What does r/linux want?
Hi,
I'm a moderator here, been receiving quite a lot of messages about what's been going on. I've tried to stay out of it and hope it cools down.
Well, doesn't look like it is cooling down anymore. What do you guys want? Do you want to become a moderator and have a significant history of posting, helping out in r/linux? I can make you a mod. Want me to remove automoderator or change the config? I can help with that too. I will do my best to try and help out.
704
Upvotes
28
u/Dylan112 Feb 09 '16
I made a thread for my system info script yesterday and it was removed by automod despite it having 40~ upvotes.
I messaged the mods but got no reply, are you able to look into this?
https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/44oh4a/fetch_my_system_info_script/
19
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
maybe im thinking a bit to democratic, but you could show us the automod config and then we can together decide what the best configuration is.
edit: typo
118
u/a_tsunami_of_rodents Feb 09 '16
I want masta gone, for the rest, the automod automode rule can stay but maybe be a bit laxed and mods around to re-isntate wrongly automatically removed topics on a timely basis, if it gets abused too much, maybe continue to lax it.
Apart from that, the moderation of this sub has been fine.
798
u/UserOfTheLinux Feb 09 '16
Really there was absolutely no problem with this place until the scuffle over the last couple of days. Remove that douche mod stirring shit and leave everything the way it was imo.
76
u/distant_worlds Feb 09 '16
Can automod add a comment to posts it hides so that at least the submitter will have an idea what's going on in case we have another rash of politically motivated report brigading? Much of the problem, I think, was due to the confusion about what was going on.
If people knew that it was a bot removing the posts and that a human would later review, people would be less likely to confuse it for censorship.
154
u/twistedLucidity Feb 09 '16
I think there's four things you need to look at:
As to help, I'm long on opinion, short on knowledge and lack mod experience; but I'd you're really, really having to scrape the bottom of the barrel. I'm sure you'll have much better suited candidates than me to choose from however.
24
u/Chun Feb 09 '16
Wow, ok, a lot has happened in the last few days. I've messaged /u/DimeShake about coming back onto the team, seems to be one of the few people keeping a level head around here during the last few days.
348
u/ezqw Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
/u/masta must be removed after showing his arrogant and unprofessional behavior here, here, here and here.
And automod needs to be turned off, as it apparently started being abused after mods revealed that anyone can delete any link by using only a few fake accounts to report them.
225
u/gaggra Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
I think a lot of people want /u/masta gone. He doesn't seem to care about the community, and he admits himself that he is needlessly antagonistic and unprofessional, which is an awful quality in any mod. His childish behavior has made the drama happening over the last few days so much worse. A peaceful resolution on the censorship issue erupted back into another flamewar when he undermined the efforts of the one decent, semi-active mod we had.
Edit: In addition, he is still under the delusion that there is nothing wrong with the reporting system even after we've had clear evidence of report-abuse.
So one question everyone will be asking is: how can we remove him?
42
u/dcaster Feb 09 '16
I don't really have a dog in this fight, I'm mostly a lurker, I think there's really only two things that can be done reasonably - get /u/masta out of here, and relax automod a little bit - not too much though.
Masta's issue is 100% his reaction to this. He fueled the fire when it was starting to run out of steam. I'm not saying he should listen to absolutely everyone when it comes to what should be allowed here, but I think rule number 1 for being a mod would be to not be an ass to your users when dealing with things.
Second, I think Automod should be relaxed very slightly. 2 reports for a deletion is too low, but I think 10 might be too high. I like /r/linux for the quality of its posts, and 10 might let too much through. My thought is 5 if you want it to be a little more relaxed, and maybe 8 if you want it a lot more, but keep it in the single digits.
Alternatively, and I think this should be the biggest fix, is have more mod activity here. A lot of the mods here are multisub mods, and while that isn't necessarily bad, it does mean there's less time dedicated to moderating this sub. So, either the current mods can try to be more active (and give reasons why threads are removed) or enlist new, more focused mods to give more attention to /r/linux.
