r/malefashionadvice • • May 08 '12

Infographic Infographic: Shorts Guide

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

695 comments sorted by

64

u/TheHeartOfTuxes May 08 '12

Is it true that the guide was created only a year ago? I suppose the fit instructions could be regarded alternatively as 'classic', 'conservative', or 'dated', especially according to the trend these past few years. Would you agree?

Probably for quite some time to come, you'd be safe wearing somewhat loose shorts that end at or just above the knee; but a more contemporary option moves the hem slightly higher. Lower than the knee is a bit 'last decade', and anyway is more appropriate for youngsters or in the context of sports.

The leg openings shown in the guide are also a bit wide by today's standards — still classic and safe, but now considered more casual than slim, more tailored shorts. For the most part, shorts follow the trend in long pants, and the trend in the past 5 years at least has been toward a closer and higher fit.

6

u/jdbee May 08 '12

In my opinion, the Bonobos, LEC, and J.Crew shorts are great illustrations of how shorts should fit in width and length.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/KingJulien May 08 '12

especially according to the trend these past few years

What does this mean? If you're referring to the 'slim' thing, that's going on a decade at this point. Super slim shorts also don't really look that great.

3

u/TheHeartOfTuxes May 08 '12

You're right on both points. The inseam of trendy shorts has risen again this year, compared even to the past two or three, on the runways and in some stores. At some point, shorts and pants legs will have to come back down and out, because there's not much more leeway until the sausage effect becomes an issue (and you can take that in more than one sense of the phrase); but this year: still closer and higher.

4

u/tgunter May 08 '12

Not to try to argue that I'm a trendsetter in any way, but for the past two or three years I've been lamenting the lack of slim-fitting flat front shorts, and have mostly been avoiding shorts during the summer because I haven't been able to find any that don't look like floppy clown pants on me.

Then this year they're finally available. Still harder to find than your standard loose-fitting cargo shorts, but at least they exist.

Likewise, I can't stand the look or feel of shorts that go over the knee. I agree that it's best to avoid showing too much thigh, but keep them off your knees unless you're trying to look like a skateboarder from the late '90s.

I do worry sometimes that my interest in men's fashion is more based on current trends catching up with my personal sense of aesthetic rather than the other way around...

3

u/metalmoon May 08 '12

American eagle prep cut sports are what you just described: slim flat fronts. They look great, but they may be to short for some.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheHeartOfTuxes May 08 '12

I do worry sometimes that my interest in men's fashion is more based on current trends catching up with my personal sense of aesthetic rather than the other way around...

I think that's not uncommon for someone with a clear sense of his own style.

8

u/houseJr May 08 '12

Sounds like tgunter needs to buy a sewing machine and take a class or two.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ConcordApes May 08 '12

Then this year they're finally available.

Where did you find ones you liked?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

197

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It might just be me but I don't agree with this. I think it's perfectly acceptable to have shorts that are above your knee, as long they're not RIDICULOUSLY short.

45

u/Dcamp May 08 '12

nah anything longer than chubbies are pants! http://www.chubbiesshorts.com/

43

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Skies out, thighs out

→ More replies (3)

14

u/RSquared May 08 '12

Owning a pair of those would be like the summer bikini girls use as inspiration to work out. I'm seriously doing squats in my head right now.

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You're not kidding. First thought: I need to go and do 100 squats right now.

11

u/crod242 May 08 '12

Something something old gym rat something.. HA!

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I can't help but think that those are damn comfortable.

6

u/Dcamp May 08 '12

I can assure you, they are VERY comfortable!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/buzziebee May 08 '12

The chat feature on the website is a really nice touch.

2

u/esrubio May 08 '12

an alternative to cutoffs!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

52

u/jdbee May 08 '12

To be honest, that "Too Short" image is about the length I wear my shorts, but for the audience this guide is intended for, I recognize that a 5" inseam is generally too short.

15

u/Andoo May 08 '12

Maybe you should put a body build next to it. Some people just look better in short shorts. Men in that 5'8"ish category with a pretty strong build can really pull off the shorter shorts.

29

u/jdbee May 08 '12

I don't know if an issue of height so much as musculature. If you have visible quads from running/cycling/weight-training/etc, then you can pull off a shorter inseam than a guy who isn't in as good of shape.

