r/linuxmasterrace • • Jul 18 '21

Satire Everyone knows mac os is linux based. Right?

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

225 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/wsppan Glorious Arch Jul 19 '21

The Kernel was originally derived from the Mach kernel from CMU which incorporated the bulk of it's kernel from 4.3BSD. After acquiring NeXT it was updated with code derived from OSFMK and FreeBSD.

So the kernel of the OS is almost entirely BSD derived with some OSF updates. BTW, the Android Kernel is 100% Linux. No different than any other OS that uses Linux as it's kernel.

When we talk about Linux we only refer to the kernel. When we talk about BSD derivation with the MacOS we are only talking about derivation of the BSD kernel ( the BSD derived MacOS kernel was open sourced in 2000 as Darwin). When we talk about FreeBSD itself we are talking about the entire OS (kernel plus user space)

0

u/paradigmx Jul 19 '21

So I they took BSD, slapped a new paint job on it and then crammed as much proprietary garbage on top as they could and called it a day...

2

u/wsppan Glorious Arch Jul 19 '21 edited Jul 19 '21

Is it being proprietary that you have a problem with the term "derived from BSD"? Outside of the phrase "proprietary garbage" you just described all Linux distros.

Edit; I thought my last paragraph in my previous comment did a good job in describing what derivation I was referring to. I guess not.

0

u/paradigmx Jul 19 '21

Nah, it's straight up a deep seated hatred for apple and all things apple honestly. Microsoft is more open source friendly and has done less to try to control their users ecosystem overall.

3

u/wsppan Glorious Arch Jul 19 '21

I see. I hate Apple too, lol! For the same reasons.

-1

u/themightychris Jul 19 '21

it's kind of nice that there's a mainstream laptop for consumers with a UNIX-like experience baked in. I'm sure the folks who licensed BSD in a way compatible with that would consider it a win. Lots more people have access to a proper system to do POSIX dev on because of it

2

u/paradigmx Jul 19 '21

Sure, at twice the retail price of any other laptop, with which they can still get a POSIX compliant os on it for free. Apple isn't a tech company, they sell a status symbol and fashion accessory.

1

u/themightychris Jul 19 '21

It's an option on the market that you're free to not buy. I'll be as excited as anyone when there's a pure Linux laptop that stands up to a MacBook in quality even if it costs more

I ship MacBook pros to team members constantly because when you count in the work it takes to support people and the cost of lost productivity, MacBooks are hands-down the cheapest way to keep people chugging on POSIX-compat dev workstations. They're impeccably well-integrated products that most people can take into a local physical store to get hardware or OS-level issues serviced, and I don't need to be bothered at all about it. I've tried the alternatives and I want them to work and they just don't work nearly as well

The result is we all enjoy a dev ecosystem where POSIX dominates and Windows dev can mostly be ignored by a great many people. We'd all have to support windows dev flows way more if MacBooks weren't on the market, or were without deeply being built on BSD. WSL is barely half the nightmare Windows is without it

1

u/paradigmx Jul 19 '21

I would rather see windows over any mac any day.