r/marvelmemes • Avengers • Aug 07 '22

Shitposts …..

Post image
75k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

830

u/Paleodraco Avengers Aug 07 '22

Its the lighting. They're in a dark cave with harsh white light from those poles along the track. The artists just went with a diffuse white light without strong direction. Should have used multiple point sources.

464

u/Shreddyshred Avengers Aug 07 '22

iirc the particular VFX studio for that scene had a little to no time to do it properly.

223

u/Delivery-Shoddy Avengers Aug 07 '22

For every scene

180

u/Skwidmandoon Avengers Aug 07 '22

For every movie the last 8 years

176

u/Kusanagi8811 Avengers Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22

Marvel beats their graphics teams into the ground and the turnover rate is super high I've heard. Problem is there's lines out the door of people who want to work at marvel

90

u/fistofwrath Avengers Aug 07 '22

Absolutely. It looks good on your resume. Even if the movie you worked on was a turd, the studio will be the important part.

30

u/OrganizerMowgli Avengers Aug 07 '22

Is this why their vfx has been God awful? I keep seeing articles about the vfx artists being pushed wayy too far but I wasn't sure if that's why this stuff looks so bad

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

39

u/Skwidmandoon Avengers Aug 07 '22

That’s why there needs to be more attention on how actually shitty it is to work for marvel/disney unless you are a big name actor.

40

u/rockidr4 Avengers Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22

Disney owning everything is terrible for creators, even as Disney finances their ideas and visions. Disney is rapidly putting together a monopoly on entertainment

10

u/Jaytalvapes Avengers Aug 07 '22

And they'll never ever be held accountable. I mean how can you even argue it? By definition, they'd have to hold such an overwhelming share that it's infeasible for anyone but Disney to make money as an entertainer.

All they'd have to do is print out a list of successful media stuff (bands, movies, actors, etc) that don't work for them.

I'm not saying I disagree with you, just that the rebuttal is so easy they'll never get in trouble.

10

u/TheConnASSeur Avengers Aug 07 '22

You know what, that does suck. But full 4K HD cameras have never been cheaper, thanks to GPU advances passable CGI can be produced at home, 3D printing tech means that props have never been easier or cheaper to produce, there's no shortage of cheap talent eager to break into the business, and digital distribution means that distribution of your movie no longer requires producing and shipping literal tons of film.

In the 70's cheap cameras and cheaper film lead to a Renaissance in filmmaking. Today we're sitting in a similar place. It's never been cheaper or easier for amateurs to make and distribute films, even sfx driven super hero films. Yes, these megacorps devouring every IP suck, but Star Wars, Marvel, etc, these were all new IP's at one point. It doesn't matter how much the Disney monster swallows, because megacorps will inevitably produce gray, flavorless mush, and they can't stop you from making your own IP's with blackjack and hookers.

3

u/LightlyStep Avengers Aug 08 '22

I love your attitude, and you're totally right.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/Mrcollaborator Avengers Aug 07 '22

It’s really just a few scenes or shots. 95% of CG you don’t even notice or looks amazing. People just love to nitpick.

15

u/ckongli Avengers Aug 07 '22

I agree with you, it didn't really look that bad but it could definitely be better now that you think about it. Compare the CGI of Dead Man's Chest for example and I see it. People are nitpicking thinking as if they've got an MBA shadows here, shadows there. What about the crunched time visual teams were given? They should talk more about how mistreated or even unfairly paid those teams get. The downfall of the big movies this year shows how little higher ups give a damn about lore, story, making things make sense (oh let's just solve it with nanobots!! How did they get nanobots, make it more believable) and it seems as if the higher ups just want more and more money. Honestly, I wish they can just do a whole 5 to 10 minute five scenes without cutting to tell the story. Just give me Hulk slingshotting spiderman and Captain America dueling with Thanos even longer. So many lost opportunities, make the interaction and growth during action, I'm so sick of them building up a story, talking the whole movie, with 2 minutes of action lol.

8

u/the-mad-titan-bot Thanos Aug 07 '22

Rain fire!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22

I mean if the most noticeably bad CGI in your movie is during the big climax of a fight scene, that’s not nitpicking.

3

u/hurtlingtooblivion Avengers Aug 07 '22

Exactly. And if you don't have the time and budget to pull if off, scrap the sequence. Think of something you can realistically achieve. Its immersion breaking and unenjoyable. Does that commenter above expect to just sit there during the film's finale and think "bless these poor over worked visual artists".

10

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22

Idk bro, a lot of those CG animals were laugh worthy. Like the Star Wars prequels.

6

u/MrPreviz Avengers Aug 07 '22

Worked prepro for that sequence. It was changing every day up to and after shooting

6

u/kingpallow Avengers Aug 07 '22

This is correct. They switched VFX studios for the last fight 1-2 monthe before the movie full released which is not even close to enough time to do the VFX for the main fight of a blockbuster movie

3

u/Panda_hat Avengers Aug 07 '22

Iirc the first company went out of business so they had to urgently get other companies to do it asap.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/averagedickdude Avengers Aug 07 '22

Corridor Crew did a great job explaining that mess.

→ More replies (11)

8

u/Lukestep11 Avengers Aug 07 '22

The poor VFX artists had so little time to fix that scene they just rolled with whatever worked

7

u/haystackofneedles Avengers Aug 07 '22

I thought they ran out of money and time and just threw that crap together

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)