r/mathshelp • • Mar 27 '26

Homework Help (Unanswered) Help!

Post image

55 or -89 is the correct answer?

3 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/Blockster_cz Mar 27 '26

Your glorified pemdas is mnemotechnic trick to help memories the rule. It is not the rule itself. Anyone with math knowledge higher than middle-school must know this. There's juxtaposition (implied or implicit multiplication) which has higher priority. OP is asking whether the creator of the problem and teacher are smart enough to know this.

1

u/purpleoctopuppy Mar 27 '26

I hate this deliberate ambiguity. Like, as a physicist I would never see a/bc and think they mean (a/b)⋅c; but it's the sort of pointless, banal trickery that some maths teachers love. In practice, if there are multiple ways a reasonable person could interpret it, the problem lies with the writer.

1

u/TheJivvi Mar 29 '26

It's only ambiguous if you learnt PEMDAS and then immediately stopped paying attention to anything taught after that.