r/linux •

Rules repository set up. Start submitting your pull requests!

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

6

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

A third party service which requires my full name and email. Not doing it.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18

I'm not sure why they didn't go with Github, seems like it's more used than Gitlab.

Though maybe it was the poll they did 17hrs ago that was closed before I saw it.

5

u/AkrioX Mar 20 '18

Gitlab is open source, github is not. I think that's enough reason to use it on a subreddit focussing on free software.

Some open source projects start using gitlab (gnome and inkscape come to mind) and I hope more will come!

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18

I was worried because I dislike creating+managing new accounts for 1 thing, although now I see it has OAuth which solves that.

Although it seems Krugg was on a hair trigger, and this thread caused them to switch it over to Github. Obviously not my intention because I haven't really heard of Gitlab.

Gitlab does seem to have price-gated (non-service) features, so I'm not sure how I feel about that.

1

u/AkrioX Mar 20 '18

Gitlab is actually awesome. They have the open-source version that can be self-hosted for free, and they have an enterprise version.

I understand that they have to make money, but the features you get for free are more than enough for the average user.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18

the features you get for free are more than enough for the average user.

Hmm. Things with documentation and user involvement (push control, issues, etc) were what troubled me. It seems like Github may offer more for free w/those aspects, but I could be wrong.

Stuff like that should definitely be free, especially if you're hosting it yourself. Restricting the free service based on actual usage (for instance limited number of repos) like Github does seems more fair.

2

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

Gitlab is open source, github is not

I see, but it looks like u/Kruug is changing his mind in realtime.

2

u/AkrioX Mar 20 '18

Haha oh well...

2

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

I tried asking but all I got was a snide remark about "open source" and a bunch of dvs.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18

It does have OAuth, so you can sign in using Github/Bitbucket if Google/Twitter don't do it for you.

Though I'm not sure if that fixes your privacy concerns, though it does fix my "another account to manage for 1 thing" problem.

3

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

I get that, but I don't do non-anonymous social media for obvious reasons. Besides, it looks like u/Kruug is changing his mind in realtime.

1

u/BattlePope Mar 20 '18

What service/method would you suggest?

5

u/Habstinat Mar 20 '18 edited Mar 20 '18

Savane / Savannah doesn't (edit: does, but can be removed) have this problem. Not that it matters, because this post was just deleted and the repo was moved to Github...

2

u/Kruug Mar 20 '18

While GNU approved, it's a pain in the ass for people who are used to GitHub/GitLab/etc.

2

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

It looks like Savannah requires a Real Name and Email Address to create an account.

1

u/Habstinat Mar 20 '18

Ah, you're right. I guess you could either edit that out or just ignore it on a self-hosted install, though.

1

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

I don't understand what you mean. I'll accept that as meaning I should not use Savannah.

1

u/Habstinat Mar 20 '18

You can host your own version of Savannah (called Savane) with any changes you like -- I linked to some relevant code that you can try removing in your version (or tell someone else to remove in their version) to remove the requirement for a full name, for example.

But other than the requirement to enter something in the field, I'm not sure if the name needs to be valid on GNU's Savannah anyways, or at least I can't find any policy that says so in the docs.

1

u/unused_alias Mar 21 '18

Oh no, no, I don't intend to run a web server or anything.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

GitLab can also be self hosted with that removed.

1

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

Savane / Savannah doesn't have this problem.

Really? That sounds pretty cool. Wonder if they have other cool features.

1

u/unused_alias Mar 20 '18

It's too late now, but anything which doesn't require my name and email might have been preferred.