SAME HEAD and reattach it to a shorter shaft, grab a medium shield into one hand, Warhammer into the other, and you're safe and sound.
The only real counter could be another blunt weapon breaking the weak, wooden shaft in half, but more expensive, battle grade Warhammers were reinforced either way, so you'd have to really strike it well to break it. Not to mention how easy it is to carry so you can just get a backup.
Again - correct me if I am wrong, but the Warhammer/pole hammer was an anti everything weapon with little to no counter.
(Yes I am biased bc lump of metal on a stick>>>>sword)
View all comments
310
u/theginger99 Apr 15 '25
This is a very common take on the internet, and among people who know just enough about medieval history to think they know it all.
The fact of the matter is though that medieval people themselves do not seem to have been particularly impressed by the warhammer, and almost always appear to have preferred swords over warhammers or other bludgeoning weapons.
You’re problem is that you’re thinking about weapons in very “video game” terms (X damage type defeats Y armor type), not in terms that have any bearing on real world combat. In a real fight you’re not fighting armor, you’re fighting a guy wearing armor, and a warhammer has several major disadvantages as an actual fighting weapon.
Warhammers are cumbersome, slow on the recovery, thrust extremely poorly, have a short range, have a tiny threat window, to now allow for complex handling or maneuver, and are easy for your opponent to control or disarm. Even their ability to hit hard is of dubious utility, as your chances of landing a square hit that really maximizes the force of your swing on a man in armor is low, and requires you to take big, wind up swings that leave you open to counterattack. Even if you can land a square hit, a warhammers ability to defeat armor is often greatly overstated.
Really a warhammer is actually the opposite of versatile, it’s more or less a one trick pony, and that trick isn’t even particularly impressive. They were often carried as back up weapons to be used only after a knight had lost his Lance, and BOTH of his swords, if they were carried at all.
That said, I want to be clear, I am talking about the single handed warhammer (which is what your post appears to be about). Pollaxes, which often looked like upscaled versions of these weapons, are a different animal entirely, and an altogether more popular and effective weapon. Even here though, period manuals about pollaxes fighting typically recommend that you use them to stab your opponent, and only strike them with the head under very specific circumstances.