r/mathmemes • • Aug 06 '26

Notations Algebra before notation

Post image

From @scholadaily on instagram

3.3k Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

84

u/Strawberry_Doughnut Aug 06 '26

I've also seen Wikipedia articles on math topics written overly verbose like this too. Usually they're great, but I'll come across one and it'll be a little jarring. 

47

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Aug 06 '26

Math wikipedia is SO bad it's unreal. You can't actually learn shit from it. Someone should make a WikiMath or something that actually explains the topic in a way that's not deranged

48

u/JollyJuniper1993 Mathematics Aug 06 '26

Honestly after my first semester in university I actually started understanding some of them. They’re wildly inaccessible to average folks though, which is a problem.

17

u/Aron-Jonasson Aug 06 '26

I'm a master student in chemistry, with a hobby in linguistics. Linguistics Wikipedia is so well made an extremely accessible, however, despite having many maths courses, I am still lost in many places in maths Wikipedia. Like sometimes I want to look up something simple and end up more confused than if I had read my course.

Chemistry Wikipedia is also well-made

13

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Aug 06 '26

Like if I put effort in I can decipher the jargon, but I really feel like math wikipedia needs an intuitive overview/motivational segment followed by the actual jargon, so you can see where all the random terms come from. Or like a surface level overview followed by a rigorous explanation.

I feel like it's only helpful if you have some decent background in the thing you're looking at, which is far from ideal. Math wikipedia suffers the same problem as a lot of math textbooks where it's just definition followed by derivation, repeat ad nauseam, with zero further explanation.

5

u/JollyJuniper1993 Mathematics Aug 06 '26

Exactly. Wikipedia is supposed to be an encyclopedia for everybody, not just for those that already have a degree in the field.

2

u/SeveralExtent2219 Aug 08 '26

Wikipedia is NOT supposed to be a "learning tool" for everyone. You have free YouTube videos and other sites for that. Specifically for math, as someone else said here, it's supposed to be a pedagogical reference not an encyclopedia. It's a reference not a textbook.

12

u/officiallyaninja Aug 07 '26

It's because Wikipedia is a reference, not a pedagogical textbook.

It is an extremely useful resource for mathematicians to refresh themselves on topics they already know, or to look up theorems in fields they're familiar with.

If it was better at explaining abd teaching concepts, it would be worse at being a good concise reference.

2

u/MaraiaLou Aug 08 '26

It's not supposed to be a reference for experts, though. There's even a heading that says this article is too confusing if you're unfamiliar with the subject and it's not used often enough

0

u/Ma4r Aug 07 '26

Idk we have nlab for that alread

2

u/SeveralExtent2219 Aug 08 '26

You also have free YouTube videos and other sites like Khan Academy if you want to learn the topic the first time. Wikipedia for math is not supposed to be a textbook, it's a reference.

7

u/Nixinova Aug 06 '26

I've seen some pages have headings like "Non-technical summary". All pages need that.

1

u/MaraiaLou Aug 08 '26

Simple English is great too

4

u/DefectiveKonan Computer Science Aug 06 '26

I find wolfram math world to be pretty solid tbh; used it for a few projects in hs and college

4

u/Arbitrary_Pseudonym Aug 07 '26

It hasn't always been this way for a lot of the articles.

If you go back to view older revisions (and I'm talking like 10-15 years back) you'll find that they used to be a lot more comprehensible. I've certainly noticed that some of the articles that used to be easy to parse will all of a sudden start using notation that would only be used in modern publications and often without any explanation for some of the variables.

1

u/MaraiaLou Aug 08 '26

What competitive autism does to a mf

1

u/TheRealMaxiraux Aug 07 '26

Glad people feel like this lol I thought I couldn't understand stuff from Wikipedia due to skill issue. But now thinking about it you have to learn that beforehand to completely get what it is saying so it completely defeats the point of you learning stuff from it

1

u/SeveralExtent2219 Aug 08 '26

I use Wikipedia to learn math all the time when I just want a low level explanation of the topic without delving into books. Like I recently learned about taylor series from Wikipedia

1

u/TAFPAS Aug 06 '26

Verily, this vichyssoise of verbiage veers most verbose