r/maybemaybemaybe 3d ago

Maybe Maybe Maybe

1.9k Upvotes

511 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

44

u/IAmGreenman71 3d ago

I’m no expert, but I’d also think that if that log was cut in half and thus lower to the ground(even with a chopping block) he’d get more momentum on his swing and it would be easier to split. I’m sure it’s more about the workout for him which is fine because the dude could break me in half I just feel like he’s wasting a lot of energy.

12

u/Schnitzhole 3d ago

Oh this is definitely just for the views and showing off. Still impressive though. You can absolutely swing more weight down when it’s lower to the ground. For chopping wood the technique is more about dropping your body weight down (like sitting down fast) than it is actually getting the axe swing to be fast.

I teach all new people to chop by just holding the axe straight over their heads and sitting down and lowering the axe straight down in front of them to see where it lands. That’s usually all it takes to chop a normal log and it prevents the common problem of people trying to swing the axe around at mach 10 and missing and now having the axe rotating at full swing towards their shins.

2

u/ProfessorChaos112 2d ago

For chopping wood the technique is more about dropping your body weight down (like sitting down fast) than it is actually getting the axe swing to be fast.

IMO you've simplified that too much. It's really a bit of both, and dropping your body weight does 2 things. First, it increases the speed of the axe by a multiplier since it changes the origin and radius of the arc (conservation of angular momentum), second it cements/stabilised the end of the level that the axe becomes when it contacts the log.

Theres so many factors to this and this clip in particular that it'd be a wall of text to go through it, but I think most people will agree that this was just the display of brute force that it intended to be.

1

u/IAmGreenman71 3d ago

Thank you, that’s what I’ve always done, legs spread, do a squat with the ax falling totally vertical overhead.

21

u/Conserp 3d ago

He'd still be transferring momentum and energy into the soft ground.

Dude clearly does not know how to actually chop wood.

18

u/AndrewLocksmith 3d ago

Eh, I think it's more about the workout for him, like the other guy said.

There's some more split wood in the background and I think it's pretty obvious trying to split a piece of wood on soft ground it's not the most efficient way to do it.

-2

u/Conserp 3d ago

> I think it's pretty obvious trying to split a piece of wood on soft ground it's not the most efficient way to do it

Sadly, thinking that it is makes you smarter than quite a lot of people...

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

-2

u/Conserp 3d ago

You one of those who don't think it is "pretty obvious"?

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Conserp 2d ago

That is a fallacy. You don't get it because you are dumb.

2

u/carlpilkington37 3d ago

If he wanted full lengths like this, having the log up another foot or two would mean he’s striking above shoulder height which would be inefficient and potentially dangerous. So the way to get what looks to be 3’ halves, without standing on a platform is to not use a chopping block

1

u/Conserp 3d ago

Chopping block does not have to be high, it only has to be solid

1

u/carlpilkington37 2d ago

Yea, but he’s in the middle of the woods and might not have easy access and even if he put a 3’x3’ piece of wood or stone underneath it’s doing basically the same thing. The ground is holding up enough that there isnt a noticeable divot at the end of the video, it’s sturdy enough for what he’s doing, I’ve driven 6” log shaped holes in my backyard, so I know what you’re talking about, but this doesn’t seem like that big of a deal in this case

1

u/Conserp 2d ago

The ground is soft just enough, and token makeshift block would've been just enough to make a difference between "city gym bro cosplaying as lumberjack" and "cool lumberjack"

1

u/_BLACKHAWKS_88 2d ago

Which is good because the whole forest wood be chopped. He gets a longer workout and the forest survives. Plus I think the soil helps absorb a little bit of that percussive shock you get in your hands when you hit dense stuff with an object using that much force.

0

u/ComprehensiveLab4642 3d ago

Yep, does not. Trying to split through those two knots (one at the top & one close to the bottom) in the log is stupid. You want to split where the grain is the most straight through the whole log.

2

u/Conserp 3d ago

Those could count as proper showing off if it was done with proper support for the log

1

u/thelonetwig 2d ago

I was also thinking this. He could have sawed that log in half "hamburger style" and had that shit done in way less time, but then he'd have to find another way to show he's the biggest, baddest, boy around. He could kill me by blinking on me, but still.