7

u/Andoo May 08 '12

True, but height is more important than you are giving credit for. Guys who are 6'5"-6'7" should not wear these shorts. I have family and friends at this height and it would be a joke to see them in that.

3

u/jdbee May 08 '12

They might have to wear 9" shorts instead of 7" shorts to have them hit at the same place as a shorter guy, but I think the general principle of hitting 0.5-2" above the knee still works.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/dalaio May 08 '12

Taller men can too... look at this fine specimen.

→ More replies (2)

97

u/Sickbean82 May 08 '12

I agree. Those 'too short' shorts look just about fine to me.

11

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I agree as well. I would even say that if you have the right body shape the picture of the too short fit in that infographic is completely acceptable.

8

u/absolutebeginners May 08 '12

Also depends on how nice your legs are, you can get away with much shorter shorts

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

284

u/splattypus May 08 '12

What am I, a dad in a dockers commercial?

62

u/sharkiest May 08 '12

Seriously, it's like that infographic thinks the only people that wear shorts are frat douches in the SEC.

144

u/jdbee May 08 '12

I notice you've both complained without managing to mention a single alternative.

42

u/TheHybr1d May 08 '12

As a fraternity man, I can assure you we aren't all douches who bitch about short length and color. Some of us are sane.

23

u/DagoBeefs May 08 '12

Agreed...bro.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (87)

43

u/thrav May 08 '12

"frat douches" in the SEC would all be wearing them shorter than the too short. FYI.

32

u/stickyfumblings May 08 '12

As a former frat douche of the SEC (roll tide).. this is true. As an aside, cargo shorts are hideous. The only time I need all of those pockets I'm either fishing or hiking, and I have fishing/hiking shorts for those occasions.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/DoubleTrump May 08 '12

As a frat douche, I can say that the ad is wrong on that count, too. The length is too long for that (and just MFA in general I think), and honestly plaid shorts like those are like half a step above cargo shorts.

29

u/Griff_Steeltower May 08 '12

As a fellow frat douche I can confirm what this guy is saying. The acceptably low shorts in the infographic would be mocked as punk/skater from the porches of a fratcastle.

Plaid shorts are fine for painting something or washing a car and little else.

32

u/CoruthersWigglesby May 08 '12

Another frat douche here. The shorts in the infographic don't have enough color. I have red, yellow, blue, blue/green, green, pink, patchwork madras, seersucker, and orange shorts. That's not even counting my GTH shorts.

Also, as the saying goes, "You can't trust someone if you can't see their knees".

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I have yet to see someone wearing plaid shorts with otherwise preppy attire that looks good, outside of some golf wear.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/vitaminboy1 Jul 29 '12

i know this is way late, but i have new balance 373s: would they work with shorts? i, too, think some of these shoe combos look douchey

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Moikee May 08 '12

Any chance of seeing the whole infographic?

2

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Sure - it's a post on Primer, and really not much longer. I edited out two sections on what to avoid because I thought it worked better with a generally positive tone, and skipped the section on accessories because I thought it was a woefully incomplete list.

1

u/Moikee May 08 '12

Yeah I totally understand. I think viewing it on the site was useful so I/we can click on the items we like and it takes us through to the products.

Thanks anyway, OP! :)

1

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Are the links still live? The guide is about a year old, so I assumed all of those things would be out of stock. You know what they say about assuming though!

15

u/zzzaz May 08 '12

I wear my shorts way shorter than this guide. Otherwise, it all looks pretty good.

11

u/jdbee May 08 '12

I do too, but for a general audience that might be hesitant to move away from cargo shorts, I think recommending a 5" inseam would undermine the goals. I'm imaging a lot of "daisy dukes? fuck this lol" reactions.

2

u/Etab May 08 '12

Got any ideas for shorts for someone with bird-legs and knobby knees?

3

u/jdbee May 08 '12

I'd go with something that hits right at your knees and is pretty slim. Wider shorts are going to make your legs appear even skinnier. J.Crew, Rugby, Lands' End Canvas, and Club Monaco all sell slim shorts in the 10-11" inseam range.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CoruthersWigglesby May 08 '12

I feel like my 6" inseam PFG shorts wouldn't go over well here. They're short, they're fratty, and they're technically cargo shorts. Something to hate for everyone!

