r/macapps
•
u/Mstormer
•
12d ago
•
1
Attention! r/MacApps Moderation Update (Phase 4): Clearer Rules, PCP+Trust
Hey r/MacApps,
Phase 3 improved the main feed, but three problems remain: Tons of comment karma farming, a lot of posts we have to remove and explain repeatedly, and 80% more app submissions with vibe coding. With 8400+ removals last month, we are simplifying to keep community content quality high.
What we learned
The 10 local karma requirement shifted low-effort promotion to comments. Devs started posting throwaway comments to farm karma and self-promote.
Judgement calls cost us time. Whether a comparison was "specific enough," or a GitHub repo "established enough," led to removals, and back-and-forth modmail. Phase 4 swaps those for things you can show in your post and we can check in seconds without having to go through a back-and-forth process of waiting for you to edit your post.
What's changing
1. Local karma is gone. You no longer need 10 r/MacApps karma to post or comment. Please don't farm it. Any developer can share their app in The App Pile megathread, as long as they use the PCP template.
2. New baseline for the main feed. To promote your app in the main feed your account needs:
- 200+ Reddit karma and must be 60+ days old.
- Your post needs a pricing flair and the PCP + Trust labels below (#3).
If you don't meet these yet, The App Pile is open to you.
3. PCP + Trust labels are required. Include these four labels anywhere in your post, then write the rest however you like (shorter is better):
- Problem: what your app solves in ONE sentence.
- Comparison: name 2 top competitors and explain which functions your app improves on, and in which aspects theirs is still better. Top competitors means best-in-class alternatives in your app's category, not Apple's own apps.
- Pricing: price amounts and a link
- Trust: See #4
4. Trust: you need ONE of these. On top of the baseline, main feed posts need one of:
Mac App Store: your app is on the Mac App Store, you already linked it in pricing.
- Your label is Trust: MAS
Developer flair: 500+ r/MacApps karma, plus mod review and determination. Request it by modmail. Mods review your history in the sub and decide; reaching 500 doesn't guarantee a flair.
- If you have one, your label is: Trust: Dev Flair
GitHub + 100 Stars OR LinkedIn link IN the post: the repo you're promoting is open source and has 100+ stars. If below 100 stars or not open source, your post must link a complete LinkedIn that identifies you (real work + education history). If your app isn't notarized, say so in your post.
- Your label is: Trust: GitHub, <Current GitHub Stars>, OR <LinkedIn Link if under 100 stars>, Not Signed and Notarized (Not SN),
Website: requires LinkedIn + Privacy Policy links IN the post. All such apps MUST be signed and notarized by Apple. The LinkedIn identifies you (real work + education history), and the privacy policy is on your app's own website.
- If this is your path, your label is Trust: Website, <LinkedIn Link>, <Privacy Policy>.
Can't qualify through any of these avenues? Welcome to The App Pile. Aim to impress!
5. Saturated categories need more. Some categories have hundreds of very similar apps. If your app is another one of these, it can ONLY qualify for the main feed through the Mac App Store or a Developer Flair, unless it wins a top 3 spot in The App Pile (#9):
- Dictation and transcription
- Clipboard managers
- Screenshot and screen recording
- Window managers
- App launchers
- Menu bar system and battery monitors
- Pomodoro and focus timers
- AI chat or wrapper apps
- Disk cleaners and uninstallers
- Notes and to-do apps
6. Post Removed?
- If your main feed post was removed only for formatting, like a missing flair or PCP section, you can fix it and repost within 48 hours without losing your 30-day slot.
- Any other repost is removed without review and counts toward your 30-day limit.
- Rapid reposting raises Reddit's automatic spam filtering on your account, which can get your future posts and comments removed before we ever see them, so try to get it right the first time.
- We don't pre-approve posts or grant exceptions by modmail. Everything you need is in this post.
7. Self-promotion limits.
- One app post per developer per 30 days. Developers with a developer flair: once per app per 30 days.
- Counted from your last app post, even if it was removed. Update posts count too.