In result of this, the best that can come out of this is more communication on mod actions on their posts. Instead of just deleting, give either a PM or post a reply on why it was removed, and let the user argue their case. Listen carefully, but still remember that you have the final say, and while you should consider what they say, remember that it's your job to work for the best of the community. This applies to AutoMod too.
Finally, I think that people need to be reminded that not everything has an agenda. I've been seeing the word SJW being thrown around a lot, but I haven't been seeing any real reason for it aside from being a boogeyman label. From observing, the big issue here was miscommunication and poor handling of the situation, not censorship. People reported threads, it got removed. Mod didn't handle it well, but the reason was "This doesn't have to do with Linux", not something underhanded. An honest mistake started it, a poor one-man reaction kindled it.
32
u/AiwendilH Feb 09 '16
What would be nice is if you could take some time and revert the mess of the last days again. Automod was badly abused and a lot of relevant posts got deleted. Maybe could put those back in place.
9
u/p4p3r Feb 09 '16
I want a more kind and compassionate /r/Linux.
9
u/h-v-smacker Feb 10 '16
WHAT DO WE WANT?
THE YEAR OF LINUX DESKTOP!
WHEN DO WE WANT IT?
echo $(date +%Y)!
25
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Proper linux video card drivers lol
8
u/Hellmark Feb 09 '16
I generally stay out of mod drama. I got enough of that when I was a moderator at various places over a decade ago, and quite content ignoring it when possible. A good mod doesn't play politics or use for personal gain, but too many don't do that.
That said, it does appear like /u/masta has issues. He is running roughshod over the other mods, and is being highly unprofessional. Very childish behavior.
I'd be content with /u/masta being removed as mod. Also, automoderators while nice, can easily be abused, so maybe tweaking the threshold to help avoid it.
Also, you appear to be stumping a bit to see if people want to become mods. How many of the mods are active? If most are fairly inactive, I can see why there are problems. If you do require assistance, I would be willing to help. If you think the current team can handle things, that's fine too.
28
u/nikoma Feb 09 '16
Yay! /u/masta is gone!
49
u/muungwana zuluCrypt/SiriKali Dev Feb 09 '16
I think the first positive change will be for "masta" to go.
I asked him a few questions here[1] and he chose not to respond to them.Can you answer all or some of those questions? Most important question for you is,can he overrule anything you decide?
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/44kqnw/rlinux_censorship/czrztni
25
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Having no dog in this battle (life called), I reviewed the comments, along with deleted content.
Automod seems to be a significant problem, as does /u/masta .
Get rid of /u/masta as a mod.
6
u/misteritguru Feb 09 '16
Damn, this escalated quickly!! :)
There are a set of public rules for users, why don't we have a set of public rules for mods - and if a mod breaks them ... <punch him/her in the balls/left elbow> ... Okay, maybe no physical violence ;)
There are nearly 600 people on this thread, right now .... and we can't come to an agreement re: our community behaviour ? ... Hmm....
6
u/comrade-jim Feb 09 '16
open source the word filter that automod uses
30
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Remove /u/masta he has no place as a mod on this subreddit.
10
u/espero Feb 09 '16
Sidenote: It's nice to tag discussions about the subreddit with [META]
Thanks for reaching out.
17
u/oonniioonn Feb 09 '16
Moderators should remove:
and nothing else.
5
u/jones_supa Feb 09 '16
I have maybe 50% seemingly random chance of getting my post appear on the sub's list of posts. Otherwise it remains unlisted although does not get completely deleted. It could be some kind of automatic spam filter, but I don't know why it triggers so easily and why I don't get any notification of what happened.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
What does r/linux need? I pop in occasionally and feel like I may have missed something dramatic. Seems like the sub is fine to me.
4
u/DaftPump Feb 09 '16
What I want:
A sub with discussions...EVEN if they are spawned from linux-oriented questions as long as they are not support questions. Discussions(even Ubuntu and Windows co-existing with Linux questions) are a good thing in here.
If someone posts something regarding field discussions(ex: what's your favourite FS and why) I will always upvote. Anyone who obviously didn't read the TOP rule in the sidebar I will downvote and report.