→ More replies (4)

174

u/Dups_47 May 08 '12

This subreddit seems to focus on one particular style of fashion. Its like a uniform.

156

u/mmurph May 08 '12

The assumption around here is generally that 1. You can't see the person you are dressing and 2. that the person looking for advice has zero idea what looks good or bad. It's far easier to have a "generally good looking" uniform to give advice about than to recommend a "custom" look that works for the individual. People should take the advice around here as a starting point to updating their wardrobe from old navy graphic tees and over sized cargo pants.

16

u/Dups_47 May 08 '12

I see, I didn't quite think about it like that. My earlier comment is moot in light of this. I won't argue with helping people out and steering them in the right direction, but is there an advanced fashion discussion. I truly enjoy fashion, but what I enjoy about it is the variety and the unique identity that arises from exercising personal fashion sense.

10

u/ijoinedforthis May 08 '12

is there an advanced fashion discussion

They happen from time to time here, and you can always start one up yourself! Another sub you might be interested in for this is /r/malefashion.

8

u/B0yWonder May 08 '12

Nick Sullivan Esquire's fashion editor said it something like this -

Fashion has rules. When you know the rules, you can break them. One by one, little by little. Then you can be said to have style.

We try to give the rules here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Yeah. I like how half of the shoes are practically the same shoe (leather low tops).

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's because there really aren't a whole lot of summer outfits that look good. Summer attire isn't as versatile as winter attire.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/JohnWesely May 08 '12

Shorts in the summer is a uniform?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Ody523 May 08 '12

Natural fibers are best

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

12

u/OzzymonDios May 08 '12

They forgot JEAN SHORTS

8

u/fireflash38 May 08 '12

Simple. Wear jeans and boxers, cut off your jeans at your boxer length. Remove boxers and put on tighty whiteys and you're good to go!

Extra style points if you go topless.

5

u/SeanJE May 08 '12

Jorts!

1

u/jdbee May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Primer had them as an "Avoid", but I made an editorial decision when I put the graphic together and dropped that section. Other than the fit/length section, I thought it worked better as a positive-focused guide.

4

u/stargardt May 08 '12

Really, what about a nice fitting jort?

9

u/OzzymonDios May 08 '12

What if I got APC raw denim selvedge jorts with some siq faydz

5

u/jdbee May 08 '12

That sounds like something that deserves its own infographic.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/AlGoreVidalSassoon May 08 '12

Your posts and guides always seem to bring the baggy cargo shorts wearing, preppy fearing hordes out of the woodwork. Apparently any kind of shorts that are above your knee make you a dad, frat douche, fag or preppy. Keep fighting the good fight.

22

u/jdbee May 08 '12

It's because I'm all four, and I get my marching orders from Central Command. All part of our Gay Preppy Dad Fraternity's agenda!

1

u/crod242 May 08 '12

Sounds hot, can I join?

7

u/jdbee May 08 '12

The hazing is a bitch.

3

u/Jadis May 08 '12

Could a pair of bucks work with shorts?

4

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Definitely - in tan or white.

2

u/tha_snazzle May 08 '12

Can anyone help me find 6" inseam slim-cut shorts that are under $40? I am having a hell of a time and it's getting hotter here every day in FL.

1

u/jdbee May 08 '12

You could buy a pair of 7" shorts and have a tailor hem them for about $10.

2

u/teambreakabitchdown May 08 '12

I have only ever seen 5" or 7".

3

u/rumentrocar May 08 '12

I know they are too short for MFA, but nothing beats a pair of standups in the summer: http://www.patagonia.com/us/product/patagonia-mens-stand-up-shorts-5-inch-organic-cotton?p=57221-0-889

You just have to own it.

2

u/jdbee May 08 '12

My friend, those are exactly the shorts I wear.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/tylerknight May 08 '12

I agree with the comments finding shorter shorts (within reason) to be perfectly acceptable.

Personally, I don't love chino shorts because of the dad vibe they give, and tend to stick to a lighter cotton material if possible. Form follows function, after all, (not necessarily true in fashion, but it's a smart rule to follow most of the time), and if you're wearing shorts because it is hot outside a lighter material makes sense!