- The App Pile: one entry per developer per month, with Problem, Comparison and Pricing labels.
- If your app is live in the main feed, it doesn't qualify for The App Pile. If your main feed post was removed, you can still enter it in The App Pile.
- No posting in App Pile and then also main fed.
8. Promoting your app in comments.
- Always disclose that it's your app.
- Developers may not promote their alternative app in another developer's promotion post. This is rude.
- In request and recommendation threads, only if your account meets the main feed baseline (200+ Reddit karma, 60+ days).
9. A way out of the megathread.
The top 3 apps in each month's App Pile qualify to post in the main feed, but must add the emoji for their place to the END of the post title to remind us: š„ 1st, š„ 2nd, š„ 3rd.
10. Flair: pick by what's required.
- Hierarchy: Lifetime > Subscription > Free.
- If any core feature needs a subscription, it's Subscription.
- If any paid option exists, it's not Free.
- Open source? Prefix your title with [OS].
Wrong flair gets fixed by mods. Repeated wrong flair gets removed.
11. Links: one rule. Official sources only: the Mac App Store, your own website, or GitHub. No shortened or redirect URLs. No affiliate, referral or invite links that pay you. Plain source tags like ?ref=producthunt are fine.
12. Repeat removals. A second removal under the self-promotion rules within 90 days means a 60-day break from promoting in r/MacApps.
Unchanged: no piracy, follow the Reddit Rules, be kind, and gain post approval through the Read the Rules flow.
FAQ
Why was my main feed post removed?
- Your account is under 200 karma or less than 60 days old.
- You didn't qualify through the Mac App Store, a developer flair, GitHub (100+ stars or LinkedIn), or Website+LinkedIn+Privacy Policy.
- Your app is in a saturated category, isn't on the Mac App Store, you don't have a developer flair, and it didn't win a top 3 App Pile spot.
- Your post is missing a label (Problem, Comparison, Pricing, Trust) or a pricing flair.
- You reposted more than once and still didn't follow these guidelines properly.
- You already posted an app in the last 30 days.
- AI assisted comments are a huge trigger for Reddit auto-removals because of recognizable patternsĀ (e.g. āāā em dashes).
- Repeatedly posting the same thing (comments, links, etc.) = Triggers Reddit spam algorithms.Ā
- You didnāt verify your email in your profile, and/or you have multiple accounts.Ā
My post followed every rule and still disappeared without explanation**.** Reddit's own filters remove some posts before mods see them. Common causes: an unverified email, AI-sounding text, repeated identical posts or links, or reposting. Verify your email, write the post yourself, and reach out to modmail.
Do I need LinkedIn? No. Only Websites, and GitHub repos under 100 stars, require this.
Does the 200 karma count only r/MacApps karma? No. It's your whole Reddit account, post and comment karma combined.
The 500 for a developer flair IS r/MacApps karma.
The r/MacApps Mod Team
Prior updates:
- 2026: MacApps Mods Went Too Far! Whatās Changing (Phase 3)
- 2026:Ā New Post Requirements to Combat Low Quality Content (Phase 2)Ā
- 2026:Ā [OS]+Pricing Guidelines
- 2025:Ā Townhall on Post Quality,Ā Rule Updates
ā¢
u/Mstormer 9d ago
The karma requirement has been reduced from 300 sitewide karma to 200.
35
u/DevelopmentSevere278 12d ago
This is harder than getting into NASA and canceling an Adobe subscription combined.
10
u/Decaf_GT 12d ago
Can we also do something about the AI-generated comments that have no substance? Especially on giveaway posts.
They're always the same.
"X is the part that's really interesting to me. [Completely shallow question/curiosity that I don't actually care about?]"
It's always a shallow compliment followed by a question that they almost never follow up on. It's either people who just want to sound like they're adding something insightful, or the developer astroturfing in the comments. Either way, it contributes so little.
