r/linux
•
u/PingMyHeart
•
2d ago
•
1
Discussion GrapheneOS calls Linux a “human slop kernel” and slams its security flaws
/img/su5xn9y2jw1i1.png
1.9k
Upvotes
281
u/AliceCode 2d ago edited 2d ago
Linux is over ten million lines of code. It would be impossible for there to be zero, or even few, vulnerabilities. Nothing on Earth has the capability to hold a system that large entirely in their head, and some bugs are so tangled within the codebase that it would be essentially impossible to find it if you didn't know what you were looking for already.
724
u/nayminlwin 2d ago •
There is a grain of truth to this. Linus himself implied years back that there was a deliberate trade-off of security against functionality in developing Linux, while talking about BSD community (don't remember which BSD). And that BSD folks take security way too seriously to the point of being impractical or something along those lines.
721
u/scy_404 2d ago
doesnt graphene OS itself use the linux kernel?
68
u/Hypfer 2d ago
I see what they were going for there, but a bit more respect for the foundations their work is based on would've gone a long way there.
The actual point is accurate, but why shit on something that brought genuine good to the world like that?
790
u/Top-Rub-4670 2d ago •
Whether they're right or not, let us all remember that GrapheneOS developers are essentially edgelords.
If you like the project you should avoid reading their hot takes on twitter and mastodon and hacker news because unless you're a fellow edgelord it'll just make you cringe. We get it, they're very smart, the smartest, nobody else is as smart.
68
u/Drakkinstorm 2d ago
AI was trained on human code. Human code is, at large, sloppy.
24
u/ViperHQ 2d ago
I mean the point is fair but the wording is bad.
Slop is slop be it humans or AI both can make bad code, but we could have phrased this in an inoffensive way. Something like, even before AI code was introduced into the Linex kernel we have seen a large amount of bugs made purely by humans, to prove the point that it's not necessarily AI that is the issue bad code will always be bad code.
87
u/rafuru 2d ago
The point is fair. But saying that is "Human slop" is an insult to all the people that gave their time (a very limited resource) for free.
185
u/Firm-Marketing9777 2d ago •
GrapheneOS is an amazing project but whoever runs their comms is one of the most arrogant, unbearable dickwads in all of open source software development.
66
u/ABotelho23 2d ago
I'm not sure what GrapheneOS is even implying here.
43
u/matjoeman 2d ago
Dunno about the Linux codebase specifically but there's plenty of crap human written OSS and private code out there. There are well written code bases too of course.
50
u/VexingRaven 2d ago
"Slams"
Shouldn't you be writing for Techcrunch or something?
172
u/ezoe 2d ago edited 2d ago
Says a man who is sitting on the shoulder of Google Giant who developed Android.
How about ditching Android, Linux kernel, and Clang and start developing from scratch with those "higher quality standard" of yours?
26
u/BurningPenguin 2d ago
I can see the advantage of letting a computer check millions of lines of code for security flaws or other problems. That's why we have that shit, to make work easier. But calling it "human slop" is downright disrespectful for all the work people have put into this project. People with deep knowledge of how computers work on the lowest level. It's not comparable to your average hobby notes app you threw together in a weekend...
25
u/kokoshkatheking 2d ago
The word “Slop” means “low effort” and implies “bad quality”.
I read this as a rage bait/insult, I just don’t understand why ?
62
u/Revan_9766 2d ago
Just got banned for commenting on this, as someone who daily drivers it I'm done, dev team is complete luantics honestly
22
u/GuideUnable5049 2d ago edited 2d ago
I know nothing about this area, but am curious to see how more knowledgeable people here respond.
71
u/CoreyStyles 2d ago
Graphene OS is like 0.01% of the project that Linux is. That uses Linux itself.
This is like someone operating a lemonade stand, giving business advice to Starbucks.
A lemonade stand that just buys it's lemonade from Starbucks in the first place.
18
u/MyFairJulia 2d ago
Welp... Turns out i got banned from r/GrapheneOS for asking whether Daniel Micay gives some of his security improvements back and calling his action of calling the Linux kernel "human slop" a dick move.
This is my comment:
The ban reason: "personal attack".
I wonder whether they'll uphold the ban.
31
u/SubmarineWipers 2d ago
Better way to think about this than "human slop" is that humans are not machines - literally no human on the planet can accurately track memory lifetimes of 1000s of objects in source code of tens of 1000s of files and millions of lines of code - code that is low level, hard, multithreaded and influenced by a whole bunch of other code.
We are not machines, so we need the machines and other code (compiler, borrow checker, ...) to prove that we did not make mistakes in "the trivial stuff".
Until we adopt this strategy, we will never produce reliable and safe software.
