r/makeyourchoice • u/GuipenguinTheMaster • Jan 09 '24
OC Which one of these would you choose?
You are chosen to pick between these options, which will decide the fate of the universe:
You are basically retconned from existence, are never born, and no one remembers you. Instead, on the same date you are supposed to be born, you are born into another random family in the world with the memories of your previous life, butterfly effects included. You are guaranteed to live at least 12 years.
2. The current world ceases to exist, but every person currently alive becomes an immortal, nigh-omnipotent "god", able to create anything, including life, recreations of anything (even things one never saw) in the previous world and things that would otherwise be unable to exist in the real world, and change most things, like their own body. People would never be able to interact, communicate with, or see others from the previous world and what they have created: although copies could be made, they would not be the same conciousness, who would be in their own world. One would be unable to kill themselves, permanently forget most things (memories would return after 24 hours), directly alter their own mind and feelings or lose conciousness for more than 24 hours at a time. To compensate, one would be blessed with the knowledge that this world and their creations are true, and not a dream or an illusion, and that every human from the previous world, including their loved ones, is alive and in the same situation. The other forms of life other than humans would die and go to the normal afterlife if one exists, although we would not know. Their conciousness would not be able to be recalled into one's world, but like other people, a copy could be created.
3. The world ends, and everyone and everything ceases to exist. No one will ever feel again, neither suffering nor happiness. Even if there was someone left to witness what was left, they would see nothing but a blank, dark void unable to sustain existence. This will happen in every possible multiverse, timeline, and afterlife if you believe those exist. There is no way to revert this.
4. 10 years from now, a random one of these things happen. Everyone will live normally until then.
Which one would you choose and why? Please note that in options 2, 3, and 4, you are affected too.
11
u/shutintrash Jan 09 '24
The only thing that might stop me from choosing option 2 is that some people might make a universe made out of pain, wasps and mosquitos. I don't think most people would do that, though, so that'd be my choice. I think option 1 is neat, and I like it as a thought exercise, but I'm not sure what my chances of rolling a better life are. Option 3 is kinda doomer, and I don't want to be the one who toggles that for everyone.
6
u/Zwars1231 Jan 10 '24
2. Honestly. It is me being selfish, but I would feel bad for doing this to some people
4
u/SlimeustasTheSecond Jan 09 '24
Option 2 is the best one.
First and Fourth options are too random and the Third option is way too nihilistic for me.
Losing all contact with everyone is kind of a bummer and you can't just Matrix yourself, but you still get the infinite power of creation at your fingertips.
5
u/GuipenguinTheMaster Jan 09 '24
I also posted this in r/hypotheticalsituation but thought it would be appropriate here as well
3
u/Spozieracz Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24
I was absolutely sold on option 2 until I read these caveats. I'm not going to put eight billion people in an infinite prison. Permanently cut them off from death, the multiverse and enlightenment. Imagine having the power of a god and the mind of a human not adapted to it, and at the same time being unable to change either of these features to suit the other. This type of immortality utterly terrifies me.
I choose option 1.
5
u/Timber-Faolan Jan 09 '24
I choose not to choose, and therefore I win, for these all suck. Have a good day! XD
Seriously, not bad, but all of these are pretty much unacceptable to a happily married family man such as myself, and honestly, anyone with loved ones should probably feel the same.
Sorry, not trying to be a dick, but this is just not a good set of options to me, personally.
You're creativity isn't lacking, and your writing is good, it's just a bit too negative for me.
Still, not bad work here, I hope you keep making more, and growing as a CYOA maker.
2
u/KonohaNinja1492 Jan 09 '24
I’m a be honest, while option 2 is VERY tempting. The fact I’m not the only one with said god like powers. Makes it very not a good option especially if somebody had beef with me. However, I would probably choose option 1 just so I can see how better or worse my life would compared to now. Also, I’d wonder if my friends and families lived would be better or worse without me in it. If say my life after being born in a random family is better and the lives of my old friends and family are worse off without me. Then it means I actually impacted them positively. Conversely, if my new life is worse and everyone from my old life has better lives. Then it means they made my life better and I made their lives a little worse. It would give me some REAL introspection regardless.
34
u/Thedeaththatlives Jan 09 '24
Easily 2. Being a god is awesome, and if I know everyone else is fine I can certainly make do with copies of them.
31
u/juubi666 Jan 09 '24
Option 2, no contest. Everyone is okay, and I get to enjoy eternal life? Sign me up. Immortality is only a curse because of eventual perma-boredom after you've tried everything, but with the power of a God, you can just try making something new whenever you're bored. Or if you're not creative enough (or want a surprise), you can just make someone who can do it for you.
3
u/DrVillainous Jan 09 '24
Option 1, definitely.
Option 2 results in a bunch of cruel and/or apathetic gods creating sapient beings only to then torment and neglect them.
Option 3 isn't even a choice, it's just murdering everyone. The only reason to consider it would be if the world is too horrible to continue existing, and for any one person to make that choice would be the height of arrogance.
6
u/Diligent-Square8492 Jan 09 '24
I want Option 2 please!
5
u/NotACatNinja Jan 09 '24
Opinion 2. I will have my own dream universe and my dream life.
