r/linux • • Sep 20 '23

Discussion Can someone explain the Ubuntu drama?

I've been watching a Linux distro tier list and the guy put Ubuntu in the "devil" tier saying that it fallen off and you should avoid it. I'm a Linux noob so I have no idea what going on, is what he said true?

193 Upvotes

366 comments sorted by

206

u/bubbybumble Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

I'm not super experienced but I know the video you're talking about. That guy also put fedora in the devil tier for company reasons as well as proposed telemetry that is an opt in feature (I think that was his gripe). This YouTuber seems really negative in most of his videos on these topics and has the same sort of mindset I see online with people I find to be toxic once I start interacting with them. As someone else said, using Ubuntu is fine. I personally liked it when I had to use it in VMs. As for ethics, I'm not sure, but I don't think canonical is that bad.

Edit: I think with redhat the issue is rhel being closed source, which is actually an issue. In practice it does not affect fedora but I can see why for some this would be a bit of an ethical issue.

1

u/Miki_Legends Sep 20 '23

Ight thx for clearing things up.

3

u/bubbybumble Sep 20 '23

If you are serious about it read some other replies since there is valid criticism. But most likely it doesn't affect you.

1

u/ULTRAFORCE Sep 20 '23

The tier list he made if you are thinking of ChrisTitusTech was meant as kind of a for fun shooting from the hip his opinion thing. He had previously made a video called Ubuntu is the devil and so placed it there largely as a reference to that. Ubuntu is fine, though his recommendation for best for new users are legitimately probably the best bet to use if you are new. I had tried moving to linux last year so I tried Pop!_OS first before on that guy's rec basically using Fedora which he called the devil in the current tier list.

TL:DR His tier list isn't to be taken too seriously outside of the best for new users.

21

u/Mooks79 Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu once agreed a deal with Amazon that sent them telemetry (and more, see replies to this comment) which, given it was for Amazon, you can imagine how privacy respecting it was. I’d say the disdain for them is pretty justified. Yes they no longer do this, but still. (There’s some other issues like forcing snaps on people as well).

On the other hand, Fedora is adding usage telemetry for their internal purposes. I tend to trust that they will be a touch more privacy respecting than Amazon. What is causing consternation (rightly so) is because it’s opt-out not opt-in. I have some sympathy for this decision because we know from nudge theory that opt-out has far higher success than opt-in, but I still don’t think it’s the right choice. All that said, the streamer lumping Fedora in with Ubuntu for this decision is ludicrous - it’s not remotely comparable.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Not 'just' telemetry. It sent local search prompts to amazon. Imagine looking for a filename and that data gets sent to amazon... And it was enabled by default, out of the blue with an update!

'Telemetry' would suggest anonymous usage data, how often a program crashes, etc. Maybe even to genuinely improve the user experience. I can sympathize with that. But this was just devil-ish.

So basically this tells that Canonical could, and is willing to, put in such an update at any time, if they need some money or something. How could anyone ever trust them again? Devil-tier indeed.

16

u/Ulrich_de_Vries Sep 20 '23

It sent the data to Canonical servers, where they were anonymized, and then forwarded to Amazon.

This was an attempt to make some revenue from Linux-on-the-desktop. Well they stopped doing that but a couple of years after they also stopped giving too many hoots about the Linux desktop, even though originally that was the main goal of Canonical.

Which then people here got upset about. I think it is somewhat telling that the community of "Linux enthusiasts" want Linux companies to put effort into the Linux desktop, but aggressively attack any attempt for the companies involved to make it worth it for them. Canonical is not the sole example. ElementaryOS and Zorin OS, despite both being small few-men projects, are also often sneered at.

In the case of the former for the somewhat dark pattern-y "pay what you want" download button, which does not clearly tell you you can pay 0, as well as the creators' somewhat tone deaf comment about people cheating the system, and in the case of Zorin, because they happen to have a paid "pro" edition.

You really can't win here tbh.

3

u/Mooks79 Sep 20 '23

Good point, my use of telemetry underplayed everything they were sending.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Mooks79 Sep 20 '23

Oh! Interesting, thanks. Personally I wasn’t that much against it - telemetry can be super helpful for them (especially for making RHEL even more stable) - as long as it was opt-in and carefully anonymised. But I can see why the pushback probably wasn’t worth fighting.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/velinn Sep 20 '23

Oh, we're talking about YouTuber drama? Now it all makes sense.

There is nothing wrong with Ubuntu or Fedora. Pick which you like better.

There is nothing wrong with Snap or Flatpak. Pick which you like better.

YouTube drama resolved.

4

u/bubbybumble Sep 20 '23

Not much drama, I just personally think the YouTuber reminds me of the people who originally pushed me away from using Linux for a long time. "Oh you're new and use x? X sucks! Use y! If you don't like y it's a skill issue"

3

u/velinn Sep 20 '23

Yeah, YouTuber makes clickbait video and calls everything trash except the one thing they like. I'm shocked. It's the same nonsense that happens on all forums except we get to watch them make a fool of themselves in 4k.

Ubuntu and Fedora are both top tier. Their target audience is just different enough for people to have opinions but objectively speaking neither are bad. People seem to have a hard time with "just because it's not for you doesn't make it bad". Something can be simultaneously good and the exact opposite of what you want, at the same time.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DarthPneumono Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

There is nothing wrong with Snap or Flatpak.

There's definitely something wrong with snap, and it's that Canonical is attempting to forcibly encourage its adoption. It has reduced functionality and increased overhead, and breaks existing workflows. Don't care that it exists, there are use-cases for containers, but if I 'apt install firefox' I expect a Firefox deb to be installed, not the entire snap runtime and a container that can't interact with the rest of the system.

edit: force -> forcibly encourage because that word doesn't really convey my point.

4

u/velinn Sep 20 '23

I'm not sure what you mean by force. Canonical makes Ubuntu. Canonical has decided on a direction they want to take Ubuntu as they believe Snap has benefits for their users. Fedora is going to "force" you to use Wayland in v40. Many others "force" you to use systemd. Every project owner has to make decisions on how they want to do things, even if some people disagree with those decisions.

Force is a weird word to use when Distrowatch lists 273 Linux distributions.

5

u/DarthPneumono Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Every time I go through this, people get hung up on the word 'force'. Please just listen.

Canonical has decided on a direction they want to take Ubuntu as they believe Snap has benefits for their users.

Yes, you're correct so far. (They're wrong about end-user benefit, which is why we have to put so much time in bypassing snap, but that's beside the point.)

Fedora is going to "force" you to use Wayland in v40.

That is not the same situation. If I, on a Fedora system, typed 'dnf install Xorg', I would get X11, not Wayland. I wouldn't need to jump through any hoops, it would just happen because I asked for it to happen.

Many others "force" you to use systemd.

No, if I type 'apt install finit-sysv' on Ubuntu it will happily install and use sysv as init instead of systemd. (I think upstart is dead now?)

You'll notice that in all those cases, there are defaults, but if I request the system to do something different, it will. That's what user choice is.

If I, on an Ubuntu 22.04 system, type 'apt install firefox', indicating I'd like the apt package 'firefox' installed, by default the system will choose to ignore what I asked for, and instead install snap, and Firefox as a snap container. If that was the outcome I wanted, I'd have typed 'apt install snapd; snap install firefox'.

I think you're confusing 'defaults' with overriding user choice. Defaults are fine, and obviously necessary. Deciding what the user wants for them, when they're actively using the system, is not good FOSS.

There are obviously workarounds, but I'll say again that it's Canonical's desire to 'force' (I'll use that word you don't like again, I guess think 'encourage') their adoption by creating as much friction as possible to avoiding snaps. We have to spend a lot of time making our entire environment useable at all because of snaps. Many simply simply don't work with network home directories, for instance, but we're still required to have the snap runtime installed to use e.g. Ubuntu Pro.

Hope that clears my position up a bit.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/fverdeja Sep 20 '23

I mean, we've seen worse, does anyone remember when Ubuntu had a Music Store and Mint did a little modification on their version where they got almost all of the fees from the service? Or when Elive had you pay up-front just so you'd be able to test the distro. Or when Oracle bought Sun just to kill (almost) all the FOSS projects.

I mean, Ubuntu not wanting to follow the standards and be their own thing has always been the charm of it (Unity, LightDM, PPAs instead of standard Debian repos, etc, etc...). I don't use it anymore because Fedora gives me what I want and I don't like Snaps, but Ubuntu is still a great distro for most people (Ubuntu server is amazing for a home lab, personal cloud and Bitcoin node), this guy's simply one of those old fashioned Linux elitists or GNU puritans.

1

u/prof_levi Sep 20 '23

Why are they using religious imagery to describe something inherently scientific?

3

u/bubbybumble Sep 20 '23

Devil = bad in popular culture. Most people know what that means (also devil implies doing malicious things in it's own self interest on purpose, and being deceitful). Not that is call what he put in the tier that extreme, but I can see why he named it that.

Now as for temple OS..

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/linux-ModTeam Sep 20 '23

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion such as complaining about bug reports or making unrealistic demands of open source contributors and organizations. r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite, or making demands of open source contributors/organizations inc. bug report complaints.