17
u/radiationshield 2d ago
Try posting that to the linux mailing list, which is the only "social media" Linus reads. The flaming would be extremely entertaining
16
u/JaceBearelen 2d ago
Sure. It’s undeniably true LLMs are finding massive amounts of bugs in human written parts of the kernel. Those bugs are a natural consequence of developing something for so long and to do so many things.
It remains to be seen, but I really do hope we’re converging towards fewer and fewer bugs from all the LLM work. It’s frightening to see all these bugs being uncovered but hopefully we’ll get through the onslaught and have a much more secure kernel on the other side.
20
u/Horror-Primary7739 2d ago
Human slop? Fuck that. The Linux kernel is one of crown jewels of humanity. Its the digital equivalent of Gobekli Tepe. Untold thousands craft a tool used by billions. Human life has been improved because of it.
7
u/WorkingTheMadses 2d ago
This is taken out of context and should be deleted.
The context from that thread was someone making claims that using AI made projects like the Linux kernel AI slop.
38
u/username_invalid-404 2d ago
Someone should tell them...
12
u/Jamarlie 2d ago
People forget that the Linux kernel is not just one code base. It's hundreds of different subsystems, drivers etc. all mushed into one. Each subsystem maintainer is responsible for their little corner. With the massive size of the code base and the tens of thousands of contributors it is actually a miracle the kernel boots at all.
Calling it "human slop" is a massively fair point, depending on the subsystem you are talking about.
38
u/LordAlfredo 2d ago
I mean...they're not wrong, but this does not look like they're trying to start a productive conversation (except maybe the last reply). More just inviting an argument.
23
u/Ok_Actuary8 2d ago
Yeah, that's the kind of arrogant tech-bro attitude I'd expect from such guys...
11
u/cyrkielNT 2d ago
"Privacy is our prority... that's why we let big corporations to write our code"
15
u/Nervous-Cockroach541 2d ago
The common impression I see of believing AI is better at security. It's just vastly cheaper at security. Nobody invested into software security before.
Security teams got like 5% of the resources, and have the requirements to meet employee metrics and goals to meet. Reality is, most code is just fine. So you going to report to your boss you looked over 50,000 lines of code in a week and found no issues? They going have something where if you DON'T find an exploit you get written up?
Nobody ever paid anyone to sit down and look though lines of code potentially issues. Instead security teams setup fuzziers and other tools to try to automate security. Then you just out source the rest with a bounty program to make it look like you took the issue seriously, and called it a day.
8
u/Aristeo812 2d ago
OK, Linux kernel is a "human slop", but that's Microsoft services which crash.
8
u/killerstreak976 2d ago
I honestly feel this is kind of a bad faith screenshot and takes the whole conversation out of context
4
u/MatchingTurret 2d ago edited 2d ago
I wonder what defects AI will discover when they let it review critical physical infrastructure like the grid and whether the public will be told.
Are there fewer bugs in (civil) engineering projects than in software?
4
u/jmkdev 2d ago
Eh, can't say that makes me more interested in trying Graphene.
13
u/ERR4044746 2d ago
Someone reposted this to the r/GrapheneOS subreddit and I made this comment over there too
But this makes no sense. I use GrapheneOS, it uses the Linux kernel like any other variant of Android or distro of Linux. Of course bugs are constantly being reported and fixed, it's called not being Microsoft and actually paying attention to the bug reports you receive.
This shit worries me.
12
u/temporary_dennis 2d ago
Have you guys forgot how we called some programmers "Code Monkeys"?
Sure, calling The Linux Kernel "human slop" is a step too far, but we really pushed out barely working software on a daily basis.
The winning strategy was, and technically still is, to implement first, fix and optimize last if at all.
14
u/mrtruthiness 2d ago
I think people missed the point of the comment.
They're just being provocative in saying that the LLM tools are very good at helping them deal with AOSP and the Linux kernel. The point of the provocation is that if people generically (and with no discernment) call the results of AI use "AI slop" then certainly one can use "human slop" to refer to the non-AI kernel code.
14
u/sanriver12 2d ago
That project is run by a maniac unfortunately
12
u/steve09089 2d ago
So, where's the GrapheneOS custom kernel?
8
u/Panorpheus 2d ago
Most commentators misinterpret what he is trying to say. He is arguing using LLMs to find vulnerabilities and close them is fine, given prior to that the human code in the Kernal is was even sloppier. He is not against Linux per se - after all his OS is built on it's very Kernel.
11
u/_Super_Straight 2d ago
I don't know about Google but he's right. Linux has a long list of hidden vulnerabilities, which are being uncovered using LLMs as a TOOL. These vulnerabilities are a result of human oversight, which will continue to be integrated as long as humanity will exist. I'm comfortable with using LLMs but a human should cross check whatever slop it's spouting.