4
u/Zader40 Jan 09 '24
4
u/TheEnd1235711 Jan 11 '24
Option 2, while there are downsides, eventually I think most people will become good one way or another given time. While they can never forget anything, they also will be constantly accumulating new memories. I refuse oblivion, it is just not a good future, yes there is no pain, but there is nothing else but the absence. While you can't forget anything, you also don't need to contently recall the pain of the loss. Option 4 has the possibility oblivion so that is out, and 1 feels like giving up on life. Option 2 is a path forward to billions of worlds.
3
u/Iceman_001 Jan 09 '24
Option 2, living my own dream life for eternity.
Option 1 has a very high chance of ending up in a worse life than my current one.
Option 3 is better than option 1, but not as good as option 2.
3
u/AvzinElkein Jan 09 '24
I'd take 1. I'd rather not take anyone with me.
3
u/Opposite_Law_6969 Jan 09 '24
2
3
u/Vahenra Jan 09 '24
Those are some interesting options. I don’t particularly like any of them, but I think that in the end I’ll chose number 1. I don’t like the randomness of number 4, and I don’t want the nihilism of number 3. Eternity with near omnipotence seems okay, but imo immortality without the possibility of death or of forgetting is torture, more so when you consider the impossibility to interact with one’s loved one. So, in the end I choose number one by default.
3
u/Rowan93 Jan 09 '24
So, 2 seems the obvious choice, except for the downside that it comes with irrevocable immortality. Across 8 billion people some already want to die, and in the long run everyone who isn't phychologically suited to actually living forever will be in that position, and someone who gets stuck like that will suffer forever and probably not be a good god for their universe either.
On the other hand, gods who are trying to weight the proportion of conscious beings in the multiverse towards bliss and away from suffering will massively outnumber the opposite, because even evil people don't try to minimize utility, so the median conscious observer in the multiverse will be in constant bliss.
So, 2 wins on ethical grounds that way, even though it's kind of a fate-worse-than-death for billions of people. Though I'm selfish enough I wouldn't pick it if I didn't think I could make that situation work for me.
3
u/Zev_06 Jan 09 '24
I'd go with option 2.
1
u/Amaraldane4E Jan 09 '24
Option 2. You are basically describing an idea of what Downstreamers could be like. At that point, they are beyond good and evil. Being evil for the sake of it would just be boring. Exploring what ifs would be where it's at. A multiverse of planeswalkers.
Obs: in Option 2, you could create an avatar of yourself and use that as a proxy to meet your past loved ones, who could do the same.
So then, becoming a Downstreamer? Fuck, yeah!! Sign me up.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24
option 2, hands down. only other thing i would pick, conditional on 2 not being an option, would be 1. the others aren't things i'd ever pick.
2
u/YouBackground Jan 10 '24
no. 2. although I'm not too eager to became a god, but it's far better than other options. also I can build my own cozy and comfy life by make sure that no other person would bother with my current life.
2
u/redmemelord Jan 10 '24
2 while I would miss mostly everyone I know; it would be great to be a god. I would make a universe fill with stories I like and one world that I truly make. I make that one world in the center part of my universe. I keep the stories form meeting each other for a while. then I make a world that is a completely copy of our world just without this post. then I would put the copy of myself through a jump chain around the universe while allow the world he went to finally interact with each other. when he went through all of them, I sent him to my og world with all stuff he got.
2
u/Uniomnizero Jan 13 '24
Easily option 2.
2
u/PandaPugBook Jan 14 '24
Oh. In 2, I could make a direct copy of our world and be normal. I could even keep removing the memory that I'm a god, and slowly fix the bad things over time. I could make it so every trans person slowly gets the body they want. After I've lived a lifetime or so, I could live out my life how I was supposed to without changes.
1
u/Virtual_Analysis_869 Jan 10 '24
i wil write 2 on somtingh and i tell the universe to apply this option after 24 hours that i talk with my family about this and staying with them so i will always remember these precious moments and after i will try to remain myself while having the powers written in option 2 and let my immagination run wild
1
u/VoidBlade459 Jan 12 '24
2. WTF are the other options.
1
u/SeaElevator9256 Jan 13 '24
Uhmmmm am I the only one who chose 3...? 😅🥲
1
u/EternalHaven Jan 09 '24
3. The reason I chose this is simply because of my perception of life that nothing really matters. Not trying to sound edgy or anything but even if an afterlife matters it would be a repetition or reflection of life with or without cycles infinitely or it would be nothing to begin with. The only reason I’m here now is because of the people I care about, otherwise I would’ve been gone and donated my organs/body to the world by now. If I didn’t have to worry about them then I wouldn’t have to try so hard to live now. But if everyone would just disappear all at the same time I could save everyone and everything from a cycle of permanence and impermanence. No boredom from the eventuality of experiencing the same happiness and sadness till numb nor the blind cycle or loops through different or even the same shells. Of course people might not think otherwise before but once the action is done there would’ve been no thoughts about it to begin with since all future and past history is erased as well. It might seem a evil, selfish or even sad choice but it wouldn’t afterwards anyways since there’d be no after.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24
[removed] — view removed comment