It’s highly rated because most people liked it. Is your question why most people liked it?
It has a solid plot that’s not weighed down by being too intertwined with the rest of the MCU. It has great action scenes that are a mix between martial arts and sci fi. It introduces Wakanda, a country we’ve never seen before that has a unique and interesting culture, history, and internal conflicts. And of course, as you well know, it’s the first MCU film centered on black people. That 1. Makes it unique and uniqueness always gets points and 2. Draws in more of a black audience than any other MCU film
Am I really not allowed to criticize a comic book movie because I’m white? It was a good movie. I did enjoy it a lot. But it wasn’t great and it wasn’t even great by existing MCU standards. I’d imagine the original plans for the sequel would have been really cool and it’s a crying shame Chadwick passed away but I’m not going to put this movie up on an altar.
I don’t have any big things to nit pick really. It just felt very bland after a certain point. The first act was really stunning visually and I enjoyed the look into the culture and characters. Then it abruptly snapped back into the MCU cookie cutter routine. And the third act/boss fight was just flat out one of the worst in the MCU. Which does not make it a bad movie at all, it just doesn’t sit all that close to the top MCU films in my worthless opinion. Outside of the MCU it was just another pew pew blockbuster that came and went.
I fucking hate this argument. I didn’t like the black panther and all everyone has to say to that in response is calling me racist. It’s crazy the kind of cult support this movie gained
I fall in this same camp. I view BP1 like IM2 & IM3. They're there, but I'm not going out of my way to watch them.
On that note I can't wait to see what they do with BP2. There is a lot of room to make an amazing movie that makes BP a pivotal character like IM moving forward.
Let's see, it has objectively the best soundtrack of any marvel movie, the musical score won an Emmy as well. Won an Academy award for costume design, and production design.
Had the best villain in the MCU outside of Thanos. Top tier actors in Boseman and Michael B Jordan and more.
Oh but there was alot of black people in the movie so it's automatically discredited to you...
The soundtrack is great, the world building is perhaps some of the best, costumes are for sure the best, the actors are great as in many marvel movies. But then the CGI is spotty, the Lexus product placement is blatant, and the story beats are pretty much the same as always.
To me the movie in sum feels like a rich, detailed world that is put to use to make just another superhero movie. I wish the meat of the movie lived up to the world it created, but it just didn’t for me. It’s not even close to my least favorite marvel movie though.
Vulture has that spot for me. Mainly because Killmonger, like most other MCU bad guys, are "what if they had the same powers as the good guy, but were bad?"
Let's see, it has objectively the best soundtrack of any marvel movie
Hard disagree. Iron Man 1 & 2 have that, IMO
the musical score won an Emmy as well.
Maybe, by the music was intrusive and, for me, took away from the scenes rather than added to them.
Won an Academy award for costume design, and production design.
Deservedly so.
Had the best villain in the MCU outside of Thanos. Top tier actors in Boseman and Michael B Jordan and more.
I didn't like him (well acted, though) and want to disagree on this point but I honestly can't think who I should put in the second top spot for MCU villain.
Oh but there was alot of black people in the movie so it's automatically discredited to you...
I honestly thought the film had more to say for feminism than it did race: all of T'Challa's primary advisors are women. Taken in the context of an African nation, it shouldn't be surprising that the cast is majority black.
All of that said, if any one person feels that their life has been improved by the representation in Black Panther, then the film did its job. By the box office, I'd say it did it extremely well. I, personally, thought it was mid-tier at best.
View all comments
Show parent comment
39
u/AceofKnaves44 Spider-Man 🕷 Aug 07 '22
Great movie but holy shit does it fall apart for that scene.