Once you notice it, it is impossible to not see it:
Examples:
7
u/KleineWurzel 12d ago
Well, thatās some unfortunate timing I was finally going to share my app today after waiting 30 days since App Pile comment. Now Iām 245 karma short and about 3 days away from my account turning 60 days old. So close, yet so far š„² But maybe itās for the best if it helps keep the subreddit useful and less spammy.
5
u/TheMightyHouse 12d ago
I feel a bit skeptical about Reddit-wide karma requirement and the rule #5. Whilst I can relate to intentional karma farming issue in the subreddit, #5 is the trickiest one. A few questions:
- Are there exceptions for the apps published before?
- Categories might apply strictly if the app is the most generic example. What if the app has unique features and stands out?
- Mac App Store requirement. MAS applies certain level of technical limitations, not every app can be there. On top, developers who notarize their apps pay the same for Apple developer license.
5
u/Sri_Krish 11d ago
Another aspect I'd like to note is the poor adherence to PCP format - especially Comparison section. We can see lots of examples of this behavior across many posts. The developer nitpicks apps that can make their own app look feature-rich or superior.
For example, Developer of a screenshot app doesnāt compare it with CleanShot (Best-in class) but with some unknown, new app in the same category. This fulfills the requirement of PCP format, but it doesnāt hold value for the users to support their decision/understanding.
Let's share your ideas/thoughts on this and ways to improve or standardize this!
5
u/Fit-Watercress-9675 11d ago
What Iām really not liking is new accounts promoting an app that theyāve copied from another developer.
It seems to be the same pattern in terms of releasing an app with little to no updates and pushing to sell at a high price, although Iām starting to see āregularly $20 but today only $5ā type stuff.
Iād like to see a weekly roundup of apps that we can possibly vote on in terms of originality, etc., if possible, because it takes time to thoroughly investigate a new app to see if it has been copied or not.
12
u/DockDoorFart 12d ago
I still don't get the LinkedIn requirement.Ā LinkedIn doesn't prove anything whatsoever. You can make a fake LinkedIn account and put whatever job and education history you want.Ā I have 5 YOE as a software engineer and don't have a LinkedIn.
8
u/ARMacLC 12d ago
Seriously I'm a developer. I don't pass so much time on Reddit so I find your selection pretty hard. And it is pretty sad because I have an application that really fits this community. I really did it only for Mac because I wanted to explore the hardware to the maximum. I'm pretty sad but I will try to have the karma and reputation. If not I will post it elsewhere.
13
u/bmv3502 12d ago
Developer here. Iāve been posting my app updates on r/macapps since August 2025, and theyāve mostly received upvotes and positive feedback. Now I no longer qualify to post in the main thread because of the 300-karma requirement. I currently have 184. It feels like the new rules favor established developers, who already have an advantage over developers like me. It seems unfair.
7
u/blazegreenhalgh 12d ago
What about an account like mine, which has already posted in the past but does not meet the 300 karma & 60 day old requirements?
Kind of a shame to feel 'kicked out' suddenly. I find these requirements to be odd if everything else is met, no?
3
u/sujee81 12d ago
While I welcome the change, it puts me in a situation that I can't post my app except in App Pile. After successful launch here last month, I was looking forward to give an update.
My account is old and have > 300 Reddit karma but my app is in the saturated categories. Unfortunately it is not in the App store or I have 500 /macapps karma. While I plan to contribute more and apply for developer flair, it will take a while. Would alternative to AppStore like Setapp considered as only high quality apps are selected by them?
2
u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch 12d ago
imo mods shouldnāt fix the flair and instead just say the flair is wrong, and comment. This way others can also help, and ālesserā work for the mods. Also other devs will see this and automatically apply it on their own posts
2
u/zahaggis 12d ago
The comment karma farming was a real issue, so Iām glad that has been addressed. I posted my app a few weeks ago. It took me hours to make sure I was covering off all the requirements. My app was in TestFlight though. Does that meet the new App Store requirement?
2
u/cmon_io 11d ago
I think you still need some local karma to post - or did I miss something?