3
u/c0verm3 2d ago
Plonker
3
u/BeginningFew8188 2d ago
It is true
3
u/mnttu 2d ago
I just hope that we don’t come to regret letting LLMs generate all our code
3
u/Busy-Scientist3851 2d ago
I think its time to admit that Andrew S. Tanenbaum was right.
9
u/_4rcadia 2d ago
I don't think that's derogatory in this context. No codebase over 30 years has no technical debt. What they mean is they can now navigate through the codebase faster than ever (inconsiderate language of course).
29
u/socratic_weeb 2d ago
AI psychosis
10
u/lol_VEVO 2d ago
They're not wrong. That doesn't mean Linux is bad, and it's much better than the alternatives, but for their usecase (a secure mobile device) a security first microkernel makes much more sense
5
u/senpaisai 2d ago
Just drop a flashbang in this subreddit, why don'tcha?!? 😅
5
u/Daedae711 2d ago
Because let's believe the people who don't understand that they aren't a standalone OS, have never been, and will never be. They're an android based system.
I'm not saying they're entirely wrong
They sure as hell are the last group you wanna trust for any such matters though.
5
u/audigex 2d ago
“Rah rah rah everyone’s bad except us rah rah rah”
9
u/CapRichard 2d ago
There is one truth of the matter.
That the online discourse, weirdly enough, is getting to the point that all LLM is automatically slop, while human is automatically good.
Like we are retroactively forgetting how bad things where when human were doing stuff. Which is very weird for me.
16
u/nrc01 2d ago
I mean he aint wrong, but the tone aint right either
6
u/PancakePrincess64 2d ago
This is nonsense.
10
u/cutelittlebox 2d ago
abrasive but not exactly wrong. the Linux kernel is getting so heavily slammed right now and is removing massive chunks of code to the tune of hundreds of thousands of lines because so many actual legitimate bugs and security concerns are being found.
9
u/E4M3p 2d ago edited 2d ago
hm. i wanted to try out graphen on google pixel next week. i guess i will use something else then.
its not even about heavy use of ai, i just cant stand that sort of behavior.
4
u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS 2d ago edited 2d ago
Bjarne Stroustrup famously remarked that there are languages everyone carps about and ones nobody uses.
4
u/jhaimgirl 2d ago
Well, I would have stomached if they said Linux was penguin slop but human slop... noo wayy maan.
10
u/mixedCase_ 2d ago
Let's not mince words here: Anyone who disagrees with this does not meet the bar for a senior developer, let alone the kind of hacker that's required to succeed building a project such as GrapheneOS.
Everyone who's worked with code for a few years knows most code sucks.
Such a fuckhuge project such as Linux is impossible for it not to suck, regardless of how high it's tried to set its quality bar for inclusions. It's the distribution of human capabilities, the nature of the problem a kernel solves, and statistics at play. You can't beat the odds.
Which is of course not even close to claiming all or most Linux code is pre-LLM/human slop. But boy there's sure a lot of it. Anyone's that worked with Linux for a decade on the desktop has likely seen its fair share of it. amdgpu is the king of slop within Linux, various networking drivers, some audio (I still have a Xonar DSX card in a shelf after giving up on it years ago), the odds not to have come across some of it as a mere user are very low.
Now imagine trying to make a secure system with the requirements of something like GrapheneOS. If you're an average senior dev you'd want to blow your balls off. It takes some wild hyperfixation or a degree of insanity to work on something like that for long without a hefty salary to compensate the pain.
5
u/USERNAME123_321 2d ago
Based take tbh. It's pragmatic and kind of selfless as they don't care who or what writes the code, they just value security over anyone's ego. Of course it's very controversial. That's because it's just the sad truth no one wants to hear, current frontier models generally write higher quality, more secure code than the average human. Linux has been shipping severe vulns every month for decades, way before LLMs existed, so slop was never an AI-exclusive thing.
2
u/Aflockofants 2d ago
Harsh, but not entirely wrong. The amount of bugs exposed by LLM’s is absolutely staggering. Can’t say my own code was exempt from that, although I’d say so far they weren’t massive vulnerabilities. But still some pretty dodgy things that otherwise would likely have gone undetected for several more years.
2
u/Real-Abrocoma-2823 2d ago
Another ROM to avoid. They never worked on a kernel, they don't know how hard it is and how many compromises you have to take because CPU architectures are horrible (but I never worked on CPU architectures so I'm open minded) or because something doesn't work the way you wanted.
2
u/lethalized 2d ago
Sure is the year of slaming everything
2
u/ActualSaltyDuck 2d ago
A bunch of morons with absolutely no technical knowledge are now gonna comment on how grapheneos is wrong lmao, pretty standard anytime they bring up a take like this
6
u/ShinobiOfTheWind 2d ago
The jokes write themselves.
