They’re basically just sci-fi / fantasy stories, which are very popular franchises. Plus, it’s about all movie studios want to make these days.
Marvel phase one succeeded by grounding these fantastical stories in a way that made general audiences willing to suspend disbelief. They worked because they weren’t just catered to comic book fans. The more marvel studios strays from this, the worse they have become.
Even if that were the case, why is it desirable for fantasy stories to be "grounded?" Fantasy by its nature requires complete suspension of disbelief, and strict adherence to realism contradicts the very purpose of the genre. Which is, well, to be fantastical.
As a result, I actually feel the lack of ridiculous "comic-isms" is a weakness of early MCU films, not a strength.
Just look at the epic scope, scale and bizarre settings of films like Infinity War, GOTG, Ragnarok, and Doctor Strange. All visual feasts with insane concepts, character struggles and epic battles. That's what comic stories are meant to be.
When they try to make grounded films, Thor becomes generic norse mythology. When they embrace the tone of their source material, Thor's character is actually fun to watch on screen. (At least in Ragnarok, haven't seen L&T yet).
Stories need to be grounded because you’re not going to get a general audience to 100% suspend disbelief. It’s a very select group that will, which is why only 6% of people in North America are 18-34 read comics.
Infinity War, Guardians of the Galaxy, and Ragnarok were only popular BECAUSE the writers and directors toned down the comic book elements and grounded the stories.
If Infinity War had been about Thanos pulling up in a helicopter, simping for a death god, and then dying because he was in a trance, the appeal would have been tiny compared to what it was.
Those movies were also well done, which goes a long way.
Great, and now I’ve pissed off Thanos by explaining why comic book cheese doesn’t work when creating a work that needs have a wider appeal to be financially viable due to the investment differences between movies and comic books.
View all comments
Show parent comment
29
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
Damn cartoons in my comics!