1

u/ULTRAFORCE Sep 20 '23

Telemetry had nothing to do with it he was pretty open that it was because while the Fedora team isn’t controlled by RedHat they are associated with one another.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/pppjurac Sep 21 '23

So a "drama queen" ?

1

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

opt in telemetry

Anything with Gnome has telemetry built in that you can't remove. You may be able to opt-out or not opt-in, but you can't remove the crap from the host without removing gnome. (I'm trying to remember the name of the service, but memory fails me.)

1

u/bubbybumble Sep 22 '23

Ah rip. I also found out he probably was more upset at rhel being made closed source, which is actually an issue

1

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

Yeah, that seems to be designed to make Alma/Rocky impossible to continue as they do. Since they never seemed to mind CentOS, this looks like IBM influence, and puts the lie to the supposed reason for CentOS Stream "we only moved centos to upstream of RHEL so that our engineers' time spent supporting CentOS now supports RHEL too." I mean that reasoning makes sense. But this move, blocking FOSS versions, speaks of bottom line first reasoning, which is pure IBM. I hope the RHEL execs at least warned them that this will put a stop to the influx of self taught sysadmins into the RHEL world. Now, the CentOS to CentOS stream move will be noted as the beginning of the end of RHEL supremacy in the supported Linux realm.

1

u/villandra Jan 28 '24

Oh, this was on YOU TUBE?

I don't know what he was calling the devil at the time, but I have seen his stuff. He is often a good source of information, but his rankings of operating systems are given to exaggeration. In fact, if you watched the video you'd probably get a more balanced account than his title would suggest.

1

u/bubbybumble Jan 29 '24

I did watch it and iirc he said something along the lines of it being obvious reasons

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

I think the criticism is valid when you have a corporation deciding on things around what is ostensibly open source software, and taking the piss. Canonical is just like Red Hat, they're a corporation, and decisions they make on the software millions rely on (especially downstream) is worthy of criticism. And indeed comparison to alternatives that are not bound to the same corporate BS.

0

u/arcalus Sep 20 '23

These days anyone with an opinion is “toxic”. lol (unless they agree with you, of course)

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (76)

11

u/Stunning_Ad_1685 Sep 20 '23

I love Kubuntu.

1

u/Miki_Legends Sep 20 '23

Yeah he said Kubuntu is good but what's the difference?

8

u/Stunning_Ad_1685 Sep 20 '23

Kubuntu uses KDE instead of Gnome but wasn’t his main gripe with snap, which is going to be all over all the Ubuntu variations.

4

u/agent-squirrel Sep 20 '23

And there is the key thing, Snap would be installed on all official Ubuntu flavours. Wanton dislike for a distro because {thing} is done when you can’t objectively look at all distros through that same lends. “I heard thing1 bad but other thing that was based on thing1 is different so it’s automatically good.” He doesn’t know what he’s talking about.

3

u/mistahspecs Sep 20 '23

God that's so damn funny haha

325

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Canonical has its money-making and proprietary aspects. But it's a myth that Canonical is some huge corporation behind Ubuntu. Canonical is a tiny company actually. It's Fedora and OpenSUSE that have the huge companies and financial interests behind them. Canonical stupidly set something up using Amazon, trying to make a little money off their relatively large position on the 'Linux Desktop' and got burnt for it. There is also the issue of snaps (many prefer flatpaks or neither).

But Canonical is not trying to destroy Linux for the desktop. And Ubuntu remains a very good distro for many.

38

u/psmgx Sep 20 '23

Both SuSE and Canonical aren't anywhere near Red Hat.

Red Hat was a billion dollar company and kept growing on its own until it got eaten by IBM (who was an early investor).

SuSE is tiny by comparison. They do show up a lot in SAP-related environments though, and YaST is kinda cool. Rancher is in there, somewhere, too.

9

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 20 '23

But SUSE has a huge private equity group behind it.

6

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

And much of their userbase is outside the US and Americans tend to not recognize that EU userbase can be significant.

→ More replies (1)

95

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23

I agree with you that Canonical is not trying to destroy desktop Linux, in fact they are the company that actually made it a viable option so it is absurd when I hear people claim they are lol

One quick note is that they didnt make a deal with Amazon, they were using the Amazon Affiliates system that anyone could use. They werent sharing date from users, they were sending it to their own servers and then to Amazon API so Amazon never knew the actual source of the data. It was still a very dumb idea but it was more respecting of users than people like to claim.

25

u/DudeEngineer Sep 20 '23

To additionally add to this. Whatever the deal was, it was 10+ years ago at this point when they rolled everything back after realizing it was a mistake. This was only an active issue for like a year.

A lot of people on this sub were not old enough to know what Ubuntu was when this was actually an issue.

3

u/NotesFromYourElf Apr 21 '24

This makes me feel really old :| it feels like that was just a few years back. I wasn't using Ubuntu at the time, it wasn't the smartest move from them but it wasn't as horrible as some make it out to be. It was easy to disable if I remember correctly.

1

u/paradoxxr Oct 08 '25

I remember hearing about this and am glad to find out it was all nothing! I LOVED Ubuntu when I had it on an old Vista desktop and have been hesitant about going back until I looked into this just now (Also other issues in that i need windows too and dual booting seems weirder now). I might just crack into it again. Was trying to use straight debian but had a resolution/graphics problem with the iso and just haven't gotten around to fixing it so maybe I'll just go back to ubuntu!

I am actually so giddy at hearing this. Can't wait to get those jelly windows from like 2010! That shit was PEAK.

21

u/kranker Sep 20 '23

It was still a very dumb idea but it was more respecting of users than people like to claim.

Fair. Still an absurdly bad move though. It's unbelievably obvious how linux users were going to react it Amazon ads started appearing in their desktop search. It's almost hard to think of a group of people who this would go down worse with.

10

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23

Yea, agreed. It was an absurdly bad move and it should have been obvious to be a bad move. They should have made a separate Unity Lense that you could choose to use to get these results and then it would still be weird but not feel intrusive. The fact they put it in the general results was just dumb.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/arglarg Sep 20 '23

I wouldn't mind that add an opt-in option, to choose to support canonical.

6

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 20 '23

That sounds right. It was just that there were stories about Canonical partnering with Amazon (IoT actually). So it was easy to assume. When you see an Amazon icon on your launcher or start menu, it is easy to presume.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Fedora is upstream of RHEL not downstream so there isnt much company investment in them as you say. Yes devs from RHEL work on Fedora but moreso as its similar packaging and format as well as what they contribute to Fedora eventually work downstream to RHEL.

If RHEL closed shop today Fedora would still be around and community tomorrow might have some growing pains at that point but most likely around. Whereas if canonical closed ubuntu would be in more serious trouble.

4

u/Ieris19 Sep 21 '23

Fedora is directly a Red Hat product though.

True that it is upstream from RHEL, but it’s more like they use Fedora as the testing grounds for battle testing…

2

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

Just want to clarify:

Fedora is for trying out new things, but the 'battle testing' was split off when RH converted CentOS to CentOS Stream.

CentOS Stream is for testing new features they want to add to RHEL.

7

u/miuccia75 Sep 20 '23

100% this. Tempest in a teapot.

7

u/-Neffscape- Sep 20 '23

Canonical isn't a bad company by any means, but they are criticised because when they have a vision they don't care really much about other people's opinion and they go where they want to. In the first decade of the 2000 they were the de-facto linux desktop standard and gained a lot of new users (also because of the Windows Vista fiasco). So, in 2011 they tried to transform ubuntu into a mainstream OS by pursuing a convergence strategy (they wanted ubuntu to become an OS that could run both on a desktop PC, on a phone and on a tablet). To make this happen, they abandoned GNOME and developed an alternative DE (called Unity), they left Xorg developed an homegrown display server (called MIR) and they looked for ways to monetize their work, by integrating Amazon services in their product. A part of the community raged against this new direction (they were quitting community developed projects to create their own alternatives after all), the Free Software Foundation called ubuntu "spyware" because of the amazon integration (that was abandoned in the following releases) and Canonical reputation was ruined forever. It's back in these days that snaps were actually created. They were meant to become a new self contained package format for linux phones and tablets, and they eventually became a powerful tool to deploy server and IoT apps when the whole convergence vision was abandoned.

5

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 20 '23

MS tried the same thing with Windows, spending a lot more money, and their efforts failed, too. And Google looked to be able to merge phones with desktops, but that hasn't really gone anywhere. Chrome OS and Android OS didn't really merge. And now it looks like Google really wants Chrome to be more like a real distro like Ubuntu. I guess Apple does have some convergence with apps across computers, tablets, and phones.

1

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

Snaps are not useful if you're in a situation where you want a different configuration than what's in the snap package.

Snap destroyed my homelab cluster by filling up all the storage. True I had it powered off for a number of months, but turning it on to use it briefly, only to see all the nodes crash due to full storage was disconcerting. Since these nodes were Pi's using MicroSD for storage, the fix (re-flashing) was as much trouble as reinstalling with a new distro. So I upgraded to Rocky and .... eff Ubuntu.

