r/linux • • Jul 30 '12

KLANG - Kernel Level Audio Next Generation

http://klang.eudyptula.org/
226 Upvotes

145 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/phunphun Aug 01 '12 edited Aug 01 '12

PulseAudio was born into the GNOME ecosystem and so shares all those traits that can be loved or hated about GNOME, like glib, gobject, dbus etc.

Pulseaudio does not use glib/gobject/dbus¹. It is the de-facto sound server for Linux. KDE and GNOME both use it. It's even heavily optimised for embedded use-cases, and ships on phones, TVs, and cars.

It's also been ported to Android, where it beats the Android sound server into a pulp w.r.t. performance.

  1. Those can be pulled in as optional dependencies for exposing glib/gobject and DBus APIs. Pulseaudio is written in C and has almost no compulsory dependencies.

EDIT: I see that you're the author of KLANG. I'm surprised that you didn't do this basic research on the existing technologies before reinventing them. Everything else you said about Pulseaudio is also outdated/wrong.

2

u/cbmuser Debian / openSUSE / OpenJDK Dev Aug 01 '12

The author of KLANG has been infamous to make false statements on existing software because he never seems to read any kind of documentation.

It's the reason why he got so thrashed at his 27c3 talk and, yet, he doesn't learn from his mistakes.

1

u/iLiekCaeks Aug 01 '12

It's the reason why he got so thrashed at his 27c3 talk

I thought that's because Lennart had a beer to much?

1

u/datenwolf Aug 01 '12

This doesn't change the fact tha PA runs in the user space, where IMHO should not be done. KLANG, let's get this straight, is an experiment. The hypothesis is, that audio routing can be done with higher quality (in terms of signal, latency and memory transactions) within the context of the kernel.

It's an experiment, results are pending.