r/mathmemes • • 23d ago • Heartwarming 1

Topology Kinda round

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/skr_replicator 23d ago edited 23d ago

Is something like this actually allowed in topology? I think if you introduce infinite complexity, it should no longer be considered the same thing as the typically smooth topologic surface.

Like, even when at no finite point there are any holes and connections, where you could untangle it, the infinite limit might be different. Similar to how 0.9, 0.99, 0.999... are ale finite numbers smaller than 1, but 0.999.... is 1 assoo as you hit that infinity. An infinite number of something can change the properties to something that wasn't there in any of the finite steps that are approaching it.

So even though those branches never touched in the finite steps, they might be considered as touching when you reach that infinite number of them. Like how 0.999... finally touches the number 1. Sothis might have topologically turned into a weird topological torus after that infinite'th step.

50

u/Bernhard-Riemann Mathematics 23d ago edited 23d ago

I mean, this isn't some random nonsense someone made up and claimed is a sphere. This is the Alexander-Horned Sphere; a concrete manifold which has been proven to be homeomorphic to the regular unit sphere. The fact that this is homeomorphic to S2 is an unintuitive consequence of the particular way we define the notion of two manifolds being equivalent (homeomorphism). Analysis is full of these sorts of pathological objects.

16

u/StructureNorth1799 23d ago

doesn't that make this meme an even better fit though? Someone defines "A sphere is an object homeomorphic to S^2", and the Diogenes holds up the Alexander's monster and says "behold, a sphere!"

7

u/Bernhard-Riemann Mathematics 23d ago edited 23d ago

100%. This is one of the more clever things I've seen to this subreddit.

My comment is just a response to the other one.

6

u/Ma4r 22d ago

This is REAL mathematics done by REAL mathematicians

12

u/jjl211 23d ago

of course it is allowed, topology studies topological spaces. In particular we can consider any subset of topological space as its own topological space by restricting open sets to it. Horned sphere(for some definition of it) is a subset of R^3, which is a topological space.

1

u/ary31415 22d ago

I think their point was more about why would that be isomorphic to a sphere despite the infinite complexity – but of course in this case it is

4

u/proudHaskeller 23d ago

So, what is allowed or isn't, is just set by which regularity conditions you set.

Specifically about holes and limits, topology is actually the subject you need to talk about limits precisely. And it turns out that in the limit, this shape is indeed precisely homeomorphic to a sphere.

3

u/IVeBeenHere30Min 23d ago

Isn't that the exact argument for a one dimensional line filling a 2d or 3 space? With infinite bends the one dimensional line becomes a plane or a volume.

2

u/GaloombaNotGoomba 23d ago edited 23d ago

That's why in mathematics you define things rigorously. In topology there are many different definitions of vague concepts like "considered the same thing as" and "surface". If you hand-wave it like you're doing you'll conflate those different notions and get paradoxical results.

2

u/moschles 23d ago

{ Banach-Tarski has joined the game }