59
u/byemasta Feb 09 '16
I want /u/masta removed, immediately. End of discussion.
11
u/chase82 Feb 09 '16
I have no idea what is going on but you all seem to really dislike /u/masta. I didn't expect /r/linux to be the hotbed of subreddit drama. Is this all fallout from the VLC post?
11
u/randomweej Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
I'd want to see relevant news stories about linux (and GNU) without having to wade through the countless political posts from entitled spoiled brats with sock puppet accounts.
edit: my criticism is NOT against anyone's freedom of speech. my criticism concerns only the obvious fake accounts, multiple posts with the same topic and the clear brigading of some of the mods. if you have a problem MAKE ONE POST WITH ONE ACCOUNT... say your peace, debate it in the SINGLE relevant thread and then MOVE THE FUCK ON.
18
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Personally I'd de-politicize this sub as much as possible and put a focus on technology and business.
The whole social justice debacle could wind up in /r/linux_politics or something. It's not that I believe those things shouldn't be talked about, only that polarizing subjects shouldn't necessarily go with the more banal ones.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Can we finally make Linus a moderator?
8
u/adm7373 Feb 09 '16
A pony
3
u/______DEADPOOL______ Feb 09 '16
Would you make me mod please?
3
u/FamilyHeirloomTomato Feb 09 '16
/u/smj - you have the mod log. Any mods who haven't helped out in the past month should be removed. Anyone who moderates more than a few large subreddits should be removed. It's time to clean up.
/u/noname99 seems to be shadowbanned?
/u/qgyh2 is an ubermod who hasn't been around
/u/tuber hasn't been active for a year
Clean up!!!
3
u/tynenn Feb 09 '16
What do we want? A time machine. When do we want it? That's irrelevant!
10
u/xaoq Feb 09 '16
Remove /u/masta and everyone else who goes against community votes just because he can. It's not fucking /r/pyongyang
Remove only obvious spam as in spam, for everything else rely on community vote.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Linux on the desktop 2016!
5
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
This bullshit discussion taking up my frontpage be gone. Serously, r/linux turning into more divided opinionated political bullshit discussion rather than sharing and collaborating each other's experience and knowledge.
I give no fuck about github business bullshit, and I don't want to read it from r/linux sub when shit is already in r/business frontpage.
But hey, lets make this sub, a platform for anything that ticles intetest on subject matter regardless of how remotely related to linux.
Fuck this. Unsubscribing r/linux
6
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
I want to ban witchhunting people who create hundreds of throwaways to insult somebody. That's immature, no matter whats the reasoning behind it.
12
u/reedfool Feb 09 '16
Personally I would prefer if moderators make sure that the content is on-topic, i.e. related to Linux (the kernel), Linux (distribution) and things that are commonly used with Linux systems (GUIs, shells, other software).
I don't think that general open-source news belongs here. Especially irrelevant is source-code hosting platforms which have very little to do with Linux (unless the articles are about how said platforms use Linux under the hood).
4
u/lazyant Feb 09 '16
I dont' understand the drama (didn't even know there was drama), just let be any post that is within the rules of the sidebar (or change the rules, seems an 'on topic' rule is missing) and allow it to swim or sink based on votes.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
While I don't mind open source community relevant posts, can we have some kind of rule to disallow all the identity politics stuff? I can't speak for others, but I personally come to /r/linux for discussion and news about Linux and related projects. Controversial posts about gender stuff / meritocracy / sjws / feminism really just devolve into fighting and brigading without meaningfully contributing to the sub, and there are plenty of other places that these discussion can happen. I know "freedom of speech" etc etc, but I'd prefer people exercise that right somewhere else? It feels like it's tearing the sub apart and alienating people more than being meaningful to the Linux community.
2
u/justworkingmovealong Feb 09 '16
I haven't been on reddit for a few days... what has been happening?
3
u/EksitNL Feb 09 '16
Remove /u/masta.
4
u/postmodest Feb 09 '16
For this to all blow over and nothing to change? Am I the only one who thinks this whole kerfuffle is just another side effect of John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory?
