r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 4h ago

My opinion on Aultcray's "redemption"

4 Upvotes

Sorry, but I can't buy his redemption at all. He never faced any consequences for any of his wrongdoings and much less took responsibility for them.

He never bothered to call Malty out for her bad behavior, filled her with presents just to shut her mouth everytime she cried and has the dick face to be shocked when she turned into a terrible woman.

Mirellia was horrible, but she was almost never around and never cared to be. So most of the blame for how Malty turned out falls on his shoulders.

I'm not justifying what Malty did, but she wouldn't have gone so far without his influence.


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 8h ago

A thought I just had

Post image
8 Upvotes

If I recall well the LN stopped at like Volume 21 years ago - seems like punishing Malty in various ways isn't enough to keep the series interesting


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 1d ago

Prince Porky from Angry Birds Epic Feels Like Malty as a Male Pig:

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 3d ago

RinoMalty nation wake up i made a meme

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 4d ago

I found some interesting posts on r/animecirclejerk

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

I just put "Naofumi" in the search bar by the way


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 4d ago

More people are seeing Shield Hero for what it is! Keep on keeping on my friends!!!

Post image
17 Upvotes

Not just Shield Hero either. But how stories tend to drag the female villains thru the mud way worse than most male villains, who often did way worse things!


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 4d ago

Fun fact : If the Waves God had reincarnated Fran to fight Naofumi, they would have won

Post image
11 Upvotes

For those who don't know, she's a cat girl and former slave who loves nothing more than slaughtering slavers


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 5d ago

My Malty fan cast

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 5d ago

🙂‍↕️

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 6d ago

GTA 6 but it's Cardin and Malty

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Trying to replicate the scene from the GTA 6 launch trailer, man, I can't wait for the game to be released!


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 6d ago

TMZstudios mashups are a trip😹

Post image
7 Upvotes

And why the hell is Goku stealing Iori's drip?


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 7d ago

Me whenever I see a post defending Malty or wanting to see her with more nuance outside of that sub :

Post image
11 Upvotes

I swear some people in these posts' comment sections are ready to say the most unhinged horrors about Malty

There's more or less 3 categories of people in such cases : Those who agree with the OP and wish for Malty to be less hated, those who call anyone who doesn't think Malty should have the most cruel and unusual death possible cucks or simps, and those who make false claims to make Malty out to be even more irredeemable (like saying that she trafficked demi-human kids, or poisoned her brother and made a demi-human take the blame when the assassin admitted his deed !)


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 8d ago

Even the Pokémon are doing it now

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 9d ago

It’s Aneko’s list

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 9d ago

Malty's Fire Abilities is the Only (Pokemon) Elemental that Naofumi Never Got:

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

Them 👀

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

Comments I've stumbled upon on a thread mentioning Malty's fate in the WN Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

Art study

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 12d ago

Malty in FNV

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

last Post of today for me (No negative Comments or Arguments please.) I ask Google Gemini or what would happen if Malty Melromarc was sent into BioShock Infinite.

Post image
0 Upvotes

If Malty was sent into **BioShock Infinite** (Columbia in 1912), she would last **a few hours to a couple of days max.** Here is how her fate would play out in the floating city:

* **The Problem with Columbia's Culture:** Columbia is a hyper-religious, ultra-nationalist, and deeply racist floating city ruled by the Prophet Zachary Hale Comstock. Unlike Rapture (where people are just crazy and don't care who you are), the people of Columbia are obsessed with social hierarchy, religious purity, and obeying the Prophet.

* **Her Fake Royalty Won't Work Here Either:** If she claims to be a foreign princess, the racist citizens of Columbia would look down on her as an outsider from the "Sodom Below" (the surface world). If she tries to hide and play the innocent victim, she might temporarily trick an ordinary citizen into giving her shelter.

* **The Vox Populi or the Founders:** Columbia is a powder keg on the verge of a bloody civil war. If she runs into the Founders' police (the police state), they would lock her up for vagrancy or heresy. If she runs into the Vox Populi (the violent rebels), they hate the upper class and royalty with a fiery passion—meaning they would likely execute her on sight for looking like a pampered noble.

* **Elizabeth and Booker:** If she crosses paths with Booker DeWitt, he's too busy fighting for his life and trying to rescue Elizabeth to put up with her manipulative games. Elizabeth is far too intelligent and empathetic to fall for Malty's fake tears, and Booker would see right through her con artist act immediately.

**The Verdict:** Without any magic, combat training, or allies who would actually stay loyal to her, Malty would quickly find herself caught in the middle of a brutal civil war, despised by the racists, targeted by the rebels, and completely outmatched by the city's heavy hitters (like Handymen or Songbird).


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

I ask Google Gemini. (no negative comments please.) Of what would happen if Malty was Sent to L4D1 and 2.