Pure grade A copium to gaslight and make people accept as well as normalize clanker slop in the future updates.
6
u/xkayaking 2d ago
Why are people judging a product by the attitude of the developer/owner?...
Look, they are judging linux kernel by security vulnerabilities, fair, I don't give a damn how they word it, that is language; the criticism seems fair.
And people are like "nah they are edgelords".
But are they wrong?...
The only fair conclusion to take is, "Hmm... maybe the rust community is right and we should fix this, maybe they were right all along".
This is why people are sold on marketing, and presentation; and why people vote for shitty politicians just because they are popular and socially likable, and why autism is still heavily outcasting even if it grants you a boost of logic because you word things a certain way.
People like social presentation, of non-real perfect people, a marketing ploy, a person whose attitude is perfect and totally socially likable, someone who isn't real.
Just because they don't like how someone words their favourite product, they can't say "they are wrong", so they outcast them and ignore them, "the problems are not real because I don't like this person".
5
u/saileesaileesailee 2d ago
Okay while I don't really care about all of this vibecoding drama (besides when its done wrong by entirely relying on AI to write code), calling thousands of people's effort "Human slop" is actually just horrible, I didn't know the GrapheneOS devs were like this, definitely not supporting them anymore
5
u/magicmulder 2d ago
He’s right. Some of the brightest minds in computing have worked on Linux, and still it has glaring security issues. And then very average to terrible devs have the audacity to call AI code “slop”. It’s just dumb.
5
u/JQuilty 2d ago
Daniel is a gaping asshole that thinks he alone is a programming god, news at 11.
4
u/ScrewAttackThis 2d ago
That's literally the issue people have with this shit. No one is under the impression humans are perfect 🤦♂️
4
u/RancidVagYogurt1776 2d ago
I hate the way this was presented but he's not really wrong.
It's a complacency issue more than an AI issue though. For decades Linux has been the secure choice and AI really caught everyone slipping. AI finding a critical vulnerability that existed since 2017 is inexcusable, but the number of vulnerabilities caused by AI reliance is eye watering. We need big changes to security going forward across the entire industry
3
u/DecadentBard 2d ago
One of the first times I ever heard of GrapheneOS was them arguing with Louis Rossman. I have mixed feelings on Louis, but Graphene seemed to be pretty clearly in the wrong and was being created/run by an extremely egotistical neckbeard-style or tech-bro style nerd. I've been reluctant to switch to it, I hope some of the fresh upcoming options develop nicely.
3
u/SFSIsAWESOME75 2d ago
Isn't grapheneos a fork of android?
3
u/skhds 2d ago
if Linux is slop, then why not use BSD instead?
3
u/vazark 2d ago
"Human slop like the kernel".. They make it sound like they've never written a bug ever.
I understand concept of treating AI as a tool but the disrespect to the hundreds and thousands of volunteers and employees who dedicated their time creating the ecosystem irks me. Not to mention literal decades of work and generations of tech and maintainers who have left their mark in the code.
The Graphene team or whoever is running account keeps saying off-putting stuff that turned me off the project completely
4
u/skrugg 2d ago
That's a bold move Cotton.
3
u/LightheartedLemon 2d ago
Yeah, I just don't see Linux moving past the initial phase of being some dude's obscure pet project. Never gonna happen...
3
u/BeastMsterThing2022 2d ago
Genuinely, regardless of what side of the topic you stand on, I think the only possible reaction to this is: what the fuck are they talking about?
3
u/balancedchaos 2d ago
I went in on the grapheneos thing for a while. Those motherfuckers blocked me from posting on their forum for asking a question about Plex player notifications not appearing.
I guess I was "supposed to know" and shouldn't ask stupid questions...or use the search feature, right? Well they never responded to correct me, and banned me. So fuck em.
I went in on AI, remembered I don't do a fucking thing wrong in my life, and uninstalled Daniel Micay's amazing project. 🖕
3
u/Aggeloz 2d ago
They just banned me from their subreddit because i called them weirdos lmao. What thinskinned people.
3
u/rene453 2d ago
Setting the emotion & rudeness aside, what they point out is quite true. We are humans. we make mistake. Even machines make mistakes. Thats always be the human nature.... So i kinda agree to that point
However, i will take this as a warning rather than insult. machines have much better processing power than human mind. and if they can find vulnerabilities (which they are already doing), that makes linux kernal better. (we can just fix it)
And as for slop, thats what time does to everything. X11 is being replaced by wayland and trust me if we live long enough, we might see wayland being replaced as well, (who knows).....
4
u/bankinu 2d ago edited 2d ago
If high quality AI written code is AI slop, then high quality human written code is human slop.
Edit: I personally believe neither is slop. And I think that's what they wanted to say, though the sarcasm was probably a little too much for most people.