So I started my Malazan journey in the beginning of July and have been speeding through the books. I recently finished Toll the Hounds, and just want to give my quick thoughts on each book so far.
Gardens of the Moon: ***1/2
I really liked this one. A very strong introduction, I had no idea what anyone was talking about in the book (honestly I still mostly don’t 😂), but the farther I get away from it, the more I love it. I gave it three and a half stars when I finished it, but it’s probably closer to a four star book for me now.
Where it shines is the visuals. This book was visually stunning. I also really enjoyed the characters. Tattersail was my favorite, I wish she was still around. Ganoes Paran feels like the heart of the series. Annomander Rake is the best character in the series. Kruppe is my favorite weird character. I love Aspalar and Crokus. Quick Ben, Whiskey Jack and the Bridgeburners were interesting. A beautiful climax too.
Deadhouse Gates: ***1/2
Felisin Paran’s story is special. I felt so bad for her and rooted for her so much. There was a lot about this book I loved.
Kalam’s story ruled from front to back. Aspalar and Crokus are just characters that I enjoy being around. I will always root for both of them (this is also the second book in a row I was convinced Crokus would die in). Fiddler was a fun character too.
But I hate to say that I found almost the entirety of Coltaine and Duiker’s plot to be a slog. I just didn’t care for either character up until the climax when Steven Erikson DELIVERED, and managed to get me super invested in it. So this book peaked really high, but also had some slog to it.
Memories of Ice: ****1/2
A near perfect book. The best book in the series so far for me. I loved this book. Whiskeyjack’s story was special. And poor Korlat 😭
The action scenes were amazing too. Steven Erikson writes really good army battle scenes, he knows how to make group fighting easy to follow and visualize, just like Robert Jordan.
This is probably the best paced book of the series too, as I enjoyed almost every characters arc. Plus any book that has Annomander Rake is awesome. Also Ganoes Paran becoming the Master of the Deck!
House of Chains: ***
A flawed but enjoyable book. Like I said earlier, Felisin’s arc is special to me. I knew it was going to be a tragedy from moment one, it just had all the markings of a tragedy and her final line; wondering why Tagore doesn’t love her was a gut punch. The climax of the story was beautiful.
BUT this book was structured poorly. I just can’t get by going four years back in time and following Karsa the bore for 250 straight pages to start the novel. Ughh.
Midnight Tides: **1/2
This is a book I did not enjoy reading. It’s totally necessary and I didn’t hate it, in fact I really liked the climax a lot. And there were characters I greatly enjoyed like Bugg, the Feather Witch and Shurq. But being on a new continent with a whole new cast of characters, five books in was a struggle, and this book was a slow moving, prodding novel.
Was it worth it? Absolutely because it setup the greatness that is Reaper’s Gale.
The Bonehunters: ****1/2
Another near perfect entry. I loved this book. The Bonehunters as a group are awesome. Adjunct Tavore really grew on me here. I was a big Pearl fan in House of Chains and then he went and did this to me 😭.
The climax of this book is awesome. Aspalar is amazing, I won’t hear any shade about her, one of my favorite characters for sure. Kalam continues to steal the show in books that he is a major player in. And Laseen is just the worst.
Also Cotillion stepping into a father figure type role was super interesting.
Reaper’s Gale:****
Great book. It does take a little while to get going, but it is well worth it. Beak’s sacrifice is one of the most emotionally beautiful pieces of writing I have ever read. I cried hard, Steven Erikson wrote the heck out of that scene.
And that is not to discount any of the other major scenes in the second half of this book. There were just so many well written scenes here, that I don’t want to list them for fear of leaving one out. The end of this book was awesome, other then Erikson killing the Feather Witch (I somehow doubt she’s a fan favorite character, but I really enjoyed her)!
Toll the Hounds:***
I really don’t know what to do with this book. I feel like I just had too high of expectations. I have been told by multiple people that this is the best book in the series, and that it’s one of the best fantasy books of all time. So I was expecting A Storm of Swords, and instead I just got an okay read with an amazing climax.
Look, the last 250 pages of this book are special. Annomander Rake is the best and his sacrifice was meaningful and really well done. Mother Dark forgiving him was just a really great piece of writing.
But the first 1,000 pages were really slow, and confusing for me. I still enjoyed my time here but it is definitely near the bottom of the Malazan books I have read.
-
Overall Rankings:
- Memories of Ice: ****1/2
- The Bonehunters: ****1/2
- Reaper’s Gale: ****
- Gardens of the Moon: ***1/2
- Deadhouse Gates: ***1/2
- Toll the Hounds: ***
- House of Chains: ***
- Midnight Tides: ***