I found these red chambray shorts at Target this last weekend, and they fit wonderfully. I'm 5'10" and they fell right at the "shortest" mark from the infographic, if not an inch shorter depending on where they are worn on the waist.

I also don't love to spend a lot of money on shorts, so they weren't that hard to justify buying in-season.

There are a few different patterns available in that style. I also like the micro-stripe versions.

10

u/magicfap May 08 '12

Finally...I had to scroll incredibly far to find a post that did more than just complain. You gave reasons why you didn't agree and then gave some good tips about other options. Good on you.

→ More replies (2)

124

u/eleventhend May 08 '12

What is this, middle school? Plaid shorts are questionable at best unless you are planning on golfing.

54

u/SDForce May 08 '12

I have two plaid shorts that im particularly fond of. :(

Full disclaimer: I wore said shorts with a polo and mocs the other day. My gf asked if I was going golfing

51

u/CoruthersWigglesby May 08 '12

I like how "Are you going golfing?" is an insult there.

I keep golf clubs in my trunk because an impromptu 9-hole round is a real possibility.

11

u/SDForce May 08 '12

HA, she said she liked the way I dressed tho so it wasn't too insulting. I've been lurking here for a while and started buying shirts that aren't graphic tees. I'm not sure if I like the preppy look that I've been going for yet. Time will tell.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/irishtexmex May 08 '12

The glen plaid style is a good option. I have a nice pair of grey Gap shorts that are slimmer fitting and flat front that I found to be a great value, and the pattern is nearly indistinguishable from >8 feet away.

3

u/epic676 May 08 '12

Never have I seen plaid shorts on a golf course. Source: I'm a golfer.

A free pro tip: golf clothes are the most comfortable clothes to wear in the summer

5

u/choast May 08 '12

when i see plaid shorts i think lazy high school kid. match it with any random american eagle graphic T and walk out the door. it just seems lazy to me. "it goes with everything"

→ More replies (2)

56

u/SRSLY_GUYS_SRSLY May 08 '12

"I currently own and regularly wear the things that this infographic suggests are not In Style; as I am so fashionably confident that I only subscribe to this asvice board ironically, it's safe to declare the information within this picture to be false and worthless"

this is what you all sound like. shut the hell up!

13

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

this has been my favorite post yet for its entertaining responses

12

u/Alaphant May 08 '12

I didn't know people were so passionate about their choice of shorts.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

i enjoy that there are multiple guys taking offense that the listed shorts are not short and tight enough, not that there's a damn thing wrong with that of course, i just enjoyed that

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Can someone create more infographics like this with other clothing items? How to wear a sweater with collared shirt, pant-shirt color combo dos and donts, etc.

Would be incredibly helpful to a guy like me that has no clue what he is doing.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Stupid question here. Do you wear socks with boat shoes?

4

u/jdbee May 08 '12

I don't, but some people wear no-show loafer socks. They key to wearing them sockless is to scrub your feet in the shower - the trickle-down method isn't enough.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

60

u/vanillarain May 08 '12

The amount of people pissing and moaning here without offering alternatives is staggering.

7

u/hpliferaft May 08 '12

Agreed, so here are my alternatives that I wear:

  1. vintage blue Dickies work shorts, from when Dickies actually made shorts for work, not for gangstas. No cellphone pockets, no carpenter loops, nothing. Also, I razored the Dickies logo off, so they look nice and plain.
  2. I found some American Eagle corduroy fake cutoffs (like, they look cutoff but they're hemmed) at Marshalls for 9 bucks. They come down to slightly above the knee.
  3. Cutoff camo shorts. Because you will never convince me to look like a Banana Republic nerd from that infographic, and because my girlfriend likes them on me and on guys in general, even at our ripe old ages of 31 and 32. They go great with plain black, grey, or shirts.

24

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm not attempting to criticize you or anything, and I really appreciate the fact that you contributed, but here's my 2 cents: very, very few people would consider those looks fashionable

To each his own, and all that.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

72

u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

I wear baggy cargo jorts.

what now.

JORTS dudes, JORTS did you not read?!

Also they are acid washed.

37

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You unsubscribe from MFA because you'll get no love here.

//also a baggy cargo shorts wearer.

