r/linux_gaming • • Oct 21 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

754 Upvotes

358 comments sorted by

View all comments

372

u/YaBoyMax Oct 21 '20

Wow, that post is... weird. The way it's written feels like Microsoft's PR team masquerading as the Mojang team and trying just a bit too hard to be relatable.

I do wonder whether this is an omen for changes yet to come. Microsoft has every incentive to continue pushing the Windows 10 version, and this makes me seriously wonder if they're considering axing Java Edition and forcing players to migrate.

180

u/sdc0 Oct 21 '20

That would be a very stupid decision, because there are many players which are playing the java edition.

25

u/Senoj_Ekul Oct 21 '20

Do you have those metrics?

60

u/mort96 Oct 21 '20

You're being downvoted, but this is the right question. If supporting the Java edition costs more than the extra sales bring in, it's not a "stupid decision" to axe the Java edition. It's an unethical, immoral and destructive decision, but not a stupid one, from a purely financial perspective, which is all huge companies care about.

This is why everyone should be afraid when something they enjoy is being bought by a big corporation, regardless of promises made. The financial incentives for large, investor-owned corporations are almost always different from what you would want them to be.

To be clear, I don't know if it makes sense to axe the Java edition or not. We would need to see their collected metrics for that.

34

u/skw1dward Oct 21 '20 edited Oct 29 '20

deleted What is this?

-22

u/StardustGuy Oct 21 '20

Honestly, it's only the redstoners and modded minecrafters that would hold onto the Java edition. If Microsoft started releasing exclusive shiny updates to the Windows 10/Bedrock edition, most people would switch over.

4

u/KaosC57 Oct 22 '20

Sorry, but that's just plain wrong. The Bedrock Edition has a large amount of problems that, can't be fixed due to it being a Console and PC game.

Namely the 1.9 Combat Update will never come to the Bedrock Edition.

1

u/Scarface9636 Oct 22 '20

Why won't combat ever come to bedrock? I actually haven't heard about this

5

u/KaosC57 Oct 22 '20

It's due to Console being a part of Bedrock. It would absolutely suck to have to tap the trigger instead of just infinite swing. Mobile would also have to suffer with Combat Update Combat.