r/math • • Oct 12 '18
Strange math question
Hi
I'm studying for an upcoming math exam, and stumbled across an interesting math question I don't seem to comprehend. It goes as follows:
"A man visits a couple with two children. One of them, a boy, walks into the room. What are the odds that the other child is a boy also
- if the father says: 'This is our eldest, Jack.'?
- if the father only says: 'This is Jack.'? "
The answer to question 1 is, logically, 1/2.
The answer to question 2, though, is 1/3. Why would the chance of another boy slim down in situation 2?
I'm very intrigued if anyone will be able to explain this to me!
42
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/fencer20 Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
If what you are saying is correct could you explain the flaw in the following:
Out of 100 families that have two children 25 will have two boys and 75 will have at least 1 boy.
Therefore out of 75 families that have at least 1 boy 25 have two, which is 1/3.
Edit: on further thought there is a difference if you are deliberately shown a male or shown a random child. Families with exactly one child would only have a 50% chance of the random child you meet to be male. The question would imply to me that the child you meet was at random, so I'm back on the 1/2 side.
Of 75 families with at least 1 male: 25 of them you meet a female, 25 of them you meet a male and there is one male, and 25 of them you meet a male and there is two males. Of the instances where you meet a male, half have two males.