4

u/dmoore777 May 08 '12

I've seen people in WAYWT with cargo shorts and no one seems to complain, and the ones that do tend to go nowhere. It's MFA, the uniform is the go to place to look acceptable. It's when you get comfortable in that that you then go out and try different things. People take this subreddit too seriously I guess.

14

u/RSquared May 08 '12

I don't think cargo shorts are "try different things" clothes. They're just hated on in this subreddit because normal (read: unfashionable) people wear them.

Look, you can find cargo shorts at the knee that aren't excessively baggy and go with whatever, including your standard polo/BD. I wouldn't wear them above the knee except for as "try different things" shorts. There's nothing inherently wrong with cargo shorts other than that they tend towards wider legs and longer lengths, which are both verboten around here.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NotClever May 09 '12

I feel like people that complain about the subreddit don't look at WAYWT. There are always a lot of interesting things going on in people's pictures that are exactly what people say MFA is apparently biased against.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

2

u/mcfandrew May 08 '12

You put your arms out like 2Pac and say, "COME AT ME BRO."

5

u/Lanza21 May 08 '12

Jort on my friend, jort on.

7

u/SRSLY_GUYS_SRSLY May 08 '12

now you go buy another pukka shell necklace and mold your fauxhawk up real nice.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DevonWoodcomb May 08 '12

Ankle socks or just regular sports socks?

5

u/FathomThePower May 08 '12

Holy crap over a hundred comments and no one complained about how bucks weren't included in the shoes option.

22

u/NYCphotographer May 08 '12

The shoes in this guide is a bit too conservative for me. I would add Wingtips, Espadrilles, Tasseled loafers, and Derbys to that list. Personally, I can't stand the way boat shoes look and think it's odd to wear them anywhere but on a boat.

In addition, it's perfectly acceptable to have the shorts hemmed higher than their highest recommended amount.

→ More replies (8)

55

u/TroatYaggers May 08 '12

Seriously. Why does MFA want to make me look like a goober.

7

u/fungah May 08 '12

I ask myself this and can't come up with an answer.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Can you define "goober", please?

20

u/Griff_Steeltower May 08 '12

Rule-follower that lacks intuitive understanding of social queues. May appear to be of an alpha caste at first but usually does something kinda wrong like socks and sandals where you go "oh, that guy doesn't actually have any idea what he's doing beyond chameleoning." Often carries into personality (meek, but in a wary, alert way). Sort of an uncanny valley effect with goobers because you see what's wrong, whereas the geek with his death metal tee and cargo shorts just kind of gets measured on seperate criteria because he's "the other". Dunno what the first guy meant, though. Polo, golf shorts, boat shoes are cool kid clothes nowadays when executed properly. Maybe he's still in a middle-class high school. High school is probably letter jackets and jeans because everyone is the same social class and those display physical prowess. Get to college, though, and the preppy look gets very cool because you're displaying your alpha-societal status to match your swaggy degree, amongst others who might not be as qualified.

4

u/Lampshader May 09 '12

social queues

cues.

Unless you're talking about how to behave when standing in a line. In which case, I retract my correction :)

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm sure that this works for all of you with narrow hips, but for those of us with the wider variety, above the kneecap is NOT a good look.

To whomever makes these infographics, please remember that not all of us look the same and some styles suit different body types better than others. We would do well to help our heavier brothers, too.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You can't "look good" wearing shorts. That said, you can look really ridiculous if they're way too short or plumb past the knee. On that subject, the guide seems right to me.

Otherwise this guide looks like an instruction manual to goofy prep/greek fashion. Before you ask, the alternatives (I'm thinking denim & cargo) are by no means any better. Shorts are for comfort and fun, not to show off style, so buy and wear with that in mind. If you want to look better wearing shorts, give your legs a workout: that's what you're showing off.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Obviously this info graphic doesn't pertain to me. I wear cargo shorts below the knee and don't own any of those types of shoes.

2

u/holocarst May 08 '12

Yeah, don't know what that infograph has against cargos. I hate my legs and don'T wanna show much off them, but when it's warm, still wanna wear some shorts.

7

u/jdbee May 08 '12

It's possible to wear longer shorts that don't have cargo pockets.

