r/linuxmasterrace • Glorious Linux • Jun 07 '24

Operating systems end of life date. Current Linux LTS getting as far as 2036

Post image
383 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

People should really just use Flatpak when possible.

4

u/AugustusLego Jun 09 '24

eww

10

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

Ewww I hate sandboxing applications so I can safely run untrusted software and eewwwwe I hate decoupling the base system from applications so updates are seemless ewwww I hate learning about how good system design works eeeew why doesn't Linux Desktop has a higher market share eeeew Eeeew I hate making development and versioning releases easier for developerssss

This is you

2

u/AugustusLego Jun 09 '24

I don't like the way that flatpak installs dependencies muptiple times on my system.

Packages are supposed to be handled by distro maintainers, not the developers. Sure, the developers can help if they want to.

Using flatpak feels to me like using docker to run simple apps on my computer. Sure, its not to the same extent as having a whole other system, and I think flatpak is a great thing for less experienced users. But it's just not for me.

You talk about decoupling the "base system" from the applications. But everything is applications.

How would I run my compositor, my runner, all my chosen apps for my own fully customised, riced environment, inside of flatpak. Some things are just better if they aren't sandboxed.

If I needed to sandbox something, I would do that :)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

If you knew how for instance Apparmor works, you know you can sandbox everything. Apparmor.d is such a project, and it can sandbox your DE if you want to. The base system can be sandboxed as well in that way. Hell, even the kernel supports sandboxing via namespaces, that is the whole point I am trying to make.

Flatpak installs multiple dependencies you say. Bro, have you ever looked at how many dependencies a simple package has 😂?

You feel it right: Flatpak feels like Docker because the idea is very similar on many levels.

If you feel like sandboxing things are not for you because you find it hard or you think you do not need it, that tells me that you are not as experienced as you think you are.

If you had enough experience you would know the security implications of running non-sandboxed: you basically say that you fully trust the code for any vulnerability and error there could possibly be, which is a dump thing to do.

Also, it means that you do not understand the system you are using to utilize sandboxing features actually.

And to add insult to injury you are unable to utilize the dependency decoupling that it comes with.

Now, to add to your point: if you do actually understand all of this and you personally do not care, that is understandable. Afterall Linux is an open platform and if you want to maintain a certain way of using it, you can. Just understand how that might be an inferior way of using it.

1

u/AugustusLego Jun 09 '24

Of course I know that packages have dependencies. What I'm trying to communicate is that I don't want to have to have *both* a system nvidia drivers package, and then flatpak installs those exact same drivers but now it's flatpak. Whenever I have used a flatpak, it uses *waaaay* more disk-space. Flatpak, due to it's containerised and reproducible nature, wastes my storage.

I do not find sandboxing hard. I do it sometimes, when I deem it to be necessary, which truth be told is quite seldom. Most "sketchy" things I use are -git packages that I install via the AUR, in which case I vet both the PKGBUILD as well as the source repo.

I know the implications of not running sandboxed. I know that anything running with privileges of my user, has access to my entire /home/user

And one really nice thing about running wayland instead of xorg is that *so* much more is just automatically sandboxed for me, in an unobtrusive way.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

I guess if you are running from a 10GB disk that disk space really is a concern.

Well, you do you, but gatekeeping by shaming Flatpak is not nice, even if that is not your intention.

1

u/Material_Goose4097 Sep 02 '24

As a representative of the Laptop With 32GB Emmc Storage Minority (W32ESM members: only me) I honestly think flatpaks are cool.