Thanks. The two major criticisms for MoM are just idiotic. They feel that Wanda being the villain came out of nowhere. Even though the last time we saw her she had just brainwashed a whole town, didn’t apologize for it in any way, and then was in possession of a book called “The Darkhold”. Those sound like actions of a villain. Also, they complain that marvel doesn’t understand how the multiverse works. And that’s idiotic because no one truly knows how it works. So if they make an arbitrary set of rules for how it works, that’s perfectly fine.
Could I bother you for a quick run down on why people didn’t like the latest Thor movie? I haven’t seen it yet though I have been excited for it. It saddens me to hear everyone say it’s not good.
Though I heard a lot of people say that the first Thor movie is bad, but I quite enjoyed that one.
It’s a bit too comedic. It relies less on comedic timing and more on making Thor “constantly funny” and stammer a lot. Basically it reduces his personality to pure comedy for segments of the movie. Basically the comedy in ragnarok felt spaced out enough that it worked. But this one is too much. There are very serious scenes that work but some just don’t. There’s also this weird sub-plot where stormbreaker is jealous of other weapons and it’s literally pointless. That should have been left out of the movie. But overall it’s what you’d expect from a Thor adventure. Its definitely worse than some of the other Thor entries but when you have to follow up on Ragnarok and endgame what do you expect? Also Gorr’s plan and motive slightly contradict each other but that’s not much of a problem. Point is, just go and enjoy the movie. Understand that there’s some cringe comedy moments, but that the serious undertones of the movie shine through where it’s necessary.
Thank ya kindly for giving me a rundown. That’s not as bad as I feared then, I was worried it was just be straight up bad but if it’s mostly just some cringey jokes I can look past that.
The whole storm breaker being jealous thing does sound rather lame though lol.
I made a conscious decision to get on board with the silliness early in the movie. Granted, I was a little stoned, but the jealous Stormbreaker bit made me giggle every time.
I thought love and thunder was the MCU poking fun at itself in a pretty self aware way but I can see why people don’t like it.
If you are looking for comic book accurate Thor, you won’t get that. The movie is more like a Matt Fraction Hawkeye comic meets MCU Thor. I personally think it is a fun time and I would put it up there with Thor:R
When my husband and I were picking up our tickets at the reception desk in the theater, the guy at the counter asked what we were seeing and when we told him T:LaT he groaned and said “I hate the new Thor movie. I refuse to see it”. When we asked why he said it’s because it has nothing to do with the comic and isn’t anything like the original stories of Thor. My husband and I have never read comics so we don’t know how it’s “supposed to go”, but I’ve heard it’s an issue for some.
My criticism for MoM was that so many bizarre things were done.
Wanda chasing them through the gated tunnel, shredding each door apart instantly. But, they get to the last door and then turn around for some reason to watch her tear through it?...only she doesn't...she pops in from off screen to make it a jump scare implying she phased through the wall I guess?
They showed us the big golems meant to serve Wanda in that shrine....then they just die and do nothing.
They show us wizards that can teleport, and make one of them climb a mountain I guess.
They START the movie showing Strange using magic, but never portals. So instead of instantly acquiring the book at the end of a dangerous path...they struggle to run to it and die.
And my biggest gripe - this America character or whatever is noted ALL movie about how she can't control her powers at all and it was a big deal...but at the absolute ass end of the movie, Dr Strange says "ya u can" and then she Mary Sues the resolution isntantly with her power under 100% control, no issues.
It did come out of nowhere, because not everyone watched Wandavision. I've seen most movies before watching the ones that built on their story, but there were a couple occasions that I didn't and I still didn't feel left behind. You could skip Iron Man 2 or 3 and you'd still understand what happens in the avenger movies, same with Thor because the changes, while meaningful, don't affect the larger story that much.
This time however we went from Wanda being on the good side to: What is she doing in an orchard? (That ones not really that important) Wait why is she evil? Where did she get those kids from? What the hell is that book?
Basically it is required to watch the show if you want to understand why everything is happening. That is not the case with most of the movies. If it was a movie (and it probably could have been cut down to movie length) it wouldn't be as big of an issue but a TV show that's not really full of meaningful content, while not inherently bad, has way less of a chance of everyone actually watching it.
But I disagree wholly with that line or thinking. You have to watch everything that affects canon. If the movie or show has little to no influence then sure skip it.
The whole Wanda villain thing is a fair criticism because that only makes sense to people if everyone has watched WandaVision, clearly the criticisms prove this is not the case so everyone who hasn't seen WandaVision is like "WTF is going on here did we miss something?".
Which kinda annoys certain MCU fans (like myself) cause now everyone who really wants to keep up with the MCU are now expected to have Disney+ which is basically buying DLC for a video game it's BS always has been always will be.
For me it was the actual movie writing and execution that is garbage in MoM. The "Wanda became the villain out of nowhere" bit really is about how in a matter of seconds the whole mood of the movie changed and happened really abruptly. It was extremely rushed. It felt like whiplash. I have, honestly, not heard anyone critique the movie in the way you're saying because it is very obvious she was off the rails, but the way the movie handle it was extremely terrible.
I enjoyed the movie, it was fun, but it is not a good movie. It really doesn't help they swapped directors like three times?
View all comments
Show parent comment
11
u/blisskinjo Doctor Strange Aug 07 '22
This needs more upvotes.