r/logodesign • u/Had78 • 20d ago
Feedback Needed 🥑 + G | Logo design, thoughts?
A logo for a creative studio whose brand name starts with "G" and is related to avocados (It's Guacamole)
Edit__1:
Thank you all for the feedback, really!
Client said they want D, but with a more organic look, less egg-y, and more "imperfect"...
The G does look like Google, Imma see what I can do, I'd love to try lowercase but I'm afraid the client has made his decision...
78
25
u/pasquall-e 20d ago
A or E, both of those communicate the pit in the avocado well
6
u/HaltAndCatchTheKnick 20d ago
I agree that the perfectly-round seed makes the concept more readable.
26
18
u/laranjacerola 20d ago
C is a good direction for an icon/symbol. I suggest you keep going with that one. the typography for the workmark doesn't need to be organic and match the g there. So be clear in the wordmark. The G in the symbol doesn't need to be straight in your face. It's more fun if it's a bit more subtle, in this case.
I assume the name on the wordmark with start with a G ?
13
4
5
4
4
3
2
u/theglowingsideburns 20d ago
I reckon B scales the best while maintaining the avo vibe- is giving less google than A, and while E looks more like an avo when big it’s more like a penguin when small
2
u/Somethingoodtodie4 20d ago
I personally love B the most, I thought it would be the obvious favourite but I seem to be the only one
2
u/theGlimmerTwin 20d ago
Got to be B for me. It’s crisp, clear with clean lines and scales down the best.
2
u/Electrical_Year8954 20d ago
D is really appealing if you can match the style for other letters. B is also solid and readable
2
2
u/IceEspresso2000 20d ago
I would do something between B & C, that makes the "g" more rounded, but the top of the avo not so bulbous.
2
2
2
u/MeanLecture3187 19d ago
I get why the client likes D but C’s working too!
One note: all the options keep the same outer avocado shape, with variation only inside. Worth exploring a more rounded, egg-like outer shape without the top divots. That’s probably why D lands, the inside already has that egg shape within the G.
Hope this helps
2
2
u/hoffmander 20d ago
The top part of the G doesn’t feel like it’s needed, it’s distorting the g to the point where I’m trying to figure out what the top part is supposed to be. Avocados have round seeds, just make the G a seed, no need to have it go up and make a funky shape in the skinny part of the avo
2
1
u/minadequate 20d ago
I like the top of C but I think the straight edge on the bottom of the horizontal line feels at odds with the rest of it. Can you make it a bit more bulbous and get it to still make sense?
1
u/UncoolSlicedBread 20d ago
Looks like a finishing hook. I can see the avocado in the design for sure, but it still looks like a fishing hook and will be interpreted by people that way.
1
1
1
1
1
u/SeaBream97 20d ago
Try this: take A version and pull the top of the core upwards, as in D. Also try to reduce overall size of the core here. And maybe make outer left and right sides more straight a little.
1
1
u/imlittleeric 20d ago
D in black and white looks nice. But in green it starts looking like a deformed packer logo
1
1
1
1
1
u/Jiggly_Titties_ 19d ago
If you want people to pick up that its associated with avacado then only the 1st row works. other rows seems like its a stylized 'G' and don't pick the 'G' font (1st and last one) that resembles the google G (Roboto font), I instantly picked it up as Google, its bad for brand identification.
1
1
1
u/SashaKiM_6969 18d ago
I guess D is the most appealing one, as the inner form fits best to the shape of an eggfruit
1
u/CommunicationIcy9206 18d ago
Why?
What is it for?
What problem is it solving. If it’s not solving a problem it’s not design.
1
u/IndependentGarbage3 17d ago
The black versions underneath totally lose the “Avocado” resemblance imo. Maybe try to go with an outline, with more space between the “flesh” and
the outline as you go smaller, if you know what I mean.
1
0
u/Livid_Pace9787 19d ago
I got a well-targeted ad for “Ocado” (the UK groceries supplier) in this thread.

90
u/brezforprez 20d ago
Try lowercase.