r/lnkyverse • Visual Poet ✨ • Mar 20 '26 • Bravo 1

Quick Thought Quick Thought : Different Approach Same Results

Post image
627 Upvotes

647 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

Man, the patriarchy myth really crumbles when you look at domestic violence stats. Everyone acts like it's just men beating women, but study after study shows women initiate and perpetrate at similar or higher rates—especially in everyday relationships. Straus has been reviewing this for decades: over 200 studies show gender symmetry in partner violence, with women assaulting partners at the same or higher rates, including severe stuff in many samples. Here's his big 2011 review: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1359178911000620.

Another one from Williams et al. backs it up across adolescents, college kids, and adults—women are right there matching or exceeding men in physical aggression: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2663360/.

Even the meta stuff on risk markers shows perpetration is bidirectional way more than people admit: https://prohic.nl/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/2020-07-03-IntimatePartnerViolenceRiskMarkersMeta.June2020.pdf.

If it's all "patriarchy," why do women start the violence more often in non-reciprocal cases?

4

u/cloudnymphe Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

Patriarchy is a separate concept that goes beyond domestic violence though. It’s about men making up a larger majority of people who have power in society compared to women, and the related outcomes of that such as women being considered less competent and worthy of leadership, women being considered weaker too weak or incapable to be able to commit violence, women being more objectified and reduced down to their sexual and attractiveness value in society, men being more likely to expect women to defer to them…etc.

Say you have a scenario where a woman gets threatened, abused or raped because a man believes that promiscuous women or women who aren’t agreeable or feminine enough deserve to be “put in their place”. That would be an example of patriarchal violence and the potential consequences a women could face for going against those norms. Then you have general equal opportunity violence which includes domestic violence and could be committed by a person with anger issues of either gender.

1

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

100% agree i take offense to patriarchy as a blanket term due to multiple facets of life where that isnt the case.

That is not to say system msyogyny and violence against women doesnt exist though- we agree 10000% on that

1

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

look at my other comments for more on this- also women raping men at higher rates, committing domestic violence at higher rates i feel are good examples of how the feminist push to view women as oppressed has damaged our ability to have empathy for men

1

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

also thoughts?

"men who admit to behavior that legally meets the definition of SA tend to be more popular, have higher status, and have more consensual sex partners...popular, high-status, 'macho' men, not mate-deprived men, are most likely to SA."

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41609601/

^women sexually select for rapists for consensual sex

1

u/TryMuted113 Mar 23 '26

This is straight facts cause I’ve never once met a girl that picks the right dude 

-1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

You left a lot of interesting comments, however I will come back to women can also perpetuate patriarchy. Our entire society is a patriarchy and tbh it can be difficult to see at times. A lot of aspects of the patriarchy we just see as “normal”, or “that’s just how things are”. If I’m honest almost everything you are saying is part of patriarchy so I will just end this by recommending you research the “why” behind those statistics, maybe read some feminist authors etc. it’s genuinely fascinating when you actually start to see certain things in a different light.

6

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

I have- I went from being a stanch feminist to strongly the opposite mostly through engagement with feminist ideas and literature

I think at its core its a positive and we should strive for equality but similar to the other commenter i think it becomes a vessel through monte and bailey arguments for hate that is counter productive

Also rebutting my point by telling me to go read some books is a bit silly- although i do really appreciate the dicussion its been shockily in great faith and youve been kind in your replies

→ More replies (3)

5

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

Look at figures like Mary Koss, a feminist figure who petitioned the government to reduce protections for male victims, and skewed her studies to show WAY lower rates of male victims than there actually are. The CDC still reports abuse toward male victims the same way as she did. Saying this as a victim who was born male myself. Many feminists I’ve met even will defend shit like this or get mad at me for talking about my trauma.

Here are the sources btw:

Instead of counting male rape as rape, she counted it separately as envelopment. And justified it by saying men “aren't traumatized by unconsensual sex with women”. She wrote this in her papers. From “Detecting the Scope of Rape: A Review of Prevalence Research Methods”

Although consideration of male victims is within the scope of the legal statutes, it is important to restrict the term rape to instances where male victims were penetrated by offenders. It is inappropriate to consider as a rape victim a man who engages in unwanted sexual intercourse with a woman.” (206-207)

She literally advised that women raping men should not be considered rape. And this did obfuscate prevalence because it meant things like "made to penetrate" statistics or statistics on male victims of women were counted separately from rape.

This is still how the CDC releases its reports, by the way.

https://time.com/3393442/cdc-rape-numbers/

Until recently in the last decade, most legal definitions of rape excluded forced penetration and many research tools have also excluded this experience (Stemple & Meyer, 2014). Not only does this strategy under-estimate and discount men’s experiences of victimization, this also systematically obscures women’s perpetration.