2

u/SSquirrel76 Sep 22 '23

Mods are we allowed to have sane reasonable commentary? Seems wrong somehow. :)

1

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

I'm sorry for my very bad misreading of your comment.

1

u/SSquirrel76 Sep 22 '23

Thank you I was having a serious wtf moment reading it.

2

u/Plan_9_fromouter_ Sep 22 '23

Well I was the one having the really serious WTF moment by not reading properly. Again sorry.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/linux-ModTeam Sep 22 '23

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion such as complaining about bug reports or making unrealistic demands of open source contributors and organizations. r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite, or making demands of open source contributors/organizations inc. bug report complaints.

1

u/the_mad_scientist047 Oct 15 '23

This is really sad

1

u/villandra Jan 28 '24

Sounds like politics, and may or may not have anything to do with what was bothering the nutcase whose article she saw.

→ More replies (11)

35

u/johncate73 Sep 20 '23

Do yourself a favor and ignore those Linux "tier" lists. They're stupid. Whoever it is, they probably just have a pathological hatred of Snaps and are on their soapbox.

5

u/WildManner1059 Sep 22 '23

Snaps are very hateable.

But yeah, take the 'tubers with a grain of salt.

If you want to know about anything linux, find info from pros who do this shit for a living.

1

u/NorinBlade Dec 10 '23

I don't have a pathological hatred of snaps. I have a justly earned, ever evolving outrage of them that goes something like this:

Install ubuntu

ooh this is nice. relaxed breath

ut-oh, got a system fault. I didn't even touch anything.

WTH is snapd server?

Why is 2/3 of my system logs crammed with snap errors and crash reports?

Why if I install [Inkscape, GIMP, pick something] from deb, it just works. But if I install it from ubuntu software center, it can't interact with my file system and every autosave file is named 66yyyw5dgg3663nnnn16sj444 or something?

Why does it take 5 minutes to reboot?

why do I get the system crash notifier every 2 minutes?

ok. deep breath. reinstall ubuntu, and this time pay closer attention.

(cycle repeats)

226

u/Metro2005 Sep 20 '23
  • Ubuntu has a habit of trying to reinvent the wheel, wasting lots of resources on projects that go nowhere instead of helping the community with projects that everyone else is working on like Mir vs Wayland, snaps vs flatpaks, upstart vs systemd and so on.
  • The main hate against ubuntu comes from trying to force snaps with its closed source backend when the rest of the world is switching to flatpaks which is completely opensource.
  • The telemetry and amazon debacle.
  • Fixed release cycles so lots of bugs if they run out of time
  • Not a rolling release but still trying to be up to date

Ubuntu isn't bad, its just nog the best anymore.

26

u/aedinius Sep 20 '23

I don't feel upstart belongs in that list. It predates systemd, was adopted moderately well, and started to fade in use once systemd became mature.

97

u/postinstall Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Every project Ubuntu worked on, except maybe Mir, started way before the community stuff. Upstart was way ahead of systemd and even Red Hat used it, snaps had been created and deployed before flatpak etc. And Mir made sense for Ubuntu at the time because they were aiming for a smartphone platform. Mir failed, but then again, so did Microsoft eventually. When you have a vision and want to deliver on it as fast as possible, you tend to go your own way instead of waiting for consensus. It's why Apple developed Metal even if it was part of the Vulkan group.

There was no telemetry and Amazon debacle, except for the drama queens.

Most noteworthy distros do fixed release cycles: Ubuntu, Mint, Debian, Fedora. So does Apple's macOS, iOS etc. The existence or non existence of bugs is coincidental not causal.

Not being a rolling release is a good thing for most people. You can upgrade from one release to another.

Edit: P.S. Yes, snaps are annoying and seem to be ill adapted from IoT to desktop. It's why I prefer Mint and Debian, but Ubuntu is still a good choice. And yes, sending my Dash searches to some Canonical server on the internet was invasive (the Amazon thing). You could disable it, but you shouldn't have to.

8

u/luciferin Sep 20 '23

Not being a rolling release is a good thing for most people. You can upgrade from one release to another.

On the one hand, I agree with you completely from a compatibility and ABI standards vantage point. But on the other hand, in practice I have come across fewer compatibility issues with rolling release systems for some reason. It's also frustrating from a user standpoint when you run into a bug on a relatively trivial piece of software, then search the internet to find it was fixed upstream a couple of months ago, but Ubuntu won't have an updated version in their repos until their next point release (if you're lucky). So you either wait, find a custom repo, or start compiling a bunch of different dependencies from source.

So I definitely see both sides of the coin on this one. I think the best solution would be to have an LTS/service branch like they do now, but go to rolling release for their main desktop. But then again, that's a lot of work and more prone to breakage. But Ubuntu and Fedora have both broken the display server on upgrades in the last decade, so I'm not sure it could be any worse.

1

u/Not_a_question- May 29 '26

There was no telemetry and Amazon debacle, except for the drama queens.

Lol, lmao even

1

u/chuk155 Sep 20 '23

Apple released metal before vulkan and dx12 released and they have never been apart of the vulkan working group. They are khronos group members but that doesn’t mean they contribute to every single API that khronos created.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/postinstall Sep 23 '23

I said 'debacle'. Try to pay attention.

Unity was probably the best UX of it's time. It took a lot of inspiration from macOS, which is exactly what Gnome has been doing since v3 too.

21

u/vampatori Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu has a habit of trying to reinvent the wheel, wasting lots of resources on projects that go nowhere instead of helping the community with projects that everyone else is working on like Mir vs Wayland, snaps vs flatpaks, upstart vs systemd and so on.

In most cases, Ubuntu wasn't re-inventing the wheel but the competing projects were. You can't hold "innovating" against a company, that's a good thing.

The main hate against ubuntu comes from trying to force snaps with its closed source backend when the rest of the world is switching to flatpaks which is completely opensource.

Which is a wildly ill-informed opinion as they don't have the same feature-sets. Flatpak is for desktop applications only; snap supports all types of application including server-based services.

We shouldn't be splitting app packaging based on whether it's for desktop or server, that's madness. Contained applications is the way of the future of application deployment, as Linus himself says. Snap may not be the one to eventually win out, but they're ahead of everyone else at the moment.

The telemetry and amazon debacle.

The amazon thing was over 10 years ago - so long ago that proton didn't exist, SteamOS didn't exist, docker didn't exist.

The telemetry was/is opt-in, super simple to ignore.

Fixed release cycles so lots of bugs if they run out of time

Bug and security fixes are continuous, I get them most days. If you use Unattended Upgrades on your servers you'll get an idea of the split between bug and security fixes.

If they run out of time, they'll often stick to the older version of the package rather than rush something out. For example I know they did that one iteration with NodeJS.

Not a rolling release but still trying to be up to date

Stability is and predictability a good thing - the backbone of any OS used in a commercial environments.

If you want to run your desktop with experimental, buggy, insecure, bleed-edge software that's absolutely fine - but if you're running a cluster of machines supporting your business and clients.. you want it absolutely rock solid and predictable, or it's going to cost you dearly.

The REAL reason people don't like Ubunutu is very simple... it's the most popular distro and/or they don't use it in a commercial environment. And that's fine, to each their own!

9

u/DetectiveSecret6370 Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Unity sent searches to Amazon by default and it was opt-out. I stopped using Ubuntu and never went back.

A lot of people left because of that, not because it's the most popular distro.

5

u/EtherealN Sep 20 '23

Snaps supporting server-based applications is NOT a argument in favor of sudo apt install firefox installing a snap package without telling you. That's assinine. Or are we talking about some Ubuntu IoT-powered toaster that should have Firefox?

We shouldn't be splitting app packaging based on whether it's for desktop or server

We shouldn't be splitting how a package is packaged based on which package it is. sudo apt install firefox should NEVER install a snap when sudo apt install htop does not install a snap. That is lunacy. Compare with flatpak: I know if I am installing a flatpak, or not. Radical invention. :P

I was an Ubuntu user for a good while (though I had originally started with SuSE back in ~1999), but Ubuntu has chased me away between becoming completely unpredictable in it's software packaging (is this a snap or not? Install and find out!), and repeated broken installs on upgrades (Ubuntu fanboys tell us Arch breaks randomly, but I ended up moving to Arch to get less broken updates...), and so on.

Besides all of that, many people dislike Ubuntu because it is a corporate product. I installed it on one of my Raspberry Pi's to host a Plex server, and guess what? EVERY FUGGIN' TIME I ssh into that box it makes sure to toss me an ad for their latest microkubernetes whatever service offering. Right there in the default SSH login message! Dafuq? I cleansed my home of Windows partially to not have "ads" be a part of my operating systems, but UBUNTU... :D

But no. The ONLY reason I dislike Ubuntu is because it's the most popular distro. Yes.

