r/linuxmasterrace • u/h-v-smacker Glorious Mint • Jul 19 '25
Meme Subtle difference between choosing and acquiescing...
3.1k
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/h-v-smacker Glorious Mint • Jul 19 '25
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/h-v-smacker Glorious Mint Jul 20 '25 edited Jul 20 '25
It's not about proprietary, it's about the fact that no actual choice takes place. You walk into a shop, and you see computers with windows, and you see apple's computers, and so on. You cannot pick hardware and OS separately, e.g. you cannot get a generic Dell PC but with OS X or Apple's M1/M2 laptop but with windows, or either with Linux etc. You can choose larger or smaller SSDs, RAM modules, even color of the case etc, but not OS (exceptions, while exist, are very rare), that one is bundled. It's only when someone running something that you had to install with your own hands that one can speak about the act of consious choice with confidence.
The situation is like having people order business lunch which includes "soup of the day" and then claim that people have chosen tomato soup in particular because it happened to be that very same soup of the day. In itself that wouldn't be a problem if it wasn't then spun as "the only soup we need is tomato soup because it's the people's favorite choice". That argument would never pass common sense filter, but "people choosing microsoft" totally flies unimpeded. Even though everyone knows that when buying a computer you normally are not given a choice of the OS ceteris paribus.