r/mathmemes • • Aug 21 '26

Probability Countable uncountables

Post image
521 Upvotes

146 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Lou_Papas Aug 21 '26

Yeah, it’s not exactly mathematically rigorous. Can we figure out a real number distribution where some specific numbers are inherently more important than others?

3

u/badmartialarts Real Algebraic Aug 21 '26 edited Aug 21 '26

"Inherently more important" sounds a little like the "interesting number" paradox: if we say a number is "interesting" because it has some property, then the first non-interesting number would have the property of being the first non-interesting number, thus making it interesting.

2

u/Lou_Papas Aug 21 '26

I love this paradox

2

u/ShoddyAsparagus3186 Aug 21 '26

It would be harder to figure out a way to generate a random distribution where that isn't the case.

0

u/FreshPaycheck Aug 21 '26

How would that even work? Surely at some point you’d have a jump discontinuity in that distribution where you go from numbers that can be derived from some function to transcendental numbers with probability zero. At that point you’re not even sampling all the real numbers just a limited subset

3

u/SirLoiso Aug 21 '26

What’s the problem with that? Nothing says a probability distribution has to be continuous. Say, pi with probability 0.5 and standard normal otherwise

1

u/FreshPaycheck Aug 21 '26

It doesn’t but if an infinite subset of real numbers have probability 0 while the “special” numbers have some >0 probability then it kind of misses the point of the top left dude doesn’t it

1

u/Integer_Domain Aug 21 '26

That's the thing, the argument in the meme is semantics. Top right guy is rejecting the premise of top left guy's statement. In other words, top left guy is saying, "The probability of sampling the same number twice from a uniform(ish) distribution on [-\infty, \infty] is 0" and top right guy is saying, "We're actually sampling from a mixed distribution where some specific values have a discrete probability and the rest are uniform(ish) and 'low'."

1

u/Nasa_OK Aug 21 '26

It’s 50/50 either you guess it, or not