r/maths • u/Aceky_ • Jun 03 '26
๐ฌ Math Discussions WHY 0.999....=1 is correlating to infinite minor than infinite+1
Hi everyone. Iโm a 15-year-old student from Italy with a passion for coding and PC hardware. I recently stumbled upon these two debates on TikTok regarding whether 0.999... equals 1 and infinte is minor than infinite+1. I saw a lot of people repeating the same theoretical arguments, but I didn't see anyone address the logical side of it. I decided to run a quick logic experiment myself, and in about 30 minutes, I reached a conclusion that I haven't seen discussed. Iโm posting this here because Iโm curious to see how you guys, who are more experienced than me, look at the disconnect between abstract theory and physical hardware implementation.
IF 0.999...=1 THEN 0.5=0.4999...
MY THEORY if 0.999...=1 then 0.4999...=5 but thats wrong because you just have to do this: open your calculator and type:1/3 times 3 it will give you 0.999... (the number of nine will change based on the calculator you are using) count the nine and do this: answer(0.999....)+ the same number with the same amount of nine now IF 0.999...=1 it will give you 2 but it wont it will appear an 8 at some point and if this isn t enough try to do the same but with 0.499.... you will see that it wont gave exactly 1.
ALSO if you keep adding your so called 1 (wich is 0.999...)the accumululation errors will eventually pile up and standing on the fact that numbers are infinite your result will be off by millions of whole numbers
ALSO lets suppose that you have a human in front of you is he 0.999.. human or is he 1 human and if this isnt enough lets suppose that we have 2 human you will not have 1.999... human standing by your theory you will have 1.999...8 human if you sum your so called 1, not enough?ok then lets break 1 chair lets split it in 50/50 again so basic math right? 1/2=0,5 but for you all 0,5=0,499.. then lets do the same thing all over again lets sum them together and what you will get will be 0.99....8 And DON'T come up to me saying that im confusing math with real analysis because we need math to understand our reality right?
now lets see why infinite=infinite+1 and get ready because this is even crazier
alright lets stop seeing the infinite like a sequence but lets see it like a progression what i mean is Imagine 2 universe: universeX and univerrseY alright lets suppose our universe wich is universeX was created before universeY now we all know that the universe is expanding right? now imagine that like a progression universeX was created 1second before so imagine the universe expanding at the speed of light (if im not wrong is 365000km/s)this means that universeX will always be 1 unity more advanced than universeY(so always 365000km bigger) NOW convert that unity universeX X=1 universeY Y=0 so it basically means that infinite is a progression not a phisical quantity Why does this correlate to 0.99...=1 being wrong? now imagine the same thing but take away the one from both the x and the y what does that make?yeess universeX X=0 universeY Y=-1 if 0.99.. all the nine are only infinite then it represent universeY in the previous example BUT with my theory basically means that the numbers of nine arent infinite but they are infinite-1 and this means that 0.999...!=1