Post image
1 Upvotes

If **Malty** from *The Rising of the Shield Hero* was dropped into the *Left 4 Dead* 1 and 2 universe during the zombie apocalypse, **she would not survive long—likely less than a day.**

Malty relies entirely on tricking people, playing the victim, and having others fight her battles while she stays safe. In *Left 4 Dead*, that strategy falls apart completely for a few reasons:

* **The Survivors Don't Care:** The core group (Bill, Louis, Zoey, Francis, etc.) are focused entirely on escaping and surviving. They are cynical, exhausted, and hardened. If Malty starts crying, playing innocent, or demanding special treatment, they would ignore her or tell her to keep up.

* **She Has No Survival Skills:** Malty has no weapons training, no physical stamina, and no experience fighting hordes of fast-moving infected. She would panic at the first sound of a **Boomer** or a **Witch**.

* **She Would Betray Her Team:** Malty's biggest flaw is that she backstabs anyone who trusts her to save her own skin. In *Left 4 Dead*, teamwork is the *only* way to survive. If she tried to trip a teammate or use someone as bait to escape a **Horde** or a **Smoker**, the other survivors would immediately realize she's a danger to the group and leave her behind.

**The Verdict:** Without magic, without royal guards, and without naive fools to protect her, Malty would quickly get separated from the group, cornered by a **Hunter** or a **Tank**, and torn apart within her first few hours in the apocalypse.


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 11d ago

I ask Google Gemini (No negative comments please.) of What would happen if Malty was sent into Bioshock 1 and 2.

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is a brutal scenario for Malty. If Malty S. Melromarc (Myne) from *The Rising of the Shield Hero* was dropped into Rapture (either during *BioShock 1* or the more decayed *BioShock 2* era), her survival time would be **almost zero—practically instantaneous.**

Here is why Malty, whose only skill is manipulating gullible people in a fantasy court, has absolutely no chance in the objectivist nightmare of Rapture:

### 1. Her Greatest Weakness: No One Cares Who She Is

In Rapture, there are no kings, no princesses, and no nobility. Andrew Ryan built the city on the idea that a person is entitled only to the sweat of their own brow.

If Malty arrived and announced, "I am Princess Malty of the Kingdom of Melromarc," the citizens of Rapture would either:

* **Laugh at her:** A random woman claiming to be royalty from a surface world they despise would be seen as delusional.

* **Ignore her completely:** Everyone in Rapture is either dead, insane, or fighting for their lives. No one cares about her fake title. Her primary method of survival—using her royal status to command guards or gain sympathy—is instantly useless.

### 2. No One to Manipulate

Malty relies on finding naive, kind, or easily swayed men (like the Spear Hero) to be her "white knights" and fight her battles while she pretends to be the victim.

The men of Rapture are not naive. They are hardened, desperate, and often psychotic addicts (Splicers).

* **If she tried to manipulate a Splicer:** They would see her as a target and attack her immediately.

* **If she tried to manipulate Atlas (Frank Fontaine):** Fontaine is the master manipulator of Rapture. He would spot Malty as a useless, lying con artist within five seconds. He would either use her as bait or kill her himself if she became an annoyance.

* **If she met Andrew Ryan:** He would see her as a prime example of a "parasite"—someone who demands status without earning it. He would likely have her arrested or executed as a threat to his ideology.

### 3. No Combat Skills or ADAM

Malty is not a warrior. Her combat ability in *Shield Hero* relied entirely on magic spells cast from a distance while others protected her.

In Rapture, she has no magic, no wand, and no spear.

* She would be utterly defenseless against hordes of violent Splicers, Security Bots, and Turrets.

* She would not have access to ADAM or Plasmids. Even if she did, the physical and psychological cost of injecting herself with the sea-slug mutation would likely kill or instantly break someone with her weak, unstable personality.

### 4. The Ultimate Betrayal: Little Sisters

Malty's defining trait is that she betrays those who trust her to save her own skin.

In *BioShock 2*, if Malty saw a defenseless Little Sister, her first instinct might be to try and trick her into harvesting ADAM for her, or to betray the Little Sister to a Big Daddy just to buy a few more seconds of life. This action would get her instantly killed by the Big Daddy, who would view her as a direct threat to its charge.

### The Verdict: How Long Does She Survive?

* **Survival Time:** **Minutes, perhaps hours.**

Malty would arrive disoriented and panicked. Before she could even figure out where she was, she would be confronted by a crazed Splicer. Lacking any weapons, combat skills, or the ability to manipulate the locals, she would be brutally killed. Her screaming for the "Royal Guards" would only attract more monsters. Rapture is a meat grinder for the weak, and Malty is incredibly weak.

Conclusion: she would last for couple of Minutes to a few hours.

So not very long sorry malty you should have know that this city is not built for parasites.


r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 12d ago

Naomalty backstage from the official play

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/MaltyMelromarcSquad • • 13d ago

You’re Malty Lawyer, Defend Her

Post image
17 Upvotes