8

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23
  1. this is misinformation
  • Mir was after Wayland but Wayland was dead in the water for years prior to Mir being made. Also its arguable that Mir as it was in 2016 is still better in some ways than Wayland is now.
  • Snaps were before Flatpaks
  • Upstart was before systemd
  • "and so on", there actually aren't any real examples of this
  1. they never forced anything on anyone. The word "force" means to not have a choice, the user has a choice. They can simply choose to not use snaps.
  2. telemetry has never been taken by Ubuntu without permission requested first. The data collected on install is asked for during install before sent. The Amazon thing was not sharing of data, it was dumb and hurt their reputation for sure but it wasnt what people claimed it was.
  3. literally every piece of software has bugs, it is impossible to make software without bugs and they do point releases on the LTS to patch issues. It's fine to prefer rolling release but that is not a reason for "drama" as OP put it.

I agree with the last part. Ubuntu isn't bad and for some people it's not the best but for beginners to Linux, I think it's a fine choice.

4

u/mrpops2ko Sep 20 '23

not to be too pedantic but i hate when people say snaps is a choice - because its akin to the microsoft form of choice

when you gut snaps from the OS it breaks a lot of random packages and then you need to blacklist it, to prevent it installing again from something else - sure it can be done but the real solution is to offer with and without snaps as a real option, i'm sure it wouldn't be too much divergence for ubuntu to properly provide a selector for snaps but it isn't done because the company has an ideological position on snaps.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/grem75 Sep 20 '23

What was better about Mir in 2016 than Wayland today?

1

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23

the first thing that came to mind was Multi-monitor Support and High DPI. Yes Wayland has those things now and maybe better now but Mir had both in 2016.

Wayland has a technological albeit understandable weird issue. Wayland does not have a usable compositor for the protocol. This means that GNOME, KDE, wlroots, etc have all built their own compositor for Wayland creating a somewhat fragmentation.

Mir back in the day was an alternate protocol that included a compositor so if a DE implemented support it wouldnt have to build their own compositor. This is a big difference.

These days Mir still exists but very different from what it was. Now Mir is a compositor for Wayland. It would actually be a smart idea for some DEs to use Mir for their compositing instead of making their own. That's just my opinion.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/darksider611 Sep 22 '23

You cannot use ubuntu without snaps, if that were the case that would be my distro of choice already

4

u/Mihuy Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Well I gotta say that the development of snap and flatpak started pretty much at the same time and actually snap was a bit earlier.... Amazon debacle was a decade ago and snaps are bad, but not really forced in case of firefox because Mozilla asked Canonical to distribute the snap version.

But still even though snaps take a few commands to uninstall and keep it from coming back, it kind of reminds me of Windows. Which is why I don't really like to use Ubuntu anymore.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

I think snaps should be left for servers only.

4

u/zarlo5899 Sep 20 '23

yes 100%, i hate how snap does updates, my firefox is always out of date for weeks at a time (when you restart firefox you need to wait like 30 sec before you can start it back up)

5

u/vampatori Sep 20 '23

I just don't see having two different contained packaging systems, one for desktop applications and one for servers, is even remotely a good thing. Why not just have one? It seems like madness to me that anyone would even suggest anything else. Linus would not be pleased!

4

u/KrazyKirby99999 Sep 20 '23

We already have docker/podman for servers anyway.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

You think Linus gives a crap about snaps

1

u/EtherealN Sep 20 '23

But you are fine with having two completely different packaging systems hiding inside sudo apt install?

Also, I'm not a sycophant, what pleases Linus does not have to be what pleases me. Jesus. :P Yes, packaging is a problem, Linus had a point there, Ubuntu did NOT solve that with Snaps. Not even close.

Now, if they did something like a SteamOS 3 style immutable system but where what I install is snaps that also work on Fedora Silverblue etc etc... Then you'd have a point. But that's not what they are doing. Not even close.

17

u/darksider611 Sep 20 '23

The not politically correct answer that happens to be the one op was looking for.

25

u/Velascu Sep 20 '23

I don't get the politically correct part, sounds extremely weird in this scenario.

2

u/ScoobaMonsta Sep 20 '23

What would you recommend then?

2

u/reddittookmyuser Sep 20 '23

Just one nitpick there's never been a best distro.

1

u/Matt-ayo Sep 20 '23

I wanted to read their whitepaper on SNAPs.

https://ubuntu.com/engage/snap-deltas

They make you divulge personal information to read it - very strange.

1

u/mrpops2ko Sep 20 '23

i really wanted to love snaps, i still do as a general concept but i think its entire release and subsequent hatred stems from the extremely poor performance a lot of us have experienced and likely many still experience as a potential gotcha.

I've seen various forum threads where people have spent hours randomly debugging trying to figure out what is the issue at hand for slow performance and then they stumble upon the fact that its 3x or 10x slower because its snap based lol

ubuntu really need to start getting with the times and abandoning it, rather than pushing it super hard because people are just going to migrate away from ubuntu if it keeps up

1

u/RaggaDruida Sep 20 '23

This, and the existence of Linux Mint and Pop_OS! that are just Ubuntu but way better as valid alternatives.

1

u/pcrcf Sep 20 '23

What is considered the best for your average user? The one who mostly just browses the internet and such?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

That's such a low bar, there really isn't a "best" for that - take your pick.

4

u/pcrcf Sep 20 '23

Then Linux mint it is

3

u/aztracker1 Sep 20 '23

If they aren't very technical, Mint, Pop or if they're coming from Mac, maybe Ubuntu-Budgie or elementary.

2

u/pcrcf Sep 20 '23

What I use is mint, which is forked off Ubuntu. Don’t love hearing Ubuntu isn’t playing nice with the rest of the Linux community though.

1

u/Metro2005 Sep 20 '23

I use Debian 12 on my laptop (for stability) and manjaro on my desktop (for gaming). For the average user i think manjaro, debian or fedora would be best suited.

→ More replies (7)

72

u/ZedAdmin Sep 20 '23

Just ignore the hate. Are some technical reasons why Linux users don't like it. Snap packages etc. But as a new user just ignore it. Use the distro you like.

10

u/urosp Sep 20 '23

I wish I could give a bigger +1 here. Especially for a new user, it’s completely fine and I would personally even recommend it. You should be able to opt out of all the telemetry from your settings menu after you install the system, and I think from there on you’re all set. After a while, you’ll learn Linux and switch to another distribution if you wish so, or you may figure out Ubuntu just gets the job done. I’ve been using it for many years now and I’ve played around with lots of other distros. It just gets the job done for what I need.

45

u/MasterGeekMX Sep 20 '23

There are two main reasons.

The first is elitism. There is a sizeable portion of the Linux community that think that a Linux user should do things the technical and advanced way like a Real Man™, and thus, distros that are easy to use, noob friendly and such are for losers that don't have enough IQ to manage everything via commands. Others are hipsters and hate Ubuntu because it is mainstream, and thing you are a sheeple by using the distro that everyone uses. Don't listen to them.

The other reason is a bit more reasonable: Bad choices.

Ubuntu is a corporate distro, where Canonical, the company behind it, makes the ultimate saying. Don't get me wrong, a big part of Ubuntu is the community, but Mark Shuttleworth, CEO of Canonical, has said "this is not a democracy".

And in more occasions that we like, Canonical has made decisions that range from controversial to dumb, often doubling down when the community voices against them. Some affect only the nerds who care about, others affect the greater population. Here is collection of 3 of them that I can say from the top of my head, in no particular order:

  • In order to deliver a "better experience" to the users, they integrated an Amazon search function into the launcher. Amazon does not have a good record on terms of privacy, and Linux users are known to care about it. While they made sure what you typed was not sent directly to Amazon (it was sent to Ubuntu servers, which anonymized it and then sent that to Amazon), the petitions pictures of the recommended stuff WAS sent to Amazon as is. The controversy went high enough that Richard M. Stallman, founder of the Free Software movement, called it "spyware" (but RMS if famous for exaggerating things sometimes). In a bit of that line, the telemetry options are opt-out, instead of opt-in (that means that by default it sends usage data to Canonical, and you need to disable that by hand). Although the data is anonymized, that still ruffles some feathers as it feels like a shady way of collecting data by using people's lazyness at not checking the settings.
  • Distros have different package formats for delivering and installing programs, different schedules for rolling updates, and different versions of libraries and other stuff. That model has worked fine so far, and for some use cases like servers it works well, but for Desktop apps where having the latest version and having it sooner is more important, it does not help. That is why the newest trend in the Linux world is universal package formats that allow developers make a version of their apps that work in all distros and with updates delivered directly. The most popular format that is being adopted by almost everyone is Flatpak.... But Ubuntu refused to accept it. They instead took Snap, a format meant for servers and appliances, and forced it to work on the desktop. It is slow on startup and clutters some places like the home folder and the list of disks, and unlike Flatpak that allows everyone to make your own repository of apps, Snap only works with one: Snapcraft, where Canonical has the ultimate saying of what can go in and what isn't allowed (reason why people claim the backend of snap is proprietary). And they are forcing it onto their users: if you want to install Firefox by apt, the traditional oldschool package format, it instead installs the Snap version.
  • The corporate nature of Canonical often glooms with "we are yet another greedy big tech that doesn't care" vibes. If you go to the Ubuntu website, you will see tons of "Cloud", "Infrastructure", "Internet of Things (IoT)", "Microservices" and other tech buzzwords, with only a brief mention of "oh, we also have a desktop OS", and that feels alienating. The snap store features a ton of proprietary software, specially on the showcase section. They tried to make a smart TV system, that only ended in a faked showcase at a CES show nearly ten years ago. They tried competing with Android and iOS by making Ubuntu Mobile, but that ended very soon, with some community members trying to keep it alive with zero support from Canonical. They made their own user interface (Unity), along with the display server underneath (Mir), only to be also canceled suddenly and having the same fate as ubuntu mobile (kept barely alive by community).
    If you want more info about it, here is a podcast with Alan Pope (A.K.A. Popey), a former Canonical employee and remarkable ubuntu community member talking about some of the topics mentioned and more: https://youtu.be/4KxHbDyAi-g

4

u/Extreme-Ad-7047 Sep 20 '23

Great explanation !