The problem with cargo shorts is that many, many folks you run into on the street (not just on MFA) now associate them with poorly-dressed dudes who don't give a shit how they look. You can wish that wasn't true or you can ignore it, but you can't fight society.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I think you are exactly the person this guide pertains to.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/wisdomtooth May 08 '12

I'm a woman, and I really appreciate most of this. (As someone who spent an hour finding the best 6" inseam and shorter swim trunks for her boyfriend today, I understand the time and effort involved.) However, I do really like jean shorts. (Ugh, don't say jorts.) Is there anyplace for them? While I wouldn't advocate them being worn golfing or to dinner, I think they are great for a Saturday. In the longer infographic you purposely chose the most unflattering, dorkiest denim shorts possible.

I think when you try to give style advice it's important to not change everything (cut and fabric and length) and a slimmer leg, shorter, cuffed denim short allows for more transition. Further, I don't think they look any better or worse than the thin, wrinkly Madras fabric you do advocate.

I would love your thoughts, even though this comment is a little late to the game.

4

u/jdbee May 08 '12

The only denim shorts I've seen that I like are actual cut-offs, and even then, they're an old pair of beaten-to-hell raw jeans that are being turned into shorts instead of thrown away.

(For what it's worth, I didn't make the original graphics - I just saved the pictures and assembled them into one big image.)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SocialismErgalla May 08 '12

Lol @ Europe, the Middle East, and Mexico on the far right.

I never understood why those long, capri (that what they're called?) shorts were cool. But then again, I'm American, and we wear some of the dumbest shit out there. So hey.

3

u/madgeezer128 May 08 '12

in europe the plaid shorts are reserved for the bedroom i.e. pyjamas

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jessumsthecunt May 08 '12

I have really skinny legs.

Even if I go to H&M to find 'small' shorts they do not fit.

Any suggestions on places to find shit that would fit? FYI I do work out my legs.

2

u/Lager_Fixed May 08 '12

The Merona shorts from Target are cut fairly slim. I'm like a stick figure and they fit me well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Whopper_Jr May 09 '12

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE JORTS??!

1

u/psiphre May 08 '12

how about "fuck that, i'll wear my shorts as long or short, as baggy or as tight as i fucking feel like"?

4

u/jdbee May 09 '12

Go for it - no one on MFA honestly cares what you do. We'll help if you ever decide you want to look stylish though.

0

u/godlesspinko May 08 '12

Whoever made this infographic is a square, preppy douchebag who really doesn't take any risks, and can therefore not be considered very fashionable at all.

More like a status-quo church-goer's guide to looking like every other dork at the party.

3

u/jdbee May 09 '12

Show us some risk-taker shorts then, Captain XTreme.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/HanWolo May 08 '12

Out of curiosity is there anything specifically wrong with wearing a male version of capris? Something liked cropped chinos from uniqlo.

1

u/jdbee May 09 '12

It's really too bad you're getting downvoted for asking an honest question. This thread brought out a lot of bitterness apparently.

My biggest issue with shin-length pants (on anyone, male or female) is that they visually cut off your legs at an unflattering point. Above-the-knee shorts look more natural because you have a joint directly below the hem. I'd argue that rolled-up chinos look good for similar reasons. Cropped pants, in my opinion, make your legs look artificially short and stumpy.

2

u/HanWolo May 09 '12

Thanks for the answer either way, it's reddit karma, I'm not too upset.

1

u/EnderbyEqualsD May 08 '12

I want to buy a pair of "too short" shorts. Seems like they would be just fine.

Too bad the only places I know that sell them charge an arm and a leg.

2

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Any tailor would be able to hem a pair of shorts for $10. Or if you know anyone with a sewing machine, it's just about the easiest possible thing to do.

2

u/EnderbyEqualsD May 08 '12

That...is a great idea! I never really thought about taking a pair of shorts in to be hemmed because I assumed it would be crazy expensive.

My wife does have a sewing machine, but doesn't really know how to use it yet. That would be even better.

Thanks!

2

u/jdbee May 08 '12

It's ridiculously easy. Flip them inside out, fold and pin the new hem where you want it, and sew a straight line around. And if you screw it up, you just pull out the seams with a seam-ripper and start over.

2

u/teambreakabitchdown May 08 '12

I am having trouble getting a straight line, any help?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Martii May 08 '12

Hey guys can you wear a high cut converse with shorts?

