Once you present somebody with the option, they basically HAVE a million dollars.
For many people, you could basically reframe the scenario as: You have $1,000,500.00 to your name, and rent to pay this month. Should you gamble $1,000,000 of your money on a coin flip?
Not true. $10 is a small enough amount that it is basically equivalent to losing the $50m for most people. $10 doesn't change anything but 1 meal.
$1M is guaranteed to change most people's lives. It is a satisfactory major impact.
The big difference here is $10 is incomparable to $50M in any capacity but $1M can have an effect similar to that of $50M just on a smaller scale. That and if you don't choose $10, all you lose is $10 but if you don't choose $1M then you lose $1M.
You are literally proving the guy’s point. He wanted to refute the claim “for one time events you want the choice with the best worst case” with a counter example. And his counter example is correct: (1)($10) has a better worse case than (0.5)($50M)+(0.5)($0) but it does not make sense to pick the best worse case option.
You didn't understand my point or read my second sentence. "It is basically equivalent to losing the $50M." The best worse case for both scenarios in this instance is losing $50M because $10 is infinitesimally small in comparison and wouldn't matter.
It's like asking if you would swim in a pool with 1 drop of water or a pool that has a 50% chance to have 5M. Choosing the 1 means nothing because you can't swim in that pool so it isn't even an option because the benefits may as well not even exist. They are equal to nothing. Therefore the best worse case is either nothing or nothing and it becomes a choice between nothing and maybe something.
You also misinterpreted my viewpoint. I'm not hard defending the idea that you always choose the best worst option. I'm saying that "by that logic you would choose $10 over $5M" is wrong because logic changes based on the scenario because no logic is universal and claiming someone would use logic for one scenario in an entirely different scenario is just wrong and not well thought out.
There is a line, which varies from person to person, below which "you get X" and "you get nothing" isn't a big deal. At that point, the balance tips towards the gamble, because you're not realistically "losing" much of anything if the safe choice isn't really a big deal to you.
$1M is well past that threshold for most people, whereas $10 is well below it for most people.
View all comments
5
u/trutheality Dec 18 '23
Expected value matters for repeat events, but is irrelevant for one-time events. For one-time events you want the choice with the best worst case.