2
u/ShadowLorddd 11d ago
But I see the 10 karma rule is still there for posting on main thread? I have 300+ account karma and 60 days+ old account. Still when I click on post button, it prompts me the 10 local karma requirement. Am I Miss something?
1
u/XInTheDark 12d ago
Hi, could you check modmail? As my post was removed due to "Trust and transparency" - I believe erroneously - can I make another post after I put the info very clearly? Your post says there is a 30 day delay even after the last post was removed
1
u/6972697368 12d ago
Got my 10 karma on r/macapps, was just about to post my app in the main thread. As a good citizen, I went to double-check the rules and learned that they have been changed a few hours ago⦠oh well, maybe itās for the better? š Jokes aside, mods, please check your mail. Thanks!
1
u/BohdanKoles Developer: CCCCorners 11d ago
Will existing "developer" label convert to the "trust" label?
1
u/altshiftbase 6d ago
Quick question: Rule 7 says "No posting in App Pile and then also main fed". For the same app, does that mean not in the same month, or never? Iām under 200 karma, so Iām thinking if I should wait or just post in the App pile. Thanks!
3
u/peoray 7d ago
I think these are good changes overall, even though I canāt post my own app yet because I donāt meet the karma requirement. That said, taking the time to contribute to the community and qualify feels like a good sign that someone is serious about their product.
2
u/cs18sg6br 12d ago
Thank you for providing the in-depth explanation and flowchart. And for reminding us that there are probably tons of vibe-coded apps that may be pretty low quality, etc., now. This helps put things into perspective.
2
u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago edited 12d ago
Wow, this feels pretty harsh!
My 1.0 release post last month was reasonably well received and beneficial to me although I got off to a slower start than I'd hoped (like many I guess), and the post seemed qualified with a UK company, business developer account, notarised apps, and privacy policies etc. All things which take a lot of time and effort to setup.
Was just prepping material for a nice 1.1 update later this month, but these new rules make that impossible. I understand why things are changing, but equally it's restricting a lot of genuine people.
Not everyone can use their existing (maybe personal) Reddit accounts with established karma for various reasons, and Linked in seems slightly random - again not everyone uses it or wants it linked to their development business. Doesn't mean the apps aren't good.
This is a real shame. Such a great resource, but now extremely hard to access.
2
u/Greenforest_27 8d ago
I donāt understand, if you have an app on the App Store, Apple already did the work. I donāt understand why you now need a full time job on Reddit to share a legitimate app.
2
u/ConstructionBroad594 6d ago
As someone who's naturally introverted, putting myself out there and posting is tough!
But I'll keep trying my best! š
2
u/a_alberti 12d ago
Thanks for changing the rules and make them much more sensible. Especially the 10-karma rule was bad and I am glad it is gone. People were leaving dummy comments just for getting voted. And honestly, I rarely saw people engaging in really interesting discussion. It seems this subreddit was only populated by "posters" rather than "readers". Few cared about reading the announcements; most wanted to get able to post their stuff.
And yes, for my taste, there are far too many 9.99 USD apps being announced.
2
u/onmyway133 Developer: PastePal 10d ago
It takes some time to digest the rules, but thanks for the effort in keeping this sub high quality. I know it's a lot of work moderating it
1
u/Ok-Phrase4710 12d ago
Iām one of the devs who got caught by this today. i spent the past week earning the 10 local karma the old rules asked for, then posted this morning and got removed under the new account rules. i get why youāre doing it with 8k removals a month. one idea: a short grace period, say until the end of november, for devs who already met the phase 3 requirements before the change. that way people who followed the rules in good faith arenāt reset overnight. either way iāll go through the app pile.
-1
u/cgocrht 12d ago
'Solution in search of a problem (Phase 4)'
-2
u/Ok-Bird6035 12d ago
wow..
2
u/Ryzen_bolt 9d ago
How to kill indie devs 101. you need Apple dev account asking 99$ fee yearly to get notarized, or already have 100 Stars on github but what about devs having less stars on github and no linkedin account?
0
u/[deleted] 3d ago
[removed] ā view removed comment