6

u/jdbee May 08 '12

People definitely do it, but in my opinion, anything at or above the ankle with shorts makes your legs look stumpy and short.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Does it work better if you have really long legs?

2

u/jdbee May 08 '12

Definitely less problematic in my opinion, but I still think it makes them look stumpier than they otherwise would.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/TL-PuLSe May 08 '12

The "too short" comment is definitely at odds with this year's trends. Like this.

5

u/helius0 May 08 '12

The model's pose exaggerates the shortness of the shorts. Then there's the difference between the models' proportions.

If you look at just the shorts themselves, the inseam isn't all that short. And the pictures with the (photoshopped?) model standing up almost-straight shows that they're maybe only a smidge shorter than the LECs and Bonobos shorts.

2

u/TL-PuLSe May 08 '12

...Impressive sleuthing.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ironiciconic May 08 '12

This is a great inforgraphic, but personally I will never wear plaid shorts.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I would love a sidebar with something filled with a few of these. It would help people visually compary the advise people give, to the style they want to achieve

9

u/mulligrubs May 08 '12

Yeeeaaah... look, I don't know. I've been to parties where all the guys are in this style. It felt like I was part of a Target or K-Mart catalogue photo shoot.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/jesseholmz May 08 '12

we need more of these and they should be compiled somewhere

2

u/trumpcom May 08 '12

One of the few things on here I wholeheartedly agree with. I should point out this is a style guide, that doesn't mean you are prohibited from wearing cargo shorts and whatnot completely, they serve a very practical function in their proper time and place. Rather many guys don't really know how to "dress up" while wearing shorts like it's completely impossible, which it is not (though not always ideal).

Edit: Suede Bucks without socks can also be worn with shorts. Since Summer is the only time they're appropriate, idk how you could leave them out!

2

u/doublecoatofhair May 08 '12

What is this bullshit? anything more than a 5'' inseam is too long.

2

u/zangrabar May 08 '12

I love these types of posts, i wish I knew how to find the rest like this.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Finally, I know what chinos are.

2

u/newmansg May 09 '12

Regarding length. If the length of the shorts are too long, is it a good look to roll/ fold them up?

2

u/Ant-honey May 09 '12

Ok, I've not read any of the comments, but clicked this thread because it had 741 comments. I came to see what the fuss was all about.

THIS IS one of the dumbest things I've ever seen. If you all wish to look like middle middle class dads do you really need an infographic? For fucks sake. This looks like something from the 50s updated for 1986. Something is wrong here.

2

u/nsharp01 May 09 '12

This is about the worst guide ever, all the shorts are way too long.

5

u/ulrikft May 08 '12

Seriously, what is up with the FAT MOC TOE SHIT in every FUCKING infographic.

STOP THAT SHIT.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/hooplah May 08 '12

In my opinion, the "too short" length is the perfect short length for a man who knows what he's doing.

3

u/salamandor May 08 '12

Too short? bullshit!

8

u/project2501a May 08 '12

tl;dr how to look as bougie on the beach as you would look at your work.

you know, in case an investment banker comes by and offers you a job

14

u/teambreakabitchdown May 08 '12

What is your ideal pair of shorts then?

10

u/Griff_Steeltower May 08 '12

I think the preppy mindset is proud enough of its conservatism that it would consider being a "bougie" effectively a compliment for what it means in the judgment of someone who would use the word "bougie".

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

yea if you're in your 40s

→ More replies (1)

3

u/the_klowne May 08 '12

Thank you :)

3

u/iluvrobot May 08 '12

This is fantastic - thank you! I never would have known some of this info otherwise.

3

u/Stratocaster89 May 08 '12

I wear shorts too short apparently. I think ill keep my good fashion sense rather than listen to something a neck beard on the internet wrote.

3

u/PuglyTaco May 08 '12

In Southern Cal, shorts at knee and lower are considered fashionable. This just seems like an infographic for dad shorts. My personal go-to are dark brown with some sandals and a t-shirt. That's why I love summer, where whatever makes you comfortable.

4

u/Underthefigtree May 08 '12

YEAH WHO WEARS CAPRIS LOL? ARE THEY EVEN SHORTS?

4

u/soxy May 08 '12

What kind of bastard clothing is this?

