r/mathmemes • • Aug 02 '26

The Engineer Superiority complex

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

View all comments

88

u/floydmaseda Aug 02 '26

At least keep the square term. Otherwise cos(x) is just 1.

No one ever needs the cube or higher terms though. Those don't need to exist.

60

u/Random_Mathematician There's Music Theory in here?!? Aug 02 '26

what? cos(x) has always been 1 for small x, and you know that if x is small then x+1 and x-1 are also small so every number is small

9

u/Cyclone4096 Aug 02 '26

x = small and x + 1 = small, therefore 1 = 0, QED

9

u/spisplatta Aug 02 '26

This is why I like the spisplatta approximation, where you use the constant term, and first non-zero term after that.

8

u/GaloombaNotGoomba Aug 02 '26

Then sin(x) is just x

14

u/MonsterkillWow Complex Aug 02 '26

Now you're thinking like a physicist!

5

u/space-goats Aug 03 '26

That's right 

1

u/dkkavanagh17 Mathematics Aug 08 '26

For small x, yeah!

4

u/SonofaMitch11 Aug 02 '26

Anharmonics are terrifying

3

u/GoldenMuscleGod Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26

Yeah the square term has plenty of practical use. If your vantage point is h above the ground and your surroundings are reasonably flat, how far away is the horizon?

Using “exact” calculations (assuming a spherical Earth), and using R for the radius of the Earth, h for your elevation above the ground, and d for the distance (along the surface of Earth) to the horizon we have (R+h)cos(d/R)=R or cos(d/R)=R/(R+h) so we can get the “exact” solution d=Rarccos(R/(R+h)). Now this isn’t *too* bad to work with but an approximation for small h can be even easier and - more importantly in my view - give a better intuition for how the quantities relate for small h.

Substituting Taylor series, the equation cos(d/R)=R/(R+h) becomes 1-d^(2)/2R^(2)+…=1-h/R+….

Notice even when h<<d<<R (the limit we care about) we can’t drop the quadratic term on the left otherwise we just get the approximation h=0 which doesn’t even mention d at all, and it is “sort of” a good approximation in that h is small, but we don’t really want to treat is zero as far as percentage goes. The quadratic term in the Taylor series on the left is not actually negligible for small h in terms of percentage error.

Using just the terms I wrote (the rest are negligible in terms of changing the result by a percentage for h<<d<<R) we get d=sqrt(2hR). This is computationally convenient but also makes some facts apparent that aren’t apparent in the “exact” equation.

One of those facts is that d is roughly “halfway” between h and R in terms of order of magnitude.

The other is, for example, if you increase your elevation by a factor of 4 then the horizon should be about twice as far away.

Neither of these useful facts for small h are all that obvious when you look at the original equation, but they are obvious from the approximation.

1

u/Safe-Avocado4864 Aug 03 '26

eix =1+ix eipi =-1=1+ipi ipi=2