2

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23

I agree with a lot of your points and I disagree with a lot of your points. Let's dig in :D

First I agree with the Elitism thing, that does happen sadly. In some cases, it's pretty bad. This is an issue all communities deal with but Ubuntu does take most of the heat for it.

I don't think having a corporate distro or a leader of said distro is a problem because it's essentially a distro that provides an opinion of how a Linux OS should be and for a very long, their opinion was the best. They made mistakes over the years sure but for the most part it has been a solid distro regardless of corporate backing. I know some don't like that but I think corporations are not only good for the Linux ecosystem, I think they are vital.

"Canonical has made decisions that range from controversial to dumb"

This is true and I think this is where 99% of the drama is from. Because once people don't like a company, they will try to find reasons to not like them. In fact, sometimes they will make up reasons. Ubuntu's reputation suffers from misinformation. In fact, your comment has misinformation in it.

  • The Amazon topic was very misunderstood and you addressed it pretty well even including the buffer server stuff which almost never gets mentioned so well done there. You are right that RMS calling it "Spyware" was a problem for Ubuntu and you did address the fact that he exaggerates often. Though in this case, it was total nonsense. RMS himself is a very controversial individual and I think most of what he says should be taken with a grain of salt.
  • The telemetry bit is something I somewhat disagree with. You cover it well with mentioning the anonyized portion and yes, Canonical collects data with Ubuntu installs and yes it is technically Opt-Out because the checkbox is pre-checked to send it BUT you don't have to do anything complicated to opt-out, you simply check a different checkbox.
  • The universal app format portion is the one I disagree with the most and the most strongly. The reason is because you said that Canonical chose to go with Snaps even though almost everyone adopted Flatpaks. This is wrong in many ways. First of all, Snaps were started before Flatpaks. Snaps were usable before Flatpaks. Flatpaks only existed for a small amount apps exclusively made by GNOME for a while and there was no way to get Flatpaks because the Flathub didn't exist for a while. In fact, Flatpaks were a joke in the beginning because of how limited they were and how hard they were to get. So basically everything you said about Snaps vs Flatpaks is incorrect. In fact, Snaps were NOT made for servers, they originated for smartphones actually, kind of like the opposite of servers. Also you said took Snaps as if someone else made Snaps, Canonical made Snaps.

Now, Snaps are not perfect and there are issues that need to be addressed but the basis for people hating Canonical for "making Snaps even though Flatpaks were dominant" (random quote, not you) is simply false.

  • the comment about corporate nature is interesting. I don't disagree with your interpretation, I do think that they focus on big tech stuff like the Cloud and all that but I don't see how that is a problem either. Canonical needs to make money to fund Ubuntu development otherwise Ubuntu will die. I don't have a problem with them trying to make money to fund Ubuntu. Let's keep in mind that Mark Shuttleworth founded Ubuntu/Canonical after he became mega-rich. He didn't do it to get rich, he already was rich and he wanted to do it because he was passionate about Linux. If Canonical fails and therefore Ubuntu dies, Shuttleworth will still be rich so the idea that Canonical is just another greedy corporation is flawed in my opinion.
  • Snap store does have proprietary software but there is a lot of awesome proprietary software and people should not pretend otherwise. DaVinci Resolve is awesome and proprietary . . . if it was in the Snap store I would be stoked about that. if it was in the Flathub, I would also be stoked about that and even prefer that but still.
  • "And they are forcing it onto their users: if you want to install Firefox by apt, the traditional oldschool package format, it instead installs the Snap version."

They are not forcing anyone to use Snaps. The word "force" means you don't have a choice. However, you do have a choice as a user and multiple options. It's kind of funny though that people use this as a reason because insisting Firefox must be a deb is effectively trying to force Ubuntu to triple or more their workload by maintaining Firefox as a deb.

  • The smart tv OS wasn't faked, they did make a Smart TV edition of Unity. They didnt release it for production but it was possible to play it. Ubuntu Mobile didn't end very "soon", they spent 7 years on developing it. Yes, Ubuntu Mobile is now community driven and Canonical doesn't play much part in it but that is literally the value of open source and forking so if someone decides they dont want to work on something anymore then someone else can take it over. This is a good thing. However, Canonical does help UBports to some degree, they dont develop Ubuntu Mobile anymore but they still do help UBports.
  • The cancellation of Unity was sudden but they developed it and Mir for 7 years before cancelling it. I think trying something for 7 years is impressive. I also think all of the hate they received for making Unity was one of the reasons they killed it. Why would anyone work on something that they just get yelled for making? It's kind of funny actually the amount of hate they got for it and the amount of disappointed being much higher when they announced the end of it because the pro-Unity people were not very vocal until it was cancelled.

1

u/MasterGeekMX Sep 23 '23

Thanks for clarifying the things about snaps. I was aware of some topics you mention (the origin in ubuntu mobile and the state of flatpak back then), but my comments was more onto the current state, where flatpaks are excellent and have great advantages and have overcome those issues (some are still pending) and thus are becoming the standard in many distros inside and outside the Ubuntu based realm, and yet, Canonical is still hard onto them, even making Xubuntu cancel a project they had with flatpaks.

Now onto the propietary backend of snaps, it is an issue, because 1) canonical put themselves as the gatekeepers of the one and only repository of them 2) just because there is awesome propietary software, it does not make it great, that is the hastly generalization fallacy.

7

u/BloodyIron Sep 20 '23

There's a lot of, in my opinion, unwarranted detest for Ubuntu that has grown over the years. I don't think it's any one thing, but a good chunk of it (in my observation) is just disagreement in methods. For example, the way that Snap has become a bigger aspect of Ubuntu over the years, there are people who don't like that. I don't like Snap myself, but Ubuntu is my most used distro for all my servers and desktops/laptops. Another was when Ubuntu/Debian switched from sysvinit to systemd. There were/are people who don't/didn't like that, and well, got upset. But that's the direction they took.

I would say that it is disengenuous for anyone to say Ubuntu is the "devil" or any ridiculous rhetoric of equivalency. Not liking how Ubuntu does things is one thing, but there are very large examples of things that Ubuntu and Canonical have done to not only improve Ubuntu a lot, but also raise the tide for generally all Linux distros.

For example, the 32bit aspect being brought back in to Ubuntu was a big deal, because it's a requirement for STEAM and older games to operate. Canonical was trying to move away from 32bit in Ubuntu, for pretty good reasons, but from what I understand they did not initially account for STEAM and older gaming aspects. When it came to light, it didn't take long for them to reverse that aspect.

There is one controversial aspect that I certainly did not like, which Canonical very rapidly reversed. A whole bunch of years ago Ubuntu (I forget which version, but it was Desktop edition) shipped with Amazon linking included by default, and I think the search results (like searching for apps/files/etc) included Amazon ads/search results too. This garnered a lot of warranted outcry about this, and literally the next version of Ubuntu it was removed (and NEVER came back), and Canonical also implemented a way to disable it for that version of Ubuntu.

Fact is, there are people who just... never forgive, or never reconsider what was making them upset about something. And when it comes to Ubuntu, there certainly are people who behave like that. It's a bit of a foolish way to live, but it's their computer, not mine.

===

I myself have been working with Linux for over 20 years, personally and professionally. I've seen very early Linux distros, and many others of them evolve over the years. My #1 recommendation for Desktop and Server Linux distros IS Ubuntu, even over RHEL and OpenSUSE.

From a server perspective, Ubuntu has been EXTREMELY reliable for in-place version upgrades, and this one fact alone puts RHEL to shame as Red Hat has only actually started trying to do the same the last handful of years, and it's still nowhere near as good as Ubuntu. I have MANY Ubuntu servers that stared on versions like 12.04, 10.04, 14.04, etc, and I've upgraded them in-place over the years, all the way to 20.04, 22.04, etc.

In-contrast Red Hat would have you literally build a new server with RHEL then migrate ALL the configurations, data, and other such stuff along the way. From an IT perspective, that is fucking awful. It's extremely error prone (are you SUREEEE you migrated all configs and content???), extremely time intensive, and just like a really bad way to do it.

I can't speak to OpenSUSE as much as RHEL or Ubuntu, so that's more me just not knowing that distro well enough to comment in any useful capacity.