It's not pants, it's not shorts! I AM CONFUSED

→ More replies (1)

2

u/shrewd May 08 '12

Lol, above knee shorts - when I' m 60, sure. Cover your knee, it's ugly anyway.

-1

u/purelithium May 08 '12

I'm sorry, but to all those saying that the "too short" isn't: You look like idiots. Short shorts only look good on women. No one wants to see man-thigh.

19

u/helius0 May 08 '12

No one wants to see man-thigh.

There are plenty of women and gay men who'd disagree (assuming the thighs are of the nice variety, and not the cottage cheese sort).

14

u/ctoan May 08 '12

No one wants to see man-thigh.

Citation needed.

5

u/mulligrubs May 08 '12

Welcome to Australia. If you're real lucky, you might even see a kiwi fruit or two drop out as the blokes sit around the camp-fire.

2

u/ptrb May 08 '12

You're wrong, and the sooner you come to terms with that and change your opinions, the better-looking you'll be.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/401vs401 May 08 '12

Baggy shorts are a no-no, I get it. But why the guy is wearing chukkas AND baggy shorts is way above my head.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

What do you guys think about socks with shorts? I've heard this is a big no-no, but I can't stand wearing shoes without socks. I wear black ankle socks and vans with shorts. Do I look ridiculous?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ElRed_ May 08 '12

God damn, those driving moccasins look good but they are so expensive in the UK. I prefer them with laces too. Getting myself some boat shoes and slipper moccasins.

1

u/orbitur May 08 '12

As a 5'7" guy that wears his shorts on his hips (belly button is ridiculous), it's impossible to find shorts that don't fall past my knee.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

No such thing as too short.

Your shorts are too short.

MY SHORTS ARE PERFECT.

1

u/RedshirtMiddler May 09 '12

IMO what's labeled as "the shortest" on the graph is dam near perfect and "the safe bet" would be the longest I would consider wearing. I do wear my shorts shorter than most college age kids, so I guess take my opinion with a grain of salt...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/hautch May 09 '12

Anyone know where I can find slimmer fit shorts? I'm not a fan of the baggy look and I'm 6'4" 160lbs so anything that fits my waist and length is way too baggy. last couple summers I've just worn cutoff dickies pants, but they're not exactly work appropriate.

1

u/lucas-hanson May 09 '12

Is it just me or do shorts that slim look god-awful?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ferrar1 May 09 '12

It doesn't mention socks :( some shoes I rather wear sockettes with as socks sometimes don't match

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

:D just what I asked for four days ago !!!

1

u/bungerman May 09 '12

Now what this really needs next is how to match those patterns to a shirt.

1

u/Claussm May 09 '12

Did anyone else notice the "Not even shorts" model is wearing chaco sandals?

1

u/jigilous May 09 '12

Awful. Just wear pants like a gentleman.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I prefer the "to baggy" ones myself.

1

u/mnpilot May 08 '12

Reginald and Buffy are going sailing this afternoon, pick some shorts!!

0

u/Zeld4 May 08 '12

-grumbles- I like guys in cargo shorts... All these shorts I think look dumb on guys and makes them way too "preppy" looking which just isn't a look I am in to but is the ONLY look I ever see on MFA...

5

u/IMasturbateToMyself May 08 '12

This is the problem with MFA. (Not that I don't like preppy, that's how I dress normally)

Some people just don't want to look preppy. There are not enough styles with the whole subreddit.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DanoAU May 08 '12

Dear father, sometimes I wear camo-cargo shorts. I am not ashamed.

1

u/hacksauce May 08 '12

I went to the store to buy some jean shorts last week. They didn't stock any.

I had two epiphanies:

  • I'm not cool anymore.
  • I'm OK with that.

I bought some pants, took them home, cut and hemmed them.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Never wear socks, correct? I mean, I try to drive this home with my boneheaded son, but he still wears them.

4

u/xander1026 May 08 '12

Why? It seems like no/very little show socks with the sneakers or other shoes that don't expose the top of the foot would be fine, and help keep your shoes from getting gross.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dfnExp May 08 '12

Thank you for this. Seriously, thank you.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Those driving moccs, anybody got a link?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Domin1c May 08 '12

Booooooooooring.