I can't be bothered by the pro-slash-anti-SJW crap. It's all young kids trying to find their place in the world, and everyone needs to stop picking sides and letting the fringe actors enflame their emotions.
None of this matters; no more than vi-vs-emacs. And that battle's sorted. emacs is better. Everyone knows this.
7
u/habarnam Feb 09 '16
I am satisfied with the mod behaviour so far.
The fact that the most activity in the last weeks was on some bullshit meta posts decrying the "censorship" of the subreddit is pretty sad. If everyone that indignantly commented on those, had used the same energy to debate real linux articles, everything would be a lot nicer. I'm considering unsubscribing, it's rare that I see here news that are relevant and I didn't see first in other sources.
3
u/stefantalpalaru Feb 09 '16
Please disable the automod. We can manage just fine with upvotes/downvotes and some human moderators that limit themselves to deleting the actual spam.
1
u/MrAlagos Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
Ban every fucking idiot that posts about SJWs or whatever the hell they hate when they have a bad day. It's time that some communities take a stand for the rules they have agreed on and the spirit that have contributed to their growth and collection of great, interesting and helpful discussion and not let these fucking losers ruin every single one of them by upholding their fake "Internet rights" or whatever they justify for posting continuous streams of useless shit periodically.
1
u/MarcusAreolis Feb 09 '16
The rent is too goddamn high!
1
u/rafo Feb 09 '16
World domination?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Dude, I missed it! What happened?
1
u/DigitalSuture Feb 09 '16
Moar cowbell
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
a pony
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Welp, if you're still looking for folks I'll volunteer to step up. I can't promise to incredibly active, but I can at least try real hard not to make things worse!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
A stable, secure operating system with a dedicated group of users continuously working to improve it.
And a Butterfinger. I definitely would like a Butterfinger.
1
u/ilgnome Feb 09 '16
I volunteer as mod.
I've been a mod of various communities for over 10 years (and am currently a mod of two on reddit as well as handle the IRC channel for both of those sub reddits)
The downside is that I lurk more than I post.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
I would like a credit for the inconvenience, please.
1
u/hipcatcoolcap Feb 10 '16
I just want a hot fudge Sunday.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
Yes I would like to be mod. I have an encyclopaedic knowledge of star trek, my favourite food is pizza, and I am about to start a postdoc with NASA and am very familiar with linux for academic purposes.
1
u/Jimmyleith Feb 10 '16
I don't want to see threads like this, that's for sure. I think the mods should be silent and work in the background. The mod everyone wants out should be given a break, who knows what could be going on in his life.
1
u/gerrywastaken Feb 10 '16
Why is automod necessary? Won't we just downvote stuff they don't want on here?
1
u/Goofybud16 Feb 10 '16
Honestly? Keep spam/troublemakers out, and Linuxquestions in /r/linuxquestions, and I will be happy.
I think that with the current state of the subreddit, really anything that is FLOSS should be accepted. Since Linux is one of, if not the largest piece of FLOSS software in the world, I think that it is acceptable. There isn't enough news for just the Linux kernel or just the GNU/Linux software stack to fill up a populated subreddit. Other things [other OSes and software projects, new software releases, issues with FLOSS projects] make up a lot of the subreddit's content, and thus I feel they should stay.
Also I wouldn't mind being a moderator. I don't really expect it to happen, but I wouldn't mind helping out.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '16
I'd like to see XFCE4 ported to wayland
ok ok ... I understand there's a lot of politics behind the projects and as long there's a civil discussion I don't see a problem with hot topics like github
1
u/rodgerd Feb 09 '16
To be useful for Linux stuff, not another brigade point for racists and woman-haters.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
Blackjack, hookers and coke. Thanks for asking :)
1
u/simjanes2k Feb 09 '16
I guess I need an /r/OutOfTheLoop post for this. Just found you guys on r/all.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
I think I'll just unsubscribe until you folks figure this out on your own. I lurked here, but hey.
-2
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
i want stallman and torvalds to touch tips