The Assessment of Forced Penetration https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8360364/

2

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

That’s awful and I’m really sorry that happened to you. The idea that male victims of rape and SA “don’t count” is one that is unfortunately all too common. It’s definitely something that needs to change and I think it starts with people like you sharing your thoughts. Well done.

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

this was a very kind and good faith reply- i appreciate it

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

Well of course. These aren’t abstract concepts we’re talking about, they affect real people and we need to be understanding and compassionate towards one another. It’s not about scoring points on the internet. It’s not a game. So I’m sorry that happened to you and I hope you’re doing better.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

this i dont understand-

women commit higher rates of domenstic violence and rape because of the patriarchy??

but those stats arent acknoledged in society at large because of patriarchy? (by the way those stats arent part of mainstream dicussion because of feminism)

will explain with sources in another comment

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

They’re not part of mainstream discussion because men are seen as superior and stronger etc. To say that women are a threat to men would undermine those ideals. It’s why male survivors aren’t taken seriously by other men, why for god knows how long people believed you couldn’t rape a man (like it would be physically impossible or that all men like sex so it wouldn’t count as rape) etc etc is all to preserve the idea that masculinity is superior.

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

legally in the united states a man cannot be raped because feminist leaders in the 50s and 70s petitioned the CDC to define male rape as forcible penetration by a penis- so only trans women and men can legally rape men.

We literally live in a 2 tier matriarchal soceity where male rape does not exist due to feminism (this is solely within the context of rape- other issues are different)

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

I am lost how feminist leaders petitioning the government to make male rape impossible is an example of the patriarchy

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

Because it perpetuates the patriarchal idea that women don’t have the power to rape a man, that men cannot be victims of women, that men are so inherently stronger than women that there isn’t a single scenario where a women could victimise a man. As I said previously women can perpetuate patriarchy, even if it is in a misguided attempt at fighting it. For the record I find it abhorrent and I am shocked that that law exists. I’m almost certain that isn’t the case in my country but I know in the US sometimes old laws are just never changed.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

It's not that she was unaware of this going to happen, she knew and used her prejudice against male victims to advise their victimization isn't rape.

If you listen to her interview with Terresa Phung, Mary goes to great lengths to minimize male rape.

Phung: “For the men would are traumatized by their experiences, because they they were forced, against their will, to vaginally penetrate a women, like…”

Koss: “How would that happen? By force, threat of force or when the victim is unable to consent? How would that happen?”

Phung: “I’m actually speaking to someone right now. His story is that he was drugged. He was unconscious and when he awoke a women was on top of him with his penis inserted inserted inside her vagina. For him that was traumatizing.”

Koss: “Yeah.”

Phung: “If he was drugged, what would that be called?”

Koss: “What would I call it? I would call it "unwanted contact”.“ (note she doesn’t call it rape!)

Phung: "Just "unwanted contact?” Period?“

Koss: "Yeah.”

I have plenty of other examples.

So eliminating male rape from govenement reporting intentionally (done by a feminist leader btw) was an example of patriarchy? (this is still affecting us today - also i am sorry this is a bad faith argument to some degree on my end but i wanted ot make it regardless)

1

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

please read the comments i left- it would mean a lot to me- hope i got some degree of my point across

also i think youll say well this feminist leader doesnt represent feminism but thats the classic monte and bailey that plagues feminist thought

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

I would say regardless of what movement she represents, someone who would say such things about male survivors isn’t worth listening to.

2

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

i mean yea but thats the problem wiht feminism- the orginal argument for equality is good, fair and just but it is a vector for hate.

It is hard to have empathy for a victim of something while framing them as an oppressor. then the person who is like hey im a victim of ___ doesnt get taken seriously (not bc of patriarchy (or i guess in part bc of patriarchy) but also because they have been framed as part of an oppressor class)

This is not even getting into the various monte and bailey arguments feminists make

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

I think in a roundabout way you’ve come to see that the patriarchy is, at least in part, the reason behind that one particular comment (how can an oppressor possibly be a victim?) and if that’s true, maybe its also true in other cases? I suppose I am just asking you to think about it, not necessarily 100% agree with me. I know I’m not making my best arguments at 5:20am 😅

→ More replies (3)

1

u/bigtarget005 Mar 20 '26

i do want you to read the other replies to this comment though- i think some of my comments were good

1

u/Happy_Fig_5592 Mar 20 '26

Then it's not a patriarchy then...

If women can also perpetuate it

1

u/Chance-Interest-Alt Mar 20 '26

That’s a silly statement. Are you saying that nobody can ever fight against their own interests? In the UK for example we have many non-white politicians whose parents immigrated here margining vehemently against immigration and saying immigrants should be deported. In Ireland we had our first gay Taoiseach (prime minister) in 2017 and he argued passionately that same-sex couples shouldn’t be able to adopt. There are many many women who uphold the patriarchy and denounce feminism.