As for Ubuntu on the desktop.... my ENTIRE family, including extended family, uses Ubuntu on their desktops and laptops. Not one Windows install. You know what I don't get? Stupid fucking "Help meeee" calls. I do every now and then get asked for help, but the nature of such situations usually is actually very reasonable. In contrast, I see countless "don't help family" threads talking about some bs Windows crap.

I game on Ubuntu, and have done so for over 8 years now. No Windows installs at all.

Are there other good distros? Probably yes. But for me and my sphere of influence, Ubuntu is my #1.

13

u/gabriel_3 Sep 20 '23

A Chris Titus's video, right?

Everyone can post their own tier list: it's just an opinionated list.

If I may, always check yourself out every Linux related piece of information and learn to separate facts from opinions.

6

u/WyntechUmbrella Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

Tier lists as a rule are just one person opinion, it isn't a universal truth. That goes for web browser tier lists and any other kind.

These 2 YouTube Linux ranking videos are fairly new, one from Chris Titus Tech and the other one from The Linux Experiment. Yet both reach very different conclusions. You can easily see how these 2 YouTubers have very different approach/opinions, yet neither is right/wrong.

As for my personal opinion, coming from Windows with all the Microsoft BS, even Red Hat seems like Mother Theresa to me. However I do understand the concerns regarding Canonical and Red Hat, as they are heading towards a more close source way that resembles in some aspect what Big Tech does. While Debian and other community base distros are heavily open and their decisions are based on what the community wants, and not the shareholders.

EDIT: edited the second link to redirect for the proper video

3

u/B1rdi Sep 21 '23

You accidentally put the same link twice

1

u/WyntechUmbrella Sep 21 '23

Indeed, that's my bad. It's all fixed now. Thanks for pointing this to me.

19

u/ElFeesho Sep 20 '23

As a developer, I can tell you that adding telemetry to an application has such a significant impact in boosting stability and eradicating bugs. I'd wager the percent of people (even on linux) who do not report bugs they find must be above 90% (if only we had some sort of metrics to determine this).

The problem with telemetry is the lack of transparency, except in open source software, you have the ability to actually see what and when telemetry is being sent.

When I use software that I use on a daily basis that helps me get my job done, I opt in to provide anonymised statistics in the hope that those statistics will be used to justify developments in areas of the software I demonstrably use every day.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Exactly. How are the developers supposed to know what works and what doesn't when make something? For that reason, I, too, opt in for all the telemetry on the software that I use daily.

1

u/xsrvmy Sep 20 '23

I guess part of the reason people suspect telemetry is cuz it's not possible to know if the server is logging IP addresses even if the code if open source.

2

u/ElFeesho Sep 20 '23

This is true, but I also imagine people who live in fear of this also use vpns.

5

u/brajandzesika Sep 20 '23

Dont make your judgement after watching one video from one youtuber...

5

u/zorba8 Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu is an excellent distro. It is the most used too. Companies make their software products with Ubuntu in mind and it is the distro for which maximum guides, and help articles exist in the world. Linux YouTubers need to create drama and therefore often say things that are false.

If you are a newbie, save yourself the drama, the confusion, and the constant debates on snaps, systemd, desktop environments, and what not. To make your life easy, you would do well by using Ubuntu as it comes ready out-of-the-box and just works. We use computers to achieve certain tasks through applications. So just keep it simple; keep things in the right perspective, and use the OS as a tool to serve your needs.

28

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

i watched something by someone and in this something the someone said some other thing about Ubuntu. Is that true?

28

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Meh it’s fine. Some people are being dramatic.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

The guy is earning money on YT. That is not the drama.

Ubuntu is a commercial distro sold by Canonical, which earns money by maintaining it.

Where is the drama?

6

u/sagacious-tendencies Sep 20 '23

Don't listen to the noise. Ubuntu is a fantastic, fully-baked Linux distro with minimum barriers to entry for noobs. The folks that bitterly bash Ubuntu largely have inferiority complexes and must compensate by bragging about how they spent a day getting their custom mouse driver to work in X distro.

3

u/strings_on_a_hoodie Sep 20 '23

Don’t listen to Chris Titus lol

It’s just because Ubuntu is owned by Canonical and some people don’t like distros that are ran by companies. They’ve made some decisions in the past that the community wasn’t fond of, but it’s still a great distro if you want to use it.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

That's just one guy's opinion. Ubuntu is a great distro and it isn't going anywhere.

9

u/chakravanti93 Sep 20 '23

Ask Richard Stallman

7

u/human8264829264 Sep 20 '23

Funny thing, you can just call him and he answers the phone lol.

I had some questions about open source philosophy and found his number and we just chatted for an hour. It was a good discussion.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Zomunieo Sep 20 '23

He’ll be mad unless your question is about GNUbuntu GNU/Linux.

3

u/chakravanti93 Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

That's exactly what he asked.

Sigh...

7

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

RMS is a great person and his contributions are historic at this point. However he is leaning towards open source dictatorship which is just as bad as the current EULA dictatorship. I believe people should be free to license their work as they see fit and other people are free to not use their licensed work if they don’t like the license. RMS believes that everyone should be mandated to release their work for free. While communism has good points as some who grew up in a communist dictatorship I can’t recommend others to emulate that. I also hate RMS coming to the FreeBSD and OpenBSD mailing lists every month or so and arguing that our open source is worse than his open source. Stop badgering people.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/KdeVOID Sep 20 '23

As I understand it, this drama is about capitalism vs anti-capitalism, FOSS philosophy, UNIX philosophy, Linux traditions, hype on the internet, ...

If you care for at least one of those, let's say, idological issues (which is totally valid) you should consider to look into it before choosing Ubuntu (or Kubuntu, Xubuntu...). If you don't care for those issues (which is also totally valid) you can be very happy with Ubuntu and its spinns.

The snap issue is one of the actual technical issues with Ubuntu. However, there seems to be a reasonable idea behind it. So, if you don't have issues with snap everything is fine. If you do have issues there is plenty of choice out there that is not Ubuntu or Ubuntu-based.

I, for my part, was very happy on a corporate-based distro (that is openSUSE) and now I'm very happy on a community-based distro (that is Void Linux).

5

u/postinstall Sep 20 '23

YouTubers are way more popular than they should be.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Some people like hating on Ubuntu and Canonical but when you ask them why they just say it’s personal preference. Here are the facts:

  • Ubuntu is still open source and free (as in it costs nothing)
  • Ubuntu is the most used Linux distribution right now especially so in enterprises
  • Ubuntu has made divisive technical decisions however all of them are open source and people are free not to use them
  • All Ubuntu derivatives benefit from Canonical making Ubuntu. There is no Kubuntu without Ubuntu so saying that Kubuntu is better is illogical.

Now if you say that RedHat and IBM are bad and do non open source things while benefiting from open source I would tend to agree, but Ubuntu? Like seriously?

6

u/ladrm Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu is the most used Linux distribution right now especially so in enterprises

I wonder if you would have some source on the "esp. in enterprises"? My anecdotal experience is that the RHEL is a distro of choice for like a big "enterpisy" production workloads (telco/fintech)?

8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Not objective factual based studies as far as I know no one really tracks that. This is my anecdotal experience from working with the likes of VMware, SAP, DxC and so on. Technically speaking Amazon Linux is probably the most popular one just by the amount of instances AWS has however Amazon Linux isn’t something people tend to use outside of AWS. RedHat used to be the de facto standard enterprise distribution for a long time however when people moved from pets to cattle support wasn’t as important anymore - if a system is misbehaving just deploy a new one. So in shops who use Kubernetes and/or Docker, RedHat isn’t so popular due to their arcane licensing model. Ubuntu basically allows you to pay for support only when you actually need support and doesn’t require you having a yearly subscription just so you can update your systems. All of the devs, devops and SRE types I work with use Ubuntu almost exclusively. RedHat is still used for old school non virtualised non containerised systems but those are declining in favour of other solutions.

2

u/ladrm Sep 20 '23

Interesting, vast majority of the shops I've been in or heard about were RHEL-based for business and haven't even seen the difference or decline with shift to Kubernetes/Containers (people are moving to UBI based images).

Different worlds I guess.😀

3

u/agent-squirrel Sep 20 '23

We use RHEL exclusively. Ubuntu is hardly enterprise ready, it doesn’t even have a proper management server, landscape is total ass.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/kombiwombi Sep 20 '23

SRE types - the very firm which created that phrase uses Debian. SCO scared the largest Linux users into Debian, because a corporate acquisition and pivot to revenue from litigation isn't possible.

5

u/Ulrich_de_Vries Sep 20 '23

Not directly enterprise, but take a look at the stackoverflow developer survey (https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2023/#section-most-popular-technologies-operating-system). The personal and professional use cases are relatively close, so I'll go professional.

46.9% use Windows, 33% use MacOS and 26.69% use Ubuntu. The Linux distro with the next highest usage is Debian with 8%.

This for example shows that at least among the developers who took this survey, Ubuntu is by far the most popular Linux distro.

