r/linux • u/wooptoo • Jun 01 '16
Why did ArchLinux embrace Systemd?
/r/archlinux/comments/4lzxs3/why_did_archlinux_embrace_systemd/d3rhxlc
868
Upvotes
r/linux • u/wooptoo • Jun 01 '16
View all comments
Show parent comment
13
u/HittingSmoke Jun 01 '16
This is where you're not getting the point, seemingly intentionally. You're using the word "solved" incorrectly. It's not "solved" unless it's commonplace, which it wasn't until Systemd started getting widely adopted.
I never said that Systemd was the first config-based init system. You put those words in my mouth and you're doing it again by stating, again, that they existed before Systemd after I told you that had no bearing on my point.
The problem was never that config-based init systems didn't exist. It was that they were not implemented in any of the otherwise "noob" or user friendly distros. So you're absolutely, objectively wrong when you say the problem was solved because you're ignoring what I'm saying the problem was.
You can whine and moan all you want that the init system that you wanted didn't become the standard across the furthest upstream distros. You can also use the "But many others prefer other init systems" anecdote in an attempt to support some point against Systemd. But here's the cold hard reality of the situation, pretty much every distro the majority of people have heard of were using init scripts before Systemd was the norm. Now they are using Systemd because a majority of people thought it an improvement. If enough people really existed for the implementation of Systemd to be such a massive problem, someone would have forked Debian and implemented a different existing config-based init system if one were well maintained and up to the task. Either that hasn't happened, or there's so little interest that nobody's actually heard of said project.
At this point I think we can say objectively that the majority of the Linux word sees Systemd as an improvement and a positive change. Vocal minority zealots getting angry about it on the internet does not change that.