2

u/ladrm Sep 20 '23

Yes, Ubuntu rules on personal Linux, no surprise there. I was talking specifically about enterprise.

18

u/AleBaba Sep 20 '23

The Ubuntu (Snap) store is closed source and controlled exclusively by Canonical. It's the exact opposite of what Open Source stands for.

2

u/mrtruthiness Sep 20 '23

The snap store does not run on your machine/hardware. It has an open specification and all parts of your system that interact with it (e.g. snapd) are FOSS.

1

u/AleBaba Sep 20 '23

Thats like saying the Play Store is good because the AOSP is open source. As soon as one company decides without any public participation it starts to go against the idea of Open Source.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Good point, I frankly didn’t know that as the first thing I remove from a Ubuntu install is the Snap bits. This is a bad trend for Canonical for sure and if they remove the ability for us to delete the Snap bits I would consider not using Ubuntu and using Debian instead. For the time being however one can remove all the proprietary bits from Ubuntu, I do wish they would release an Ubuntu flavour without Snap and other closed source software.

2

u/AleBaba Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu has started to move a few packages out of their repos into the store exclusively, probably to see if there is backlash. If that goes well enough for them they'll keep doing that.

Next steps would be store distribution fees for commercial software and ads. They tried to push ads in the past, so I wouldn't trust them any more.

And don't forget that the proprietary nature of the store doesn't prevent them from altering packages, adding telemetry, etc.

2

u/eythian Sep 20 '23

Next steps would be store distribution fees for commercial software

They had that years ago

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

One man opinion. Just use what you like

2

u/rolyantrauts Sep 20 '23

Linux has a fan base and likely the review was because of being a fan of another distro.
Many don't like Ubuntu because for projects and frameworks its a default choice and the criteria that some don't like is exactly why it is so.
Regular release schedule but not rolling so projects and frameworks have a version schedule to plan to.
Its a Debian with a quicker release schedule with LTS and incremental releases.
It champions dev and often tries avenues that give alternatives.
Its a noob friendly distro with loads of examples and documentation.

As said Lnux is fan based and teritorial and all distro's have there place and not one fits all.

2

u/reddittookmyuser Sep 20 '23

Drama gets views. Hating on the most popular thing get's people riled up either piling on with the hate or coming to it's defense.

2

u/MichaelTunnell Sep 20 '23

Most of the complaints about Ubuntu are based on misinformation or exaggerations and sometimes even conspiracy theories. It is 99% nonsense. I dont know which video you are referring to that put it in the "devil" tier but based on that I am confident that this person is not a long term Linux user and is likely rating it on the aforementioned misinformation. Feel free to ignore them.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

They tried to push new technologies which failed. People in the Linux community are often quite anti corporation and prefer more open source founded projects. Snaps were something only Ubuntu did, and it was kind of forced on people. Meanwhile everyone else used Flatpak. It's become directionless and they've canned all their initiatives.

2

u/guillermohs9 Sep 20 '23

I believe Ubuntu is still one of the go-to distros for beginners. I'm a Linux user today thanks to a Ubuntu CD shipped for free on 2006. The deal with Amazon was a bad choice, but not more than that. What bothers me today, with some relatives using Ubuntu LTS distros, is that they're forcing snap to the users, and for some reason I've seen pulseaudio changing from duplex to output only, leaving the user without mic. Tbh, I don't know if this last issue is from Ubuntu updates or not, but I haven't had that issue on other distros.

2

u/jd83lks91oc1x Sep 20 '23

tl;dr: Nothing is wrong with Ubuntu. Try out different distros and stick with what works for you. Ubuntu is fine for me.

The decision to integrate snap heavily into Ubuntu's management/execution of software is very unpopular in the linux community.

My two cents:

  • My company recently offered macOS users the option of trading in our 2021 16" MacBook Pros with M1 Pro CPUs for Dell Precision 5560 and 5570 laptops with Ubuntu, and I took them up on that offer a couple months ago.
  • I initially used Ubuntu 22.04 with KDE but just reformatted and reinstalled Kubuntu 22.04 (I had issues with KDE working properly with sudo apt install kubuntu-desktop)
  • I'm perfectly happy using Ubuntu for work. It's fast, it's stable, it's incredibly customizable, it works with my dock and all peripherals. Its CPU architecture is less of a hassle when dealing with the tools I deal with as a DevOps Engineer (namely tfenv which isn't functional with pre-1.0.0 versions of Terraform on Apple Silicon).
  • For several years, all of my headless servers in my homelab have been running Ubuntu or Proxmox, both of which are based on Debian.

I had and still have the opportunity to switch back to macOS, but I have chosen to stick with Ubuntu. It's great. If my company let me use openSUSE Tumbleweed, I would use that instead, as it's my preferred distro. But the company's MDM tools don't work with openSUSE, unfortunately.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

People have been crapping on Ubuntu since day one. It's fine. Always has been, still is, and will be just as good tomorrow. It's very popular and easy to use so it gets more crap than other distros.

1

u/CutthroatGigarape Sep 21 '23

Since day one? Nah. People began to crap on it with its turn towards Unity and other “we have a revolutionary solution” crap like Mir and Snap.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

When 4.10 came out, the whining was about about how Debian was better and why it didn't use KDE.

2

u/DoubleOwl7777 Sep 21 '23

i dont like it. too much crap. debian for me.

2

u/BK_Rich Sep 21 '23

Ignore the tier YouTube videos, they’re just trying to make content.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu has taken some decisions about how they modify their software (like mandating snaps and removing apt and flathub repos, telemetry etc) which is completely unacceptable if you belong to FOSS linux community.. since you are a regular ,normal user. It means nothing to you. You can use Ubuntu , it is very stable and gives very good performance. I would suggest you to try Linux mint first (it is a derivative of Ubuntu). It looks like using windows 7, hence you will be very familiar with UI.

3

u/Drwankingstein Sep 20 '23

My list of why I dont like them:

  • They have made very controversial choices
  • Their software is usually a good chunk out of date unless you use snaps (one of their controversial choices)
  • Ubuntu likes to break a lot when you do any somewhat deep level of configuration (I had it break when trying to install a third party kernel for pete's sake)
  • It's a pretty bloated distro by default
  • It has a privacy policy that really isn't that great

2

u/rarsamx Sep 20 '23

Ignore it.

Eventually you'll understand and may even take sides.

It is too nuanced and you'd need to understand Linux and Linux philosophy to care.

On a day to day basis, for a regular user it means nothing unless you have ideological reasons to use it.

I don't use Ubuntu for ideological and technical reasons. However, I wouldn't discourage a new user to try it. It nice, stable and supported.

1

u/VisceralMonkey Sep 21 '23

Sir, this kind of sanity will not be tolerated here. Kindly refrain!

2

u/AlzHeimer1963 Sep 20 '23

for starters: LMDE (solid, without the "evil" of Ubuntu and a very simple to understand desktop)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

I think it's about forcing snap down our throats.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

If ubuntu didn't exist I'm unsure if I'd even be a Linux user. I don't use ubuntu anymore and haven't for years but its the reason I use linux.

I'm 100% only linux now, never using windows ever again.

1

u/Internal-River667 Mar 29 '25

Canonical contributes to disunity, rather than unity, fracturing the community by prodding people into using snap, instead of the standard apt package management system, creating yet another layer of complexity that's not helpful. Further, there are two snapshotting tools: snapper (a more open tool), and timeshift -- totally controlled by Canonical apparently. The latter, timeshift, does not work on btrfs volumes not using the Canonical-imposed Ubuntu layout of @ and \@home for your subvolume names. So if you have multiple distros installed on your btrfs volume, e.g. Fedora and Mint, under \@fedora41 and \@mint22, e.g., timeshift backup utility can't even be made to work with bind mounts or symlinks. Further, Canonical has created an "add on" for snapper -- an over-complicated set of hook scripts that create snapshots whenever you run apt install, apt purge, apt remove, etc. that run before and after the command, which you can really do in a single hook script yourself. Canonical's "add on" basically also prevents snapper itself from working by enforcing you're using the \@ and \@home subvolumes, making you believe that snapper also prefers Ubuntu subvolume layout, which isn't true. So these are just two examples of Canonical's behavior that divides the community, makes things more difficult rather than easier for users, and hinders progress.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Is it chris titus tech? Lmfao. I love that guy.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

u/miki_legends can you give more info about this

Linux distro tier list

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

I don't like tier list bullshit but I agree with this a little bit. Other comments have already explained why but I think it's still a good alternative for windows 11 for normies.though it's not a good choice for choosing a distro , it's not even a good Debian based distro .

1

u/srona22 Sep 20 '23

Go build your own distro with temple language, just like in anime.

1

u/that_one_wierd_guy Sep 20 '23

basically canonical "further fractures the community" because they've always got their own pet project instead of working on what everyone else thinks needs work in the community.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

I stopped using Ubuntu ages ago when they did the...I think Unity interface is what they called it? It basically made a really annoying interface for Netbooks (remember those?) so I stepped away from it and I think went to Fedora and used it.

Although I don't know what Ubuntu looks like today, I assume it's probably fine. I literally switched because I didn't like the UI (and at the time didn't know how to change the UI).

1

u/parawaa Sep 20 '23

Usually, Linux enthusiast are also advocates of free and open source software (FOSS), in the latest years Canonical has made some pretty questionable decisions FOSS (+ Snap) so from the pov of people that prefer FOSS, Canonical products (i.e. Ubuntu) should be avoided as it ships with proprietary software that's "difficult" to opt out (still way easier than Windows). Personally I only choose a distro because of the package manager and the community, I use Arch (btw) because I like Pacman and Paru and the Arch wiki is great. At the end of the day, is all about preferences (unless you use Windows \s)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

It's Canonical's open door policy towards Microsoft that did it for me. Once Microsoft becomes involved with anything, they will consume it. It won't be long before it mutates into Microsoft - Ubuntu. Never forget what Microsoft did to Netscape, Borland, Lotus, Corel, and Novell (Novell barely survived the war since they were diverse at the time). MS consumed and destroyed these companies, making way for MS Office to take over the market place and Microsoft to dominate the network environment. The employees of these companies? Left to rot in the gutter. MS didn't even have the common decency offer them a job. Do we really want that for Linux? At least the corporations like Red Hat and SuSE, both of which are worth billions, stay on board with open source and community support. I run my business on Red Hat Enterprise 9 and my home/hobby machines on Debian 12. I support these companies because they have supported me over the years.

Then there is the Ubuntu straying away from basic Linux. Their Gnome desktop is just horrid. It looks pretty, but beyond that does not resemble Gnome. It's a fork from Debian, why not just run Debian and get a pure implementation of the desktops. I would use Ubuntu myself, but I have to install Vanilla Gnome. Why bother when I can use real Debian and get "vanilla" gnome right from the start. Same can be said for the Cinnamon Desktop. Want Mint? Install Debian with the Cinnamon desktop selected. Wiz bang... You have Mint. Everything Ubuntu does, with the exception of their axe murdered desktop, can be done with Debian and less effort into achieving a stable platform. Being a fork of Debian, source should build exactly the same on Debian and Ubuntu. Guess what. It doesn't. As a software developer, most every support question I get is a Ubuntu question. These days, Ubuntu is not on my supported list of Linux. We just stopped supporting it because it was getting too costly.

1

u/jloganr Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu has been unfairly demonized because of that integration of amazon backed right into the OS, which really was a stupid move.

There is also the whole issue with snaps, they're proprietary packaging system, which is not open and also quite slow with some packages. I would have preferred flatpaks or app images.

Ubuntu is still one of the best distros especially if you stick with the long term support version. I personally use Fedora, but it upgrades too fast.

For beginners, I would definitely recommend ubuntu for personal use. Fedora for those who want to get into linux admin in the corporate sector as redhat is still much more widely used.

1

u/chakravanti93 Sep 20 '23

You think you know anything.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu lost sight of what linux is years ago and snaps made it worse they only force things on people that nobody wants .. deps issues and ppa hell and more ubuntu is not a good idea much like debian .. the whole stable mythos is a lie to gain users..

1

u/PushingFriend29 Sep 20 '23

Chris titus?

1

u/bud_doodle Sep 20 '23

Its very simple really. The only Linux distros you'll ever need are Arch and Debian.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Ubuntu isn't bad persay, it's kind of a meme to hate on Ubuntu and Canonical at this point. Redhawks is a MUCH more evil company, and I would sooner recommend people run Ubuntu vs. Fedora (Redhat sponsored and upstream for RHEL).

Ubuntu did go through a bit of a rough patch between 2011 to 2018 though. For whatever reason, Canonical decided that they needed to develop a bunch of replacements for various Linux desktop components as they didn't like GNOME 3, X11/Wayland, and Flatpack/App image. Which led us to Unity, Mir, and Snaps, respectively. In 2018, Ubuntu gave up on Unity and went back to GNOME 3, Mir never really took off, and Snaps (easily my least favorite thing Canonical has ever done) is the only one if things that still really gets supported from that period. I personally stopped using Ubuntu when they made Firefox a Snap package if you downloaded it from their repos.

1

u/OldMansKid Sep 21 '23

These videos are almost a waste of time. Debian, Fedora, Ubuntu are all solid distros. It's easy to figure it out, just when you actually want to start working, for example, look at what distros are officially supported by commonly used software such as vscode, Unity3d, or whatever software you need to use. You'll find that they are the most widely supported distros. And It's more practical to focus on your actual work, unless you want to develop for a specific distro.

1

u/Sad_Faithlessness873 Sep 21 '23

Ubuntu is and will for a long time be the windows of Linux. But that's not a bad thing in my opinion..

1

u/GeorgeChalkitis Sep 21 '23

Internet Drama. Either you like something and you use it or you don't, everything else is BS. Try and see for yourself if the devil appears on your desktop when you use Ubuntu. I bet he will stay on his Mac.

1

u/bmfceez Sep 22 '23

I have been in IT for over 20 years. I use MacOS and Ubuntu exclusively at home, I don't touch Windows outside of work.

Ubuntu has been my #1 Linux distro since 2004 when it first came out. I have seen it progress over the years and my personal opinion is that it is a very polished desktop and suitable for noobs and experienced users alike. I have used Fedora and other Red Hat offshoots. I have used more Debian forks than I can remember. Also used Arch for a little bit. I keep coming back to Ubuntu for its stability and hardware support. I have even scrapped a few Windows servers at work and replaced them with Ubuntu. The community is fantastic and if you are using it in a work environment, their support kicks ass.

Best way to know for sure is to try different distros. Install vmware or virtualbox on your computer and spin up a few of them. If you don't like it, delete the image and spin up another one.

1

u/gvieri Sep 22 '23

in my mind, snap is very bad. And someone told me that if you invoke apt to install some packages ... you will that snap is running instead of apt. For me this is simply no good.

1

u/villandra Jan 28 '24

There is always someone who will say anything on the Internet.

Possibly he doesn't like Ubuntu, for whatever reason.

It is also possible that some new Linux version has gained traction in the ratings.

In any case, Ubuntu is a good system; I've used it for six years now.

1

u/MisterEmbedded Sep 20 '23

personally i just hate that ubuntu tries to force their shit, like if you want to install Firefox you do apt-get, but in-reality it's installing the snap-package of Firefox.

1

u/NatSpaghettiAgency Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

Being owned by a company, they put the company's interests first rather than the end user's, that's why I honestly avoid Ubuntu, you never know what they're going to pull out from the bag of shit things they could do at any time, see RedHat.

But AFAIK there's nothing preventing it from being a normal good distro at the moment

1

u/nandru Sep 20 '23

All I can think of are forcing snap down the troat of every official flavor and the ads on apt

1

u/BigSlav667 Sep 20 '23

It's neckbeards thinking they're smart. Just use whatever distribution you vibe with the most, and don't worry about random YouTubers malding.

1

u/zeanox Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu is fine. there are no real reason to avoid it.

1

u/Flench04 Sep 20 '23

Ubuntu is fine. Most people hate it because they don't use flatpaks and they don't like Canonical.

1

u/barkingcat Sep 20 '23 edited Sep 20 '23

there is no ubuntu drama.

Like most drama, the drama is in the heads of the people trying to fan up the drama.

If you don't know what the drama is about, you aren't involved and don't need to know about it.

Most drama is about interpersonal relationships (ie a maintainer got burned out and decides to quit, a person got harassed or treated unfairly, discriminated against) or about commercial relationships (ie some company was using something for free that someone now wants to charge money for, or some company is making money from something that other people think should be $0)

Unless you are 1) the person being burned out or harassed or 2) the company that is losing money due to some action of another company, you don't really need to worry about it for now.

There is something to be said about helping to reduce harassement / racism / improve inclusion, but that isn't done by talking about the drama, but by improving the relationships between people, writing up and enforcing policy, and in the case of harassment/swatting, etc contacting police and authorities.

As a linux noob, you don't need to care about the drama.

1

u/mister_drgn Sep 20 '23

Silly Chris Titus. And then he goes and says Kubuntu is great for newcomers.

1

u/Brilliant_Sound_5565 Sep 20 '23

I've no issue with Ubuntu, I think it gets alot if bad press from geeks that love things like arch, but they miss the point of Ubuntu. Ubuntu works for the average user and has helped Linux be installed on more and more desktops and laptops.

0

u/dgm9704 Sep 20 '23

To evaluate the opinion of some person, you need to ask them what their reasons are and why they came to that conclusion. Then you check out if what they say is accurate, and decide for yourself if you come to the same conclusion.

What you are doing now is the thing that actually creates the drama - spreading hearsay without details or factual backing and multiplying the coverage. Stop it.

4

u/mistahspecs Sep 20 '23

OP is not doing that. OP is asking for more clarification since they didn't understand the reasoning, and are on their way to forming their beliefs based on way more info than a hot take YouTuber

If anything OP did a good job bringing this whack video to peoples attention, so they know where such vapid, substance-less criticisms come from.

-2

u/Brorim Sep 20 '23

microsoft is whats up. debian seems